The only thing I dont like more than people acting like nothing is wrong with a game, is people acting like nothing is right with the game. This game in particular was nothing but SUX OR ROX and its like jesus- get a grip people.
Not so sure. I really liked the game. I didn't find many things at fault with it. The only thing that comes to mind are that the completely optional and often hidden voxophones are crucial to understanding the story. Which is less than ideal. I only found 53 of them on my first playthrough and I missed key parts that explained the Lutece's, Comstock's infertility and so on.
Also, the combat is perfectly fine, but it tries scenario's that do not work with it very well. The encounters with Lady Comstock are the worst. Apparently, they wanted me to use the shield vigor to protect from the attacks her minions did while you lay waste to her. I was out of salts though, not to mention that vigor requires allot of it. I was also playing on hard which made her the biggest bullet soaker I've seen in a while.
After trying to kill the minions and then focusing on her and that strategy not working, I was also very low on ammo. I eventually had to exploit the game's encounter system to stand in a spot where her minions would stay in place, while she periodically seeks me out. That sort off stuff is off putting.