@WalkerD: Let's draw an analogy. If Harley Quinn and Catwoman were African-American, for instance, and the game adopted a similar tone towards them, would it be alright? And before you say it's a false analogy, it's really not. It's just more cloudy with gender relations because they're less visible and unequal power relationships/misogynist representations are more commonly accepted than racism is at present.
You're misconstruing my point. My problem is not with the thugs being sexist (although other characters, such as cops and Batman, also behave in a sexist manner) on their own. I'm saying that the logic of verbally belittling women yet representing them as weak sex objects without much agency is consistent with the logic of sexism and there's evidence that the game does just that. The one-dimensional depiction of Harley Quinn and Catwoman as weak sex objects to either be treated contemptuously or as damsels in distress betrays a male power fantasy that isn't remotely realistic, and whether Vicki Vale and Poison Ivy (lol!) are sexist depictions or not doesn't somehow make the other characters not sexist. Your whole argument is a sequence of non sequiturs and strawmanning of my position. I never said negative depictions shouldn't exist, I'm saying that the negative depiction of women in the game is ALSO sexist. It's not the same thing, and it's a common argument trotted out by people eager to deny the prevalence of sexism.
Just look at this from the article you quoted:
"TO REITERATE: IN THE FIRST HOUR OF ARKHAM CITY WE HAVE A SCANTILLY CLAD HIGH-HEAL-NINJA-ING CATWOMAN GETTING BEATEN BY TWO-FACE AS HE CALLS HER A BITCH. WE HAVE A GROUP OF MUSCLE-BOUND HOODLUMS ALL STANDING AROUND EXCITED TO DUMP HER INTO A VAT OF ACID. BATMAN COMES TO THE RESCUE AS CATWOMAN ESCAPES. SHE FLIRTS WITH HIM MERCILESSLY AND MAKES NOT JUST DUMB, BUT NOT-FUN SEXY PUNS. BATMAN THEN GOES OUTSIDE AND YOU OVERHEAR A BUNCH OF GUYS TALKING ABOUT HOW CATWOMAN AND AGAIN THE WORD BITCH POPS IN. THEY ALL THINK SHE SWINGS BOTH WAYS (CAUSE THAT’S THE KIND OF THING ANY SEXY GIRL MUST BE UP FOR). AND THEN THEY’RE BASICALLY TALKING ABOUT THEIR MASTURBATORY FANTASIES OF HER… YOU KNOW, ABOUT THE SAME ONE THEY WERE CALLING A BITCH. BATMAN THEN GOES OVER TOWARD THE JOKER’S TOWER AND YOU HOPE ALL THIS SHIT IS OVER BUT THEN YOU OVERHEAR A BUNCH OF THUGS TALKING ABOUT HOW HARLEY QUINN IS A DUMB BITCH.
NOW THIS WAS WHERE HULK LEFT IT THE OTHER NIGHT AND TO BE SURE HULK WASN’T JUST REACTING OUT OF MOMENTARY THINGS HULK CAME BACK AND PLAYED A LOT MORE TO BE FAIR… IT DIDN’T GET ANY BETTER.
ACTUALLY IT GOT WORSE. THE FOLLOWING IS STUFF OVERHEARD BY A WIDE CAST OF CHARACTERS THAT INCLUDES PRETTY MUCH EVERYBODY:
“DON’T COME ANY CLOSER OR THIS BITCH GETS A HOLE WHERE HER HEAD USED TO BE!”
“THAT CRAZY BITCH!” (SAID BY A GOOD GUY)
“SHE SCARES ME. FORTUNATELY I SAW THE CRAZY BITCH LEAVING!”
“YOU DON’T FIND THE BOSSES GIRL ATTRACTIVE DO YOU?” / “IN HERE THEY ALL LOOK GOOD.”
“DID YOU HEAR THE NOISE THAT DOCTOR WAS MAKIN?” / (GIGGLE) “I LIKE HEARING HER SCREAM LIKE THAT”
“I DON’T KNOW WHAT JOKER SEES IN THAT CRAZY BITCH”
CATWOMAN NEEDING MORE GADGETS (AND TALKING TO HERSELF): “I NEED MY TOYS. I’D JUST BE (INSERT MARYLIN MONROE VOICE) NAKED WITH OUT THEM (COO).”
“YEAH THE BOSS HAD THE CAT ALL CHAINED UP BUT THAT BITCH BROKE FREE.”
EVEN BATMAN, THE PARAGON OF GOODNESS ASKS HARLEY TO MOVE AT ONE POINT. WHEN SHE DOESN’T, HE SEEMS TO TAKE EERIE DELIGHT IN MANHANDLING HER AND THROWING HER OVER. NOTHING BUSINESS LIKE, THE EMPHASIS IS SO FUCKING WEIRD. BATMAN LIKED IT."
Log in to comment