And yet most people would miss this one. Thankfully now I have the PC version, I can capture it.

Damn you subtle scares!

Ohhhhhhh mann, that's fucking creepy. The only moment to get me good so far (just started episode three) was the very first image flash when you first go into the cabin. Loud and generally unsettling. Amazing game.

I saw that on my first playthrough and I agree that was scary. I remember going outside to try and find that person but couldn't.

@AssInAss said:

And yet most people would miss this one. Thankfully now I have the PC version, I can capture it.

Damn you subtle scares!

Yup, that one really had me scared at the time.

I never actually noticed this fella. But it sure did look scary from the vid.

Scariest moment in Alan Wake: N/A

Yea, I can honestly say I was largely unaffected in this regard, that didn't stop me from enjoying the game though.

The game made it easy to avoid encounters with the creepies, I remember running through most of the level at the end of the game, while thinking I shouldn't be allowed to do this.