Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb News

144 Comments

Nasty Xbox.com Login Issue Identified, But There’s Good News

Clicking on "Try Demo" could get you more than you asked for.

No Caption Provided

Imagine if you were told something was free, but moments later found out you’d actually been charged $10 for the transaction. It’s an easy situation to imagine for an issue that currently exists at Xbox.com but won't soon enough.

If you’re a frequent user of Microsoft’s Xbox Live service, chances are that when you arrive at Xbox.com, you’re greeted by a dancing Avatar with paid-for clothing you said you’d never, ever buy--but then you saw Rocky stuff.

That’s not always the case, and for many, there’s an equal chance they’re not logged in.

If you don't have enough points in your account, you'll get saved from this story's heartbreak.
If you don't have enough points in your account, you'll get saved from this story's heartbreak.

One of the more popular uses of Xbox.com is queueing up downloads through your phone, iPad or computer. Want to try out the latest Xbox Live Arcade release? Heard about a new game on the Indie Games marketplace? Queue it up, and have the Xbox 360 download it while you’re away. It’s brilliant, easy, and super useful.

Both sections offer free, playable demos, too, and that's where the problem comes in.

If you’re logged out of Xbox.com right now and click on “Try Demo,” of, say, Fruit Ninja Kinect, you’re then presented with a login screen. After typing in your Windows Live ID information, the bubbly Avatar appears. Soon, a pop-up window shows up, displaying a confirmation page to make sure everything's a-okay.

In the process of logging in, however, Xbox.com will mysteriously switch from “Try Demo” to “Buy Game.” One costs money, the other doesn't. It’s reasonable to wonder why one would just click “Confirm Purchase” without careful reading, except that “Confirm Purchase” is the same button that shows up when you want to download a trial version, too. “Confirm Purchase” is the generic term used on the site when approving a download in all cases.

Anyone who’s used to hitting “Confirm Purchase” for both paid and free content on XBL could reasonably click without a moment’s hesitation and suddenly find themselves with 800 (or more) Microsoft Points tossed out the door.

Giant Bomb user itsnottaken first alerted me to the issue, and I was able to verify it for myself. You should be able to make the same issue appear on your own account, and there’s a video captured by itsnottaken, as well.

Fortunately, Xbox.com users won’t have to worry about their aimless clicking for long. I contacted Microsoft about the issue yesterday, and have since been told the web team is working on a solution.

“We are aware of this issue and the team is actively working to resolve it,” said a Microsoft spokesperson over email. “We appreciate your patience and apologize for any inconvenience.”

It’s still an issue for the time being, though, so mind your mouse button.

Patrick Klepek on Google+

144 Comments

Avatar image for milkman
Milkman

19372

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 3

Edited By Milkman

@louiedog said:

@Gibbous said:

God, the writing is just tortuous. Patrick, please take a class.

If you find fault with his writing you should probably explain why. You just come off as an insulting dick otherwise.

Spoiler alert: He can't explain why.

Avatar image for milkman
Milkman

19372

Forum Posts

-1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 3

Edited By Milkman

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Cover up. Your blue is showing.

Seriously, take your fanboy system wars conspiracy theories somewhere else.

Avatar image for rekt_hed
Rekt_Hed

958

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 6

User Lists: 8

Edited By Rekt_Hed

Thanks for the heads up Patrick :) Im always impressed by your comitment to keeping us gamers informed and able to stay clear of potentially losing a ton of money. Kudos duder :)

and forget these trolls that would'nt know news if it walked up to them and smacked them in the face with a massive wooden club.

Avatar image for nephrahim
Nephrahim

1265

Forum Posts

3

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Nephrahim

@TheHT said:

@MideonNViscera said:

For those ripping on Patrick's writing style, it's that he crams as many words into a sentence as possible.

For those of you ripping on Patrick's strangely convoluted methods of writing words on the internet, the problem seems to lie within his desire to continually add needless words where none needed to be placed, actually.

Kinda like how he talks.

Thanks for the heads up, that's kinda fucked.

This is the first article he's written that I actually had trouble reading.

Could have used some editing for sure.

Avatar image for ronald
Ronald

1578

Forum Posts

28

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 8

Edited By Ronald

Nice job, Microsoft.

Avatar image for galacticpunt
GalacticPunt

1512

Forum Posts

4

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By GalacticPunt

I clicked on this story, and it was a halfway-interesting public service announcement, that wasn't sensationalist.

I look at the comments, and they seem to think they're on GiantAssholes.com

Avatar image for rvone
RVonE

5027

Forum Posts

8740

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By RVonE

Content related to Patrick results in excessive bitching and moaning. This is what I've learned (I'm slow, I know). Good job, Giant Bomb community. Good job.

Avatar image for amerist
Amerist

68

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Amerist

@patrickklepek: Ouch, that's not the sort of thing I want in any subscription service that I belong to. Glad to hear that Microsoft is working on fixing it -- I hope they're ready to refund people who accidentally bought it via click. I know that Amazon one-click and other things are nice and convenient, but at least they have a grace period that lets me immediately cancel it. Furthermore, I must opt-in to one-click. ξ

Avatar image for negativecero
NegativeCero

3160

Forum Posts

32

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By NegativeCero

I never use Xbox.com and never put points in my account that I don't need, so I was good. Hopefully people get their money back though.

Avatar image for mideonnviscera
MideonNViscera

2269

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MideonNViscera

@laserbolts said:

@George_Hukas

@AxiomaticParasite said:

"People are losing money due to a Microsoft error? I'd better not mention potential loss of money in the main article header or description or else people might actually be aware of what's going on."

- Patrick Klepek journalism.

Weird, PS3 was being "hacked" was almost just the biggest video game story last year, and virtually nothing was compromised. Two years ago, the XBLA marketplace exploit was discovered, gamers stole millions in DLC, games and content from developers (Bastion had over 100k illegal downloads), and subsequently shared them free with their friends through compromised dummy accounts, yet nobody talked about it.

Do you have a source for this? Never heard of it and the fact that you used bastion as an example and the game wasn't even out 2 years ago makes this extremely hard to believe.

Yeah, I never heard of this shit either. I find it pretty fucking hard to believe it would never come up in any of these endless PS3 vs X-Box(Winner) debates haha

Avatar image for ollyoxenfree
OllyOxenFree

5015

Forum Posts

19

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 9

Edited By OllyOxenFree

@YOUNGLINK said:

Is this story about xbox or patrick? Geez, some of you guys are ruthless.

We're surrounded by assholes!

Avatar image for bitteralmond
BitterAlmond

422

Forum Posts

21

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By BitterAlmond

@Branthog said:

@FritzDude said:

Oh look, It's Patrick writing something about Xbox live again.

Wait, what does that mean? Xbox Live is kind of a big deal. It's not like Patrick is writing a five age dissertation on the artistic merit of an indie game masterpiece about postpartum depression and the joys of woman-hood.

Does anyone else wish this game and the resulting article from Patrick existed?

Avatar image for younglink
YOUNGLINK

641

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By YOUNGLINK

Is this story about xbox or patrick? Geez, some of you guys are ruthless.

Avatar image for laserbolts
laserbolts

5506

Forum Posts

4

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By laserbolts
@George_Hukas

@AxiomaticParasite said:

"People are losing money due to a Microsoft error? I'd better not mention potential loss of money in the main article header or description or else people might actually be aware of what's going on."

- Patrick Klepek journalism.

Weird, PS3 was being "hacked" was almost just the biggest video game story last year, and virtually nothing was compromised. Two years ago, the XBLA marketplace exploit was discovered, gamers stole millions in DLC, games and content from developers (Bastion had over 100k illegal downloads), and subsequently shared them free with their friends through compromised dummy accounts, yet nobody talked about it.

Do you have a source for this? Never heard of it and the fact that you used bastion as an example and the game wasn't even out 2 years ago makes this extremely hard to believe.
Avatar image for gazzum
GaZZuM

489

Forum Posts

139

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By GaZZuM

@AxiomaticParasite: @AxiomaticParasite said:

@GaZZuM said:

Any criticism levelled upon Patrick for writing an article with the express intention of making it so you don't get exploited by a bug that could cost you money, is absolutely ridiculous. Thanks Patrick, these trolls will look for any excuse.

Here's a funny post from someone who didn't actually read any of the criticism. The point is that he's not doing enough to point out the potential loss of money (It's not mentioned in the article header).

I think it's fine for him not to over-sensationalise an issue which sounds like would only happen under very specific circumstances and that Microsoft have already told him they're working on a fix for. An article's headline is meant to draw you in, not to tell you the entire story. If the headline was "Microsoft Screw Users Out Of Money!!!" That would be dishonest to the actual situation, and would, I'm sure, also get alot of flak for sensationalising to get views.

Avatar image for goodkn1ght
GoodKn1ght

522

Forum Posts

45

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By GoodKn1ght

@Branthog said:

@thramp said:

Really great work, Patrick.

Indeed. Why, with those incredible skills to read an email and follow a couple steps on a website to reproduce a simple problem and then write a story about it, he's bound to have that Pulitzer in no time! (Not ragging on Patrick, here. There's just nothing extraordinary about the work that went into this, even though it's interesting.)

Haha I agree. Patrick can do some amazing investigative journalism, this was pretty simple though.

Avatar image for lunar_aura
Lunar_Aura

2824

Forum Posts

17

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By Lunar_Aura

only four pages and most of you guys are already commenting like hi-level dicks gj

Avatar image for sin13
sin13

275

Forum Posts

214

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 11

Edited By sin13

Not a surprising glitch, I feel like I've had that happen before and with other sites as well. Always try to log in first before you start trying to add stuff to carts and making purchases. Also, if you blindly hit a button that says confirm purchase without looking at the the deduction to your account first I don't feel bad for you.

Avatar image for jeanluc
jeanluc

4063

Forum Posts

7939

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 11

User Lists: 13

Edited By jeanluc  Staff

"you’re greeted by a dancing Avatar with paid-for clothing you said you’d never, ever buy--but then you saw Rocky stuff."

You know me so well Patrick. The Jurassic Park John Hammond outfit and cane was really tempting as well.

Avatar image for theht
TheHT

15998

Forum Posts

1562

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 9

Edited By TheHT

@MideonNViscera said:

For those ripping on Patrick's writing style, it's that he crams as many words into a sentence as possible.

For those of you ripping on Patrick's strangely convoluted methods of writing words on the internet, the problem seems to lie within his desire to continually add needless words where none needed to be placed, actually.

Kinda like how he talks.

Thanks for the heads up, that's kinda fucked.

Avatar image for fishstick
Fishstick

164

Forum Posts

6

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

Edited By Fishstick

@mariwells: I hate to tell you this, but your mother earns that money on her back.

Avatar image for curufinwe
Curufinwe

1723

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By Curufinwe

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking.

Just wait. There's no way all these FIFA hacks are just from phishing.

Avatar image for beforet
beforet

3534

Forum Posts

47

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 2

Edited By beforet

@mariwells said:

my classmate's mom makes $76 every hour on the computer. She has been out of work for 5 months but last month her check was $8625 just working on the computer for a few hours. Read more on this site *redacted*

I think this might be the most productive post in this thread.

Avatar image for bourbon_warrior
Bourbon_Warrior

4569

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Bourbon_Warrior

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

What that Xbox.com is flawed and people are losing money?!? why would a Xbox PR "person" write that unless it was a officially statement.

To acknowledge the problem yet try to reassure the userbase that the problem is immediately going away, while at the same time deflecting as much blame away from the responsible company (Microsoft) as possible? That's why a PR person would write that.

I don''t see the problem he got a tipoff from a user, researched the story and got in touch with MS to see what they had to say about said issue, Pretty basic "Journalism" to me, more than most sites do these days.

Go back and actually read my criticisms.

I have and I have stated why you are wrong. Unless you have something to add?

Avatar image for dox
dox

114

Forum Posts

101

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By dox

@Branthog: Yes!

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

What that Xbox.com is flawed and people are losing money?!? why would a Xbox PR "person" write that unless it was a officially statement.

To acknowledge the problem yet try to reassure the userbase that the problem is immediately going away, while at the same time deflecting as much blame away from the responsible company (Microsoft) as possible? That's why a PR person would write that.

I don''t see the problem he got a tipoff from a user, researched the story and got in touch with MS to see what they had to say about said issue, Pretty basic "Journalism" to me, more than most sites do these days.

Go back and actually read my criticisms.

Avatar image for bourbon_warrior
Bourbon_Warrior

4569

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Bourbon_Warrior

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

What that Xbox.com is flawed and people are losing money?!? why would a Xbox PR "person" write that unless it was a officially statement.

To acknowledge the problem yet try to reassure the userbase that the problem is immediately going away, while at the same time deflecting as much blame away from the responsible company (Microsoft) as possible? That's why a PR person would write that.

I don''t see the problem he got a tipoff from a user, researched the story and got in touch with MS to see what they had to say about said issue, Pretty basic "Journalism" to me, more than most sites do these days.

Avatar image for mideonnviscera
MideonNViscera

2269

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MideonNViscera

For those ripping on Patrick's writing style, it's that he crams as many words into a sentence as possible.

For those of you ripping on Patrick's strangely convoluted methods of writing words on the internet, the problem seems to lie within his desire to continually add needless words where none needed to be placed, actually.

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

What that Xbox.com is flawed and people are losing money?!? why would a Xbox PR "person" write that unless it was a officially statement.

To acknowledge the problem yet try to reassure the userbase that the problem is immediately going away, while at the same time deflecting as much blame away from the responsible company (Microsoft) as possible? That's why a PR person would write that.

Avatar image for bourbon_warrior
Bourbon_Warrior

4569

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Bourbon_Warrior

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

What that Xbox.com is flawed and people are losing money?!? why would a Xbox PR "person" write that unless it was an official statement.

Avatar image for mideonnviscera
MideonNViscera

2269

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By MideonNViscera

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Reporting on them fucking people over is a pass? haha Whether he paints the picture prettier or not, the facts are all there and anyone worth existing will form their own opinions from those.

Also, PS3 just sucks more! LOLZ

Avatar image for presidentofjellybeans
PresidentOfJellybeans

348

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

xbox.com has been a mess, at least for me, for months. trying to visit the page results in infinite redirect loops, unless i decide to clear my cookies, again, and even then half the pages i visit encounter an error of some sort. the site is garbage.

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@GaZZuM said:

Any criticism levelled upon Patrick for writing an article with the express intention of making it so you don't get exploited by a bug that could cost you money, is absolutely ridiculous. Thanks Patrick, these trolls will look for any excuse.

Here's a funny post from someone who didn't actually read any of the criticism. The point is that he's not doing enough to point out the potential loss of money (It's not mentioned in the article header).

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

That doesn't change the way that this article feels like something an Xbox PR person would write. It's very weird.

Avatar image for bourbon_warrior
Bourbon_Warrior

4569

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Bourbon_Warrior

@AxiomaticParasite said:

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Your missing the point of my post, I was replying to Ragekage14 who was trying to compare this to the major PS3 hacking last year. This doesn't even compare. So you hit try demo, next screen comes up with "This will cost 800 MSP" points that unless you have more that $10 laying around in your account you would have to add points anyway, by then you should be on to something fishy. I feel this has affected very few people that will more than likely get refunded unless Microsoft decide to go batshit crazy for no reason.

Avatar image for gazzum
GaZZuM

489

Forum Posts

139

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 1

Edited By GaZZuM

Any criticism levelled upon Patrick for writing an article with the express intention of making it so you don't get exploited by a bug that could cost you money, is absolutely ridiculous. Thanks Patrick, these trolls will look for any excuse.

Avatar image for george_hukas
George_Hukas

1319

Forum Posts

3735

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By George_Hukas

@AxiomaticParasite said:

"People are losing money due to a Microsoft error? I'd better not mention potential loss of money in the main article header or description or else people might actually be aware of what's going on."

- Patrick Klepek journalism.

Weird, PS3 was being "hacked" was almost just the biggest video game story last year, and virtually nothing was compromised. Two years ago, the XBLA marketplace exploit was discovered, gamers stole millions in DLC, games and content from developers (Bastion had over 100k illegal downloads), and subsequently shared them free with their friends through compromised dummy accounts, yet nobody talked about it.

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

@Bourbon_Warrior said:

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.

Notice how one section of this article is basically just an advertisement of Xbox.com and how great it is? Notice how the headline doesn't mention any potential loss of money and is only deep within the story? Notice how any mention of a problem is immediately met with "will be fixed soon" or "won't be a problem soon enough"? Notice how he even says that part of the problem is "user's aimless clicking" despite them clicking the button commonly used to download a demo?

This article feels like it was written by an Xbox PR rep, and not an unbiased journalist.

Avatar image for bourbon_warrior
Bourbon_Warrior

4569

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Bourbon_Warrior

@RageKage14 said:

@FreakAche said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Because saying, "Hey! Microsoft is stealing your money" definitely qualifies as a "pass".

He says it so flippantly, wheras if it were PS3 he would be full of rage. Look at the disparity between his stories about Xbox Live getting hacked and PS3 getting hacked. He was like "Meh, Xbox Live possibly got hacked, check your login stuff" and then for PSN he was all "Sony doesn't care about their userbase by letting this happen! What an evil company!"

This headline is "Nasty Xbox Live login issue, but there's good news!", deflecting the severity of what happened within the headline itself. If it were Sony, the headline would probably be "How Sony is stealing your money" or something inflammatory towards Sony.

The difference is the Xbox didn't get hacked, FIFA Ultimate Team has scammers but not hacking. It was more scamming a person to tell user information so they could log in to their ultimate team and steal their coins/players, I play ultimate team and have gotten a few messages saying go to freefifacoins.com to get 1000000 free coins, I usually just file complaint against their account, where as others go to that site and use the same email and password as their Xbox accounts (Stupid I know but not hacking).

PS3 on the other hand got HACKED, the entire user base couldn't get online for a month, I sold mine after the 2nd week and invested in a computer.

So to call out Patrick for being biased on something that really isn't comparable is ironically really just showing how biased you really are.
Avatar image for obscurefan
obscurefan

298

Forum Posts

6511

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 7

Edited By obscurefan

Wheeeeew, thank you for telling me this because odds are I would have fallen for this.

Avatar image for curufinwe
Curufinwe

1723

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 3

Edited By Curufinwe

@jozzy: English is my native language and I found some of the article confusing to read.

They could really do with a good copy editor like Jason Wilson who used to work at GamePro and 1up.

Avatar image for axiomaticparasite
AxiomaticParasite

7

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

"People are losing money due to a Microsoft error? I'd better not mention potential loss of money in the main article header or description or else people might actually be aware of what's going on."

- Patrick Klepek journalism.

Avatar image for cptbedlam
CptBedlam

4612

Forum Posts

7

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By CptBedlam

@RageKage14 said:

@Stubee said:

@RageKage14

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Grow up

Quite an adult reply.

The only possible reply. Stop whining.

Avatar image for wes
Wes

270

Forum Posts

5549

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 3

Edited By Wes

@RageKage14: Cite the damn articles Rage and quit merely responding with dismissive remarks.

Avatar image for ragekage14
RageKage14

72

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By RageKage14

@RVonE said:

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

So this is still a thing? 2012 y'all!

Well, it's still happening, so...

Avatar image for jozzy
jozzy

2053

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By jozzy

@louiedog said:

@Gibbous said:

God, the writing is just tortuous. Patrick, please take a class.

If you find fault with his writing you should probably explain why. You just come off as an insulting dick otherwise.

I have to admit I am not a native english speaker, but I had quite a bit of trouble making sense of the opening paragraphs.

Imagine if you were told something was free, but moments later found out you’d actually been charged $10 for the transaction. It’s an easy situation to imagine for an issue that currently exists at Xbox.com but won't soon enough.

If you’re a frequent user of Microsoft’s Xbox Live service, chances are that when you arrive at Xbox.com, you’re greeted by a dancing Avatar with paid-for clothing you said you’d never, ever buy--but then you saw Rocky stuff.

That’s not always the case, and for many, there’s an equal chance they’re not logged in.

I had to read the "It's easy to imagine" sentence a couple of times to make sense of it. I still don't get what the sentence "That’s not always the case, and for many, there’s an equal chance they’re not logged in." means in this context. Not ripping on Patrick, but I honestly had trouble reading this article.

Avatar image for rvone
RVonE

5027

Forum Posts

8740

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By RVonE

@RageKage14 said:

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

So this is still a thing? 2012 y'all!

Avatar image for vigorousjammer
vigorousjammer

3020

Forum Posts

66164

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 14

User Lists: 41

Edited By vigorousjammer

wait... so what's the good news, then?

Avatar image for ragekage14
RageKage14

72

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By RageKage14

@Stubee said:

@RageKage14

Good thing this didn't happen on PS3, or Patrick would be vehemently tearing into Sony. Microsoft seems to get a pass from him.

Grow up

Quite an adult reply.

Avatar image for 234rqsd2323d2
234r2we232

3175

Forum Posts

2007

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 16

Edited By 234r2we232

Guys. I sent a message to Microsoft on Twitter. This should all be cleared up within the hour.