Something went wrong. Try again later

Giant Bomb News

71 Comments

The Walking Dead's Faces of Death: Part 2

With episode three finally coming out, we continue our conversation with Telltale Games about the design decisions behind episode two's big choices.

[Warning: If you have not finished both episodes of The Walking Dead, you should read no further. Unlike yesterday's entry, however, there are no spoilers related to the comic book.]

If you’re a PlayStation 3 owner, Telltale Games has already made The Walking Dead’s third episode, Long Road Ahead, live for you. Everyone is patiently waiting for the next episode today, unless you’re an iOS user, in which case the second episode (a great one, by the way) is just about ready.

By the time everyone's sat down for
By the time everyone's sat down for "dinner," things have started to go really, really wrong.

Giant Bomb’s embarked on a five-part feature series with Telltale about The Walking Dead, talking through the biggest choices placed in front of players throughout each episode. While we’re explicitly focusing on choices that involve the death of a character influenced by the player and Lee, the actual conversation frequently wanders all over the place, as we talk through the various choices.

I’m joined by project leads Sean Vanaman and Jake Rodkin, in addition to writer Mark Darin, who took writing control of the darker, weirder second episode of The Walking Dead, Starved for Help.

I mean, it involves a bunch of damn cannibals, and if you’re not careful, Clementine eats it (them?) right up!

“Initially, my instinct was having a tally of good points and bad points and these things kind of add up and make people feel a certain way,” he said. “That was completely wrong--we had to go back and restructure it. [laughs] It’s just not a point-based structure. We were just trying to go and sway one or the other or anything, [but] it’s just incredibly dynamic and fluid and changing all the time, and it’s gotta reflect that, and not ever make you feel like you’re being pushed away at the same time.”

There’s more death in episode two, and I’m told episode three is even darker. Who knows what tragic events are in store for episode four, Around Every Corner, which was written by none other than our friend Gary Whitta.

And with that, let’s continue.

GB: While episode one has its own holy shit moments, I definitely think I was in a league of players that was not expecting the leg chopping off at the beginning of episode two.

Vanaman: Really?! I see that leg chop and go “Oh, yeah, yeah.” [laughs]

GB: It’s funny, because I was watching the clips of people playing, and it seems like there’s two things that happen, which results in the stat of 85% chopping off and 15% leaving him to die. You approach that scene, see you have the ability to chop off his leg, and you say “Hell yeah!” and you start chopping away. Or you’re like me, where you tried every other opportunity, and then all of a sudden you just run out of time, which I think is great, especially since the game doesn’t display that. So many other choices in the game have a timer, so you know what you’re working against.

Darin: Yup. [group laughter] We went back and forth for a little while, as to whether we should have an indicator on the screen or not that says you’re closing in. But I think people already had the mindset that there’s a leg, and I’m just gonna go ahead and chop it. I think a timer on the screen would have pushed it even further in that direction. But we wanted people to have that experience, and see who were the people who were going to not want to do that, and how far are they going to take it before they get to the point where they think they’re gonna chop that leg off. It’s fascinating to kind of get into people’s heads by looking at the stats, and see who’s doing that and who’s just going right for the leg. “This is a video game, I know what I need to do, I’m chopping that fucking leg off.”

Rodkin: The best playthroughs are the ones where they’ll get two chops in, and then run out of time.

GB: That’s what happened to me.

Rodkin: “I’m gonna try to wrench open the trap...fuck it, I gotta get that leg off.” And the guy just screams, and then Kenny pulls you off. You leave the guy in the woods with his leg halfway gone.

Vanaman: Ugh. [laughs]

One chop? C'mon. Two chops? Stretching it. Three chops? Sure. Four chops? You're crazy.
One chop? C'mon. Two chops? Stretching it. Three chops? Sure. Four chops? You're crazy.

GB: That was absolutely my playthrough, and my wife was screaming at me “Just mash the button, get the leg off.” Because she knows we must be running out of time, and then, yeah, we got two chops in, but didn’t get the third chop.

Rodkin: Good! I feel like so many things do come down to the details a little bit. I’m pretty sure, and correct me slash don’t include this if I’m wrong, but I think on the leg chop, when the scene first opens up, your reticule is right over the guy’s leg.

Darin: Yeah.

Rodkin: So the the very first thing you see is [whistle] that [scene] opens up and there’s an axe icon.

GB: [laughs]

Rodkin: I think if we had just moved that three inches off, so that it would be equidistant for you to swing it over to the chain and the trap or to the guys leg, and we had to let the player discover for themselves “Oh, I can chop off the guy’s leg, I bet that stat would have swung more equally.” And that’s totally down to a little bit of tuning that I don’t think we had a chance to do on that scene.

GB: How did you decide on three chops?

Vanaman: It’s an adventure game, so you have three of everything. Um.

GB: Miyamoto’s rule of three applies even to chopping off legs.

Vanaman: I’m trying to think. When it comes to Lee’s brother, that’s like four or five chops, right? We can only do four or three chops! [laughs]

Rodkin: In our QA [quality assurance] area, we’ve got a lot of one-legged guys now. We found that it takes three swings, on average, for a guy to use sort of strength and chopping agility slash ability to fully chop a leg.

Vanaman: Yeah, that’s a good point. [pause]

You know, I don’t really know. It’s one of those things where one chop, okay, it feels too much like a band-aid. It’s two chops, and you’re like “Okay, it feels almost supernatural to get through that much.” Then, you go to four chops, and you’re like “Okay, that just goes gratuitous.” Then, you go “Okay, three chops.”

Rodkin: When Nick [Herman, lead cinematic artist] was first putting the team together, he had all these horrible pitches for things like you chop the leg all the way off, and then the guy tries to pull his leg out, but then just this one [piece] is still connected and you go in there and just nick the last little piece off.

Vanaman: Oh, god, I remember that part, yeah.

Rodkin: That didn’t ship.

Vanaman: Did we have obj_bonefragment? I think we do.

Rodkin: I think there is a version where there’s just a little half [piece]. I don’t think we actually shipped with that.

Darin: Remember when the leg was moving and you had to hit it right on the spot? You could hack his leg up and not actually cut through because you weren’t getting it lined up. [laughs] We tried a few things.

Rodkin: Yeah, I dunno. Legs!

GB: The scene after that is with Jolene, and that one has a similar stat flip, where you’ve got only 13% shooting Jolene, and the other 87% tried to put it off and Danny just straight up shoots her. That did seem like a scene that, by design, if you were going to be the person who shot Jolene, you were taking this character down a path that was very intentional. Otherwise, it seemed like the game was sort of guiding you to this moment where, if Danny shoots her, you get the first indication that maybe something is up with these people that you’ve aligned yourself with.

Darin: That was the point where that is supposed to flip the table. During that scene, when Danny shoots Jolene--I still would have liked to do more [to get it] down the middle. There were some things, some ideas that I had for doing that, but we couldn’t make a path for a couple reasons. I still think the scene ended up really good. That stuff with Danny, the table kind of flipping on his character, happens throughout that whole scene, even if you didn’t have him shoot her. I still think it would have ended the same way, with you coming out of that scene, feeling like there’s something not right with these guys.

Vanaman: Because if you shoot her, Danny is like “Woo!”

GB: He even says “Nice shot!”

Vanaman: You’re like “What?!? Whoa, creepy.”

Rodkin: Did you end up shooting her? What’d you do?

GB: No, I just kept having the conversation with her, and let it go. Those tend to be my favorite moments in the series, and it happens twice in episode two, almost back-to-back. I like the timer because it creates a sense of tension, but I like it even more when that timer is happening in the background, and once the scene is finished, you realize how that mechanic worked. I think that’s driven more because I play enough games to understand what mechanics are. I imagine, especially to a player that doesn’t--like my wife, for example--it's a revelation. She doesn’t think about games in that way, so the surprise to her unimaginably bigger.

Vanaman: Yeah, and we implement that on-screen timer bar in situations where it’s reasonable to think that Lee would be able to intuit how much time he has left before something happens. When Danny just ices Jolene, that’s a surprise to the player and it’s a surprise to Lee, so we feel like it would be inappropriate to message to the player how much time is left until something bad happens. That’s the implementation strategy on that one.

Rodkin: If you can perceive that there’s an endgame coming if you don’t act, we put a timer on it.

Vanaman: It’s the difference between me throwing you a football and you know almost how long you have before you have to get underneath it versus throwing it at the back of your head. [laughs]

GB: There’s plenty of surprising moments in both episodes, but the only time I literally shouted “what the fuck” was with Larry. I chose to try and save him. The split there was actually 75/25 in favor of saving him. It’s specifically the way the camera is set up. You’re over him, and then the salt block just fucking shatters his face. Whereas when I watched the way the scene plays out the other way, where you chose to restrain Lilly, you know what’s coming, you know the salt block is coming over, but if you try to save him, that whole sequence is completely out of nowhere. It gives that element of surprise when you think there’s a chance.

Vanaman: It’s so funny. Whenever we kill a character, there’s a lot of talk of “Do we want to put a split here? Do we want to split the content here and bring this character forward?” That happens a lot. We have that talk every single time someone does. Again, with Larry, I felt like I didn’t know how much more interesting story there was to tell with Larry, but it was surely going to be interesting to this woman who’s in your crew if she thinks you helped murder her dad or not. That just felt like “Okay, that is the most interesting thing, so let’s make sure we get out of the scene with that.” Therefore, old Larry’s gotta go. [laughs]

If you chose to try and save Larry and saw the salt lick drop coming, you're a damn psychic.
If you chose to try and save Larry and saw the salt lick drop coming, you're a damn psychic.

GB: He felt like a bit more of a one-dimensional character. He felt like a story tool to push Lee in certain directions.

Vanaman: I thought that’s what I was writing. I really thought I was writing, and then tossing it over to Mark for episode two, and I think Mark put a lot more interesting stuff into Larry in episode two, but I thought I was writing a really one-dimensional character that I knew was going to be this tool in episode two, but there’s so many people in the forums [saying] “I didn’t think Larry was actually that bad of a guy, he’s just an a-hole, and he knew [Lee] was a murderer, so Larry seems decent. Larry just seems like a guy looking out for his daughter, and isn’t going to put up with any shit.”

Rodkin: It was surprising and kind of awesome to read. Like you, I came across a few two or three paragraph long diatribes before we were like “I know Larry is presented as the asshole in this story, but that’s who I’d fucking be in a second, if I was with these fuckers.” [laughs]

Vanaman: I dig that.

Darin: I also think it’s really interesting, watching the playthroughs of people, and they just start off episode two saying “I hate that guy. As soon as I fucking get a chance, I’m gonna kill that guy, I’m gonna kill him.” And then they get to that point and “I can’t kill him! I gotta save him! I gotta do it!” I don’t know why that is, exactly, but I like it.

GB: The conversation just ahead of that with Lilly, where you pull her aside, was important. The dialogue option I chose, at least, was “How do you put up with that asshole?” She goes through this whole little bit about “Well, he’s an asshole, but he’s my dad, and he’s just protecting me.” That is the emotional setup for what probably shifts how the player acts. I still think you would have seen a split where most people, given the choice, are not going to kill this dude, even though he’s a virtual character, but it’s specifically because of that scene that you get Lilly’s perspective on why he’s acting that way. I don’t think you get things spelled out as plainly as you do in that very short conversation, and I think that tilts it. At least it did for me.

Vanaman: That’s awesome. I’m kind of lamenting that it’s over. [laughs] Their relationship was something that was really interesting in general, but especially that opening argument with them in the drug store, I was really happy with the way that turned out. It was put together by a cinematic artist named Graham Ross, and it’s just awesome. I always wanted it to come out that Lilly was this hard ass, but if Larry told her to shut up, she was just going to shrink. I wanted the players to not actually make Larry the villain, but I wanted the way he talked to his daughter and has moments that sort of hint at proooobably some abuse there at some point--probably not a cool dude to grow up with, who-knows-where-the-mom-went sort of thing. She’s still his dad, and I’m glad that came out in episode two.

Rodkin: She’s still his dad.

Vanaman: I’m a little out in the woods. [laughs]

Darin: It was really important for me to put that all throughout episode two. [It] was to give you little glimpses of Larry’s humanity. That one dialogue that you picked really put everything on the table, but you could get through that without picking that, and still see glimpses. There’s little psychological things, like when you’re talking to Mark, and he asks about Larry and you get your dialogue options, you see an option where Lee has the option to say “He’s just looking out for his daughter.” You might not pick that, but it still sticks in your brain, and it still gives you a piece of Larry that you might not have communicated, but it still sticks with you psychologically, and that carries over about Larry’s character. So I wanted to have that stuff layered in, as well.

Vanaman: We use dialogue like that a lot. These are the sorts of things we could say, so they matter, even if you don’t pick them. Implanting them like that is always really important, and so what happens all the time is they’ll think they have learned something from a dialogue choice, and [say] “Well, I picked that.” No, you didn’t, you picked this other thing. “Well, I knew that other thing, too!” [laughs]

Rodkin: When you have the opportunity to kill Danny in the barn with a pitchfork, those stats are overwhelmingly in favor of people of people were just like “Fuck that guy” and stabbed him with a pitchfork. Then, when they get to the next brother out in the yard, the one that you can punch and then throw into a fence, next to no one threw him into an electric fence. Looking at forums, the response was “Oh, I stabbed the shit out of that guy with a pitchfork, and then Clementine was right there, and I saw here see me kill someone, and that made me think twice about doing it to the second guy, I just couldn’t do it.”

GB: You have Lee, who seems to have an aversion to succumbing to this world where you have to kill everyone and fuck everyone else. But those moments, after what those characters have gone through, you want to fuck these guys over. You want to kill them. The atmosphere--the music is pounding, it’s raining outside--it’s a setup for “You shouldn’t feel bad if you want to take these guys out.” For the player to walk away from that feels like an important emotional shift in the story, since it’s a moment where everything becomes very real for the characters and the player. If you choose to go down this path, it’s a wholly different path than if you chose to, say, not kill them. In that case, it’s the harder choice to make.

Vanaman: Yeah. Thanks for pointing that out, actually. That was something we talked about a lot. If you put a crosshair on the screen, somebody’s going to pull the trigger, you know? Games are built around these set-piece moments often times, especially linear third-person action games where it’s like “Yeah, I iced that guy!”

GB: If you put a button prompt on there, people are, by nature, inclined to press the button. If you were to put the situation down on a piece of paper and say “Do you want to kill this guy or not?” they might circle no.

Vanaman: I think some of that stuff came into Lee’s backstory stuff. I think people always say “When’s the shoe gonna drop on his backstory?” That’s coming up, obviously. We didn’t leave that behind totally. But, for me, when we were talking about “Who is this guy? What baggage does he bring to the table when you start playing the game?” I really wanted him to bring an aversion in to having killed before, feeling really bad about it, and spending some time with that to see a) if players would empathize [and] b) if players would adopt that baggage as their own and c) give Lee something to do very physically and emotionally, in idle, before the player is put through a choice where he’s going to kill somebody or not. I’m glad. I feel that’s working a little bit. It feels like it’s another wrinkle of consideration if you’re the player. If you’re an empty shell, sometimes you’re in that sort of gameplay [mindset], where it’s “I’m not making this guy do that, I’m making this shell that I’ve got [do that].”

GB: It’s not just the agency of the player themselves, but it’s also your agency over this character, who has his own backstory. There’s this really interesting tension between what the player thinks is important, but then, at least for some players like myself, not wanting to violate who you think this character is and what they would do, even if your own motivations as a player come into conflict.

Vanaman: Yeah. I think it’s interesting. It’s interesting, the gameplay story of “I met this guy, via the game, and then I sheparded him, and thus me, through a story, really trying to achieve both redemption and, also, corner off a section of morals that worked for me and the character.” On the flip side, it’s saying “I brought Lee to this place that was inside of him and it made him do all these things.” Bad ways is not necessarily the way I’d look at it. You may construe things that some people, like Kenny for instance, feels are not bad or good but necessary. That’s the thing. What is necessary is the bigger question for us when we’re creating situations for Lee. When people come out of their playthroughs, it’s fascinating both ways, and I’m happy about that.

Rodkin: And then there’s the silent Lee, who just stands around and does nothing. [laughs] Who picks the ellipses every single time, it’s the weirdest thing.

Vanaman: Yeah, whatever. That’s really hard to support.

GB: If you can separate yourself at all, how do you think you would have acted, as the player, put into these situations?

Vanaman: You’re the first person to ask that, so congratulations. [laughs] I’ve just been waiting for somebody to ask! I don’t know who I would save with Doug and Carley--it’d be close. It’s easier for me with episode two because I was a little further away. I would have chopped the leg for sure, definitely, and I would have tried to save Larry. It would be really hard to not kill those brothers. It would have been really hard not to kill those brothers. I think I would have killed them. They’re bad people in this fucking world. [laughs]

Rodkin: It’s tough. I definitely would have chopped that leg off, I think. There’s no way I wouldn’t have tried, but when everyone’s eating dinner, and Larry starts giving me shit, I would have definitely have told him to eat the fucking food. [laughs] Did you do that? That’s my favorite thing.

It's up to you whether Clementine and everyone else manages to dig into the pile of human meat.
It's up to you whether Clementine and everyone else manages to dig into the pile of human meat.

GB: No, no. I was busy yelling at Clementine.

Rodkin: There’s one, small path you can go down where you sort of get Larry’s ire up, and he starts [yelling] “You fucking fuck” whatever, and you can just look at him and say “Eat up, Larry.” And he just starts eating the plate of food.

Vanaman: It’s the one time where it pushes the racism aspect of him the most, and he really creeps up on it, and Lee can be just like “You know, dude, eat up. Fuck it.” [laughs]

GB: I gotta go try and find that clip. That sounds awesome.

Rodkin: He’s not happy with you in the meat locker, but I probably still wouldn’t kill him. I still...I got my revenge by making him eat human meat. That’s enough for me.

Marin: I really don’t know for any of these. It’s... [pause, laughs] I know who I am.

GB: Would anyone have picked to save Doug?

Rodkin: Fuck yes.

Vanaman: Hell yeah.

Rodkin: I’d personally save Doug, but that’s because, if I were in Lee’s place. But if I were me, I would save Doug, because I’ve known Doug for, like, 15 years. That’s not a valid [question]!

GB: Oh, I forgot that. Not fair.

Rodkin: Doug is based off of Telltale’s old web designer, who’s also--he does work for us on Idle Thumbs. He does our backend stuff. He’s a dude who’s real. Making that choice is skewed. [laughs] So everyone should save Doug because he’s a nice guy. The people who did save Doug are in the minority, but many of them are very vocal about the support of their choice for saving Doug.

Vanaman: They’re like a family of brothers.

Rodkin: There’s a “Save Doug!” crew.

GB: That was in one of the YouTube videos that I pulled up. In the description, that person wrote this really long “pros” list for Doug, and how you shouldn’t let the fact that she’s a women make it that you have to save her. “Put that out of your mind. Doug is much more resourceful. Just because she’s got a gun? Everybody’s got a gun.” It was really funny how impassioned he was, so Doug definitely has his fans out there.

Rodkin: That was actually Doug’s YouTube playthrough. [group laughs]

Patrick Klepek on Google+

71 Comments

Avatar image for ze_giggler
Ze_Giggler

3

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Ze_Giggler

@crswaites:

Well it's not really a twist if you help Kenny kill him because you make it happen and see it coming because you decide to do it.

Avatar image for auron570
AURON570

1778

Forum Posts

1029

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By AURON570

"And then there's silent Lee..."

LMAO, that made my day

Avatar image for spunkyhepanda
SpunkyHePanda

2312

Forum Posts

29

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 3

User Lists: 2

Edited By SpunkyHePanda

[group laughs] [three-way high-five] [freeze frame] [fade out]

Avatar image for weavminas
weavminas

101

Forum Posts

49

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By weavminas

At this point, Kenny has lost my support and respect. After smashing Larry's head, he shrinks away from the decision he made, whispering "I'm so sorry, It had to be done." The fact that he can't honestly answer to himself what he could do if it was his own family is an annoying weakness. It would be interesting to know if Kenny could choose to save Duck or his wife.

When Denny has the gun to Lee, Kenny just hid in the stall and would've watched Lee die if not for Lilly. He can act to help himself or his family, but he has fallen short on several occasions.

Of course he is just a video game character and who knows what I would do in the same situation, but in the context of the game, He's no hero.

Avatar image for lysergica33
Lysergica33

601

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Lysergica33

I was avoiding this game for a while since it looked like a load of QTE-driven wank to me, but a friend of mine who absolutely loathes anything with zombies in it was positively raving about it to me recently. So, since it was in the steam sale, I picked it up. This game rules, these devs rule, the characters and the writing both fucking rule. Everything about it just fucking RULES.

Also fuck Larry. Totally killed that guy, no questions asked.

Avatar image for hizang
Hizang

9475

Forum Posts

8249

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 22

User Lists: 15

Edited By Hizang

This was a fantastic episode, much better than the first. I didn't see the twist coming, I knew something was up but I didn't realise what was going on until I found Mark. I wanted to save Larry, but that dick threw a salt lick on his head. I really liked him in the first episode and almost always sided with him, but after he killed Larry I realised that I was backing the wrong guy. Even back in the first episode when Kenny didn't help you save Shaun(?) but instead ran away, I still liked him. I agree with Patrick though, I started to understand Larry once I had that private chat with Lilly, where as before I absolutely hated him. I also stabbed that guy with the pitch fork but left the other guy because everybody was watching me.

I can't wait to play the third one tomorrow.

Avatar image for foggen
Foggen

1181

Forum Posts

2010

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By Foggen

I let Carley die because she was dumb as hell. Who doesn't think of batteries? Who puts them in backwards?

Avatar image for sonicboyster
SonicBoyster

508

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By SonicBoyster

@GrandHarrier: This is because you're playing The Walking Dead as a video game instead of a as an interactive story experience. And also because you choose to ignore that there are two episodes left. Did you read the first interview? "Faces of Death part 1." They explain what kind of impact you are afforded in the game. If you're just playing this to feel like a powerful character who makes all the decisions you're in the wrong zombie apocalypse.

Avatar image for nomtank
nomtank

283

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By nomtank

@LarryDavis: I chose the "IT'S PEOPLE!" option for the exact same reason you did. Man was I pissed when Clementine ate Mark...but I promised myself I would never replay or restart a section until I have completed the entire game.

Avatar image for peartnoy
peartnoy

6

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By peartnoy

Look forward to more. Episode 3 was brutal.

Avatar image for seancoughing
SeanCoughing

280

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By SeanCoughing

I chose to yell "its people!" and to my horror clem at a piece, did they think i was kidding? And for whatever reason i decided to stay loyal to kenny and let him smash that dude's head. I felt terrible about it afterwards and actually started to resent kenny as a character after whereas before i felt he and lee were building a good friendship. This game is indeed a revelation for storytelling in video games, and unlike ME3 the choices affect the situations of its own episode and also leaves implications for the overall story.

Avatar image for christilton
christilton

191

Forum Posts

53

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By christilton

@crswaites: I think it was less seeing the twist coming, and more that we already saw this scene in The Book of Eli, a movie written by Gary Whitta, who is a story consultant on this game. The game also gives you strategic options to not reveal everything about your group to the new people, yet the game then later forces you to give up info I was previously withholding and then you are forced to blindly trust these people. What was the point of giving me all these choices if the game is just going to force me to go down a path that any normal person would have seen coming a mile away?

Avatar image for crswaites
crswaites

2

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By crswaites

I'm frustrated with the amount of people I've seen on the Internet who say they "saw the twist coming" in this episode. What, you mean you've seen a horror movie before? Of course you know the twist way before the characters do. 1) It's a horror game. If something seems nice and pleasant, of course it's not going to be. 2) The game drops a LOT of hints, even before the characters start acting creepy. Like, for example, this is a dairy farm with only one cow, yet they've got meat for miles-- even Lee brings this up. 3) Uh, they start acting creepy WAY before anything horrible starts. I mean, the "twist" of episode 2 has nothing to do with the fact that they're cannibals-- this is like saying you saw Alien for the first time and knew that something was going to jump out of that egg and grab on to the guy's face. Of course it was. The movie never gave you any indication that this wasn't the type of movie that would do that. Good horror entertainment will always take you down a path that you expect, give you that payoff you want, and then immediately go way past where you want it to go. The "twist" isn't that they're cannibals-- it's that a character you've, up to this point, trusted, brutally murders a man in a way you never even thought you'd see a man get murdered in a video game. THAT'S the twist. And if you say you saw THAT coming, you're lying. But the cannibal thing, have you never read a horror novel/seen a horror movie/ experienced a scary thing before?

Avatar image for massiveduck
MassiveDuck

207

Forum Posts

61

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 6

Edited By MassiveDuck

I didn't feel like not shooting the second brother was the merciful choice. I didn't want him to get what he wanted in a fast death.

Avatar image for skyfire23
skyfire23

5

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By skyfire23

It's a great read. I love how open they are about the process. Great stuff.

Avatar image for bartz
Bartz

97

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Bartz

@Flacracker said:

At first I stabbed that guy with the pitchfork but then I found out Clementine was there and reloaded. I wish the game would give you all the information before making you make a choice.

The game gives you all the information that Lee has. Lee didn't know that Clementine was watching when he dealt with Danny. You can see the shock and guilt on his face when he discovers that Clem saw what he did.

Avatar image for red
Red

6146

Forum Posts

598

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 5

User Lists: 11

Edited By Red

I saved Doug. Even though I usually go for saving women, Carly rubbed me in the wrong way when dealing with the woman who was bit, and Doug seemed like a really resourceful guy. That, and having his laser pointer save you is way better than Carly's stupid gun.

Avatar image for flasaltine
flasaltine

2547

Forum Posts

739

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By flasaltine

At first I stabbed that guy with the pitchfork but then I found out Clementine was there and reloaded. I wish the game would give you all the information before making you make a choice.

Avatar image for gildermershina
Gildermershina

411

Forum Posts

361

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 5

Edited By Gildermershina

Just like in real life, some of these decisions put me in a spot where I have to pick something that benefits me or satisfies me now, or do something in favour of someone else. Also just like in real life, I tend towards the latter because of anxiety and guilt issues. It gnaws at me, when I do something at the expense of someone else.

So given the choice in the game, I choose not to kill. Given the choice I choose not to steal. In the game most of my decisions are based on protecting Clementine from the horrors of that reality - which in real life would be futile, even dangerous to her. But I don't want the guilt of having let her eat that guy, or seeing me sticking a pitchfork in a dude who probably deserved to have a pitchfork stuck in him forever.

I kind of feel like Rick in the TV show, you know, until he finally fucking snaps. My hope is by the end of these episodes I'll snap too.

Avatar image for probablytuna
probablytuna

5010

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By probablytuna

"I also think it’s really interesting, watching the playthroughs of people, and they just start off episode two saying “I hate that guy. As soon as I fucking get a chance, I’m gonna kill that guy, I’m gonna kill him.” And then they get to that point and “I can’t kill him! I gotta save him! I gotta do it!” I don’t know why that is, exactly, but I like it."

He was pretty much describing me in that paragraph. I just couldn't go through with it, even though I hated him in the first episode.

Avatar image for surferz
surferz

102

Forum Posts

22

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By surferz

Nice read, Thanks, Patrick!

Avatar image for dbene
dbene

169

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By dbene

I see your point concerning Doug.....but one makes the choice at the end of episode 1 and would not KNOW that Doug could reverse engineer stuff like at the fence.

Avatar image for dbene
dbene

169

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By dbene

How could anyone possibly choose Doug over Carley? First off....she knew about Lee being a murderer and didn't tell.....second off she is really hot and seems desperate (her liking of Doug), and thirdly she is the best "gun" in the group in the first two episodes.........I see a comparison between Carly and Andrea on the TV show. The only thing that Doug possibly seemed to have in episode 1 ( I chose Carley ) is some slight technology understanding..

Anyway...just my points.

Avatar image for theht
TheHT

15998

Forum Posts

1562

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 9

Edited By TheHT

Haha, I gotta run a playthrough as the silent protagonist now. I was always planning on it, but now that I know some of the devs don't like it, I gotta see how everyone reacts in-game.

Avatar image for tim_the_corsair
tim_the_corsair

3053

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By tim_the_corsair

I convinced myself I was going to kill Larry after what he did in Episode 1...then when I had the chance in Episode 2 I smoked him, though admittedly with a heavier heart than I expected.

I killed both brothers too and have no regrets beyond Clem seeing it.

Avatar image for hostyl1
hostyl1

87

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By hostyl1

Note: I have *not* played episode 3 so this is not related to anything past eps 1 & 2 and what's in my head.

At some point, I think Lee is going to have to kill Kenny.

A while back, when I was single and childless, a 'Family Man' friend of mine made some, IMO at the time, irrational comment regarding his kids. When I pointed out that he was being irrational, he, surprisingly, agreed but continued to stick by his comment; adding something to the effect of "Parents tend to be irrational regarding their kids". Being now a "Family Man" myself, I now fully understand that concept.

If Kenny is as fleshed out as I think he is, he will do anything for his boy, no matter who it hurts. I initially sided with Kenny as I see a bit of me in him and understand his motives. But I have the feeling that *my* "Lee", who has similar 'parental' tendencies toward Clem, is going to be faced with a Clem v. Kenny/Duck moment. Since I already took Lily's side re: Larry, Kenny's not going to like that much. At some point, that could become a hindrance, and I'll have to off him. Too bad, as getting on his boat seems like a good idea.

Re Ep 2 specifically: Having recently seen Book of Eli the "twist" jumped out at me the moment we hit the farm. If this game really had choice, I would have chosen to follow Lily's advice and just get the dinner "To Go". Funny thing is though, I never went through with breaking into the back room. Again, I pretty much knew what was happening, but I never took all the screws off the lock. Maybe I should revisit that episode and see what was shown there.

Avatar image for ultra2extreme
ultra2extreme

156

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 0

Edited By ultra2extreme

@NickL said:

I saved Doug and for one damn good reason.

THE LADY DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO PUT BATTERIES INTO A RADIO.

SHE IS BEYOND USELESS!

How has everyone ignored that?

She was a girl. My instinct is always to save girls. Logic has little to do with it, nature has everything to do with it. Its the wrong decision but its the one id have made. Doug shouldnt have needed saving, i dont worry about who would save me only who i could save.

Avatar image for julmust
Julmust

1650

Forum Posts

108

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 15

Edited By Julmust

I am really enjoying both the game and this article series. This will probably end up being my GOTY.

@groundbeef said:

Killing off Larry in that scene is like losing your virginity to a prostitute. You want it so bad, but not like this.

Great.

Avatar image for groundbeef
groundbeef

117

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By groundbeef

Killing off Larry in that scene is like losing your virginity to a prostitute. You want it so bad, but not like this. I couldn't wait to hurt Larry after he sucker punched Lee near the end of episode 1. But i wanted to take him out man to man (or at least shoot him while he was looking), not take advantage after he had a heart attack like a coward (Kenny). Like the Duck/Shawn decision, i found this scene lacked a "rational" option, which would have been to have Kenny on standby with the block until you were sure Larry could not be revived. The zombies in this world are the slow "walker" style, so there would have been plenty time to kill zombie Larry while he tried to get on his feet even if he turned.

Avatar image for carlos1408
Carlos1408

1635

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By Carlos1408

This feature is great. I actually purchased the season pass today on Steam (which luckily was 44% off on Steam), and finish both episodes before reading them.

Avatar image for warrenebb
warrenEBB

33

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By warrenEBB

this game is so rad. It seems light years ahead of anything else I've played all year. haven't thought so much about my relationship to the game and my role within the character within the game since the first Portal. I hope it ends up there alongside big budget shooters and such, in the year end awards/lists.

(as for my playthrough experience rant: I usually try to play as the best person I can be, figuring i'll go back later and try the meaner options. but i never go back on any of these game. So I decided Lee was a bad man at the start, and have been purposefully picking the opposite of what I'd do in every dialogue. Which has made it wildly fun. Instead of picking "the right thing" as quickly as possible, I'm actively judging each option to see which best supports the character I'm trying to pull off. And I was often suprised to see my mean spirited attempts backfire. Fun to see how the game/characters won't let Lee be as bad as I'm trying to make him. Like I was trying to alienate Duck's dad, but my conflict with Larry somehow made us buddies. and I was trying to starve the kids, but many of the adults refused my offer of food.

... and somehow the Larry death scene just broke my mind. I can't remember what I chose first. But that was the only scene in the game where I've stopped and gone back and tried every other option. even tried not doing anything. that scenario reallllly got under my skin. in the good way. :)

Avatar image for emtee
emtee

178

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By emtee

When I chose to kill Larry, I didn't even think about how he treated me or anyone else in the past. In my mind, we couldn't take the risk of him dying and coming back as a zombie. There was no way in hell I was going to risk my ass, or any of the other survivors on a possibly slim chance that he'd be okay.

Avatar image for grandharrier
GrandHarrier

189

Forum Posts

1

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By GrandHarrier

After playing Episode 3, this feature is a joke. There isn't any choice in this game at all. You'll all understand when you finish it too. Fuck man. Fuck. I don't think I want to finish the last two episodes.

Avatar image for rsvaret
Rsvaret

53

Forum Posts

2

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 1

Edited By Rsvaret

@DaneGod: Exactly! I did the same thing.

Avatar image for welshcleats
WelshCleats

131

Forum Posts

115

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By WelshCleats

Really, really enjoying this feature. So happy to have Patrick back.

Avatar image for aurahack
aurahack

2561

Forum Posts

44959

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 8

User Lists: 1

Edited By aurahack

I have a lot I'd like to comment on about my own personal playthroughs and how I reflect on my decisions after reading both these stories so far, but that would be so much text. Instead, I'll just say: thank you to both Patrick and Telltale for this series. This is some of the most captivating stuff I've read in a long time.

Avatar image for vaultdweller13
vaultdweller13

123

Forum Posts

492

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 1

User Lists: 4

Edited By vaultdweller13

My wanting to pay homage to Soylent Green by shouting "It's people!" didn't work and Clementine ate the human meat.

Avatar image for terramagi
Terramagi

1167

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Terramagi

I saved Doug, because who the fuck doesn't know how to use batteries.

Zombie apocalypse comes, anybody can shoot a gun. It's the south, guns aren't hard to come by. Conversely, IT guys don't grow on trees down there.

Avatar image for andrewtr
andrewtr

49

Forum Posts

34

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By andrewtr

@NickL:

Didn't think of that, I'm actually really glad that they mention this in the second episode. They address it and she explains that she was in shock or something .

Avatar image for onemanx
OneManX

1728

Forum Posts

50

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 6

Edited By OneManX

I HATED Larry guts... but man.. Fuck Kenny, I would of at least given Lilly a chance to say goodbye, before straight icing him.

Avatar image for danegod
DaneGod

18

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By DaneGod

I'm one of the people who decided to help kill Larry, not because I hated him and just wanted to kill him because he's an asshole. I thought ok we're in this locked meat freezer with this big guy who just had a heart attack and if we can't revive him soon we're all dead. In any zombie movie I'd be screaming at the T.V. "Just kill him you know what's gonna happen if you dont!".

Avatar image for deathbyyeti
deathbyyeti

790

Forum Posts

56

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 4

Edited By deathbyyeti

@NickL said:

I saved Doug and for one damn good reason.

THE LADY DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO PUT BATTERIES INTO A RADIO.

SHE IS BEYOND USELESS!

How has everyone ignored that?

Ive said this before! Carley would be useless as soon as she runs out of ammo. Doug knows electronics and how to reverse engineer things, an example is his curiosity with the fence at the farm

Avatar image for nickl
NickL

2276

Forum Posts

695

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 2

Edited By NickL

I saved Doug and for one damn good reason.

THE LADY DIDN'T KNOW HOW TO PUT BATTERIES INTO A RADIO.

SHE IS BEYOND USELESS!

How has everyone ignored that?

Avatar image for sarx
Sarx

165

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Sarx

Went for the leg instantly because I was so immersed in the scene. Danger felt real so I did not think I had time to check the trap and started hacking.

Avatar image for coafi
Coafi

1520

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Coafi

@patrickklepek said:

@Coafi said:

The thing about Doug is that he doesn't seem to be a really useful character at first, he just deals with electronics. In a world where everything is fucked up and the only instinct that they push at you is your chances of survival. Carley sticks out as the lady with the gun, because in that moment she's the only one with a gun, and with great aim to boot. So, it makes her the more intelligent choice, I don't really think it's because she's a woman. In Ep.2 we see Doug, is a bit more useful than just turning on tvs, when he rigs that alarm system.

It's weird how didn't choose to talk about Mark, who seemed like a really interesting character and got chopped up way too fast, and about the whole situation about stealing the food.

The angle of these stories is ones involving the death of a character, as we don't have time to talk through EVERY decision. Sometimes, other ones come up, and I'm interested in doing a piece once the series is finished about how the other gut-wrenchers rippled throughout, and why Telltale framed them that way.

Thanks for replying, I would be super interested in reading that.

Avatar image for nasseh
nasseh

88

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By nasseh

I also sided with Lily and tried to save Larry, and when Kenny wrecked his whole head I was just repeating the phrase, "What the fuck?" for a solid minute. Fuck Kenny.

Avatar image for patrickklepek
patrickklepek

6835

Forum Posts

1300

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By patrickklepek

@Coafi said:

The thing about Doug is that he doesn't seem to be a really useful character at first, he just deals with electronics. In a world where everything is fucked up and the only instinct that they push at you is your chances of survival. Carley sticks out as the lady with the gun, because in that moment she's the only one with a gun, and with great aim to boot. So, it makes her the more intelligent choice, I don't really think it's because she's a woman. In Ep.2 we see Doug, is a bit more useful than just turning on tvs, when he rigs that alarm system.

It's weird how didn't choose to talk about Mark, who seemed like a really interesting character and got chopped up way too fast, and about the whole situation about stealing the food.

The angle of these stories is ones involving the death of a character, as we don't have time to talk through EVERY decision. Sometimes, other ones come up, and I'm interested in doing a piece once the series is finished about how the other gut-wrenchers rippled throughout, and why Telltale framed them that way.

Avatar image for y2ken
Y2Ken

3308

Forum Posts

82

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 2

User Lists: 28

Edited By Y2Ken

These have been a great read. I will definitely go through these once they're all out, they seem incredibly well constructed.

Avatar image for coafi
Coafi

1520

Forum Posts

0

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 0

User Lists: 0

Edited By Coafi

The thing about Doug is that he doesn't seem to be a really useful character at first, he just deals with electronics. In a world where everything is fucked up and the only instinct that they push at you is your chances of survival. Carley sticks out as the lady with the gun, because in that moment she's the only one with a gun, and with great aim to boot. So, it makes her the more intelligent choice, I don't really think it's because she's a woman. In Ep.2 we see Doug, is a bit more useful than just turning on tvs, when he rigs that alarm system.

It's weird how didn't choose to talk about Mark, who seemed like a really interesting character and got chopped up way too fast, and about the whole situation about stealing the food.

Avatar image for audiobusting
audioBusting

2581

Forum Posts

5644

Wiki Points

0

Followers

Reviews: 4

User Lists: 26

Edited By audioBusting

Aw, no talk on the very last decision? I found that to be the hardest decision to make..