OK, I just bought and completed Braid tonight. What a fantastic escape it was, yet it left me with so many questions. So I turned to Google and found this discussion. Very enlightening stuff! I have, however, come up with my own twist. For most of this point of view, I will be using the epilogue for my basis because I have not yet had the chance to run back through the whole game. Enjoy...
I think the arguments for the atom bomb work the best for me, especially with all the texts in the the epilogue. Plus, you have the ominous billowing smoke in the background. I think there is an overtone as well. Liken the Princess (always capitalized, if I remember correctly) to Mother Nature (again, capitalized) and Tim to Man. The first scene in the epilogue gives you texts of boy calling out to the girl, and him leading the way through the oppression of creatures of smoke and doubt, escaping to a life of freedom. The boy leads the girl through Manhattan (not only the Manhattan Project as already noted, but also a very urbane center of commerce). The girl cries out "you're burdening me with your ridiculous need" (our dependence on resources?), "you're going the wrong way and you're pulling me with you," and "stop yanking on my arm; you're hurting me!" We are hurting the earth... global warming, anyone?
The second scene obviously eludes to scientists. Not the scientists working on the creation of the atom bomb specifically, but classic scientists like Isaac Newton (the fall of the apple). I have no clue what the others mean with the rats and the water-starved monkeys, but they're all attempts to better understand Nature. The hidden text says the boy only knows how to see the outsides of things, which to me says we still don't understand the true beauty of Nature, we only see the superficial.
The third scene is an apparent reference to the atom bomb, but only after scrutinizing the apple and the metal orbs. It has taken us a while, but we have discovered something. The hidden text says she stood tall and majestic, and by that I took it as the mushroom cloud from the bomb. "She radiated fury." Nature's fury. And "she couldn't understand why he chose to flirt so dangerously with the death of the world."
The fourth scene is what clued me into my Mother Nature take in the first place, however weird it may be. A candy store, kids love candy stores. "Everything he wanted was on the opposite side of that pane of glass... He tried to rush for the door, or just get closer to the glass, but he couldn't. She held him back with great strength." To me, that says that man is yearning for Nature's secrets and yet she holds us back with some awesome force. But why? How could he break free... he considered violence. Right here, I thought maybe the boy was looking for democracy, or world peace, or something to that effect. The hidden text sealed the Mother Nature thing for me. "They had been here before... he was too little to know better." It lists the chocolate bar, the magnetic monopole, the It-From-Bit and the Ethical Calculus... "and so many things were deeper inside." She whispers to him, "maybe when you're older, baby." And every day thereafter she would lead him by that candy store.
So Man has grown and has learned some of Nature's secrets, sometimes at grave expenses. I think it's those mistakes which Man wonders if we can ever recover from. And there is the ever-present theme of time manipulation, which man has not been able to figure out. If we could, would we go back and change the irreversible damage we've done to the earth? I haven't seen the end of the game with the stars collected, but I hear the Princess is chained up... have we chained up Mother Nature, have we enslaved the Earth... or is that the overall goal of science?
Log in to comment