I've been listening to the GOTY deliberations and a few times now it has been brought up that the crew unanimously thinks that the story of Bioshock Infinite makes all kinds of logical leaps and the story isn't coherent. This really surprised me.
I played through the game in one marathon session and was fairly drunk the second half of it, which sounds like a recipe for not getting a complex story but I thought the story made perfect logical sense in the world of the game. I wasn't confused by anything and I thought the ending was coherent.
What do people not understand?