I have to go with Orlando. I liked Jonny (wasn't a fan of Toby) but I thought Orlando was the most entertaining. Also, he hangs out with Vincent at Kappa Heaven, which is cool. What about you?

Orlando for sure. Hell, he wins simply by having that douchey-ass hat.
 
Johnny and Toby were bros as well, though.

Orlando. He looks the best, he has the best voice and he has the best opinion towards relationships. Also, he treats Toby like the idiot he is.

I think you're all forgetting something very important.

Orlando, but that's my bias for voice actors talking. Also, white shoes.

Jonny wasn't too bad a bro, either.

I think you're all forgetting something very important.

“I finally became a man! Got rid of my V-card, BOOM,"  

But, uh, Orlando I guess.

 "Sorry, but once that hole is punched, there's no refund!"

Orlando for sure, purely because Liam's voice works so well for him (MAD SEXY)

@mutha3 said:

Orlando for sure. Hell, he wins simply by having that douchey-ass hat.

Oh come on, that hat is for winners. I wanna get me one of those.

@Soren said:

I think you're all forgetting something very important.

“I finally became a man! Got rid of my V-card, BOOM,"  

But, uh, Orlando I guess.

Oh, man, that reminds me of something even better
 

 "Sorry, but once that hole is punched, there's no refund!"

Erica should have been an option.

I'm Vincent drinking buddy.
But if I have to choose it would be Jonny since we both have a lot to say about life. 

Orlando's probably the coolest, but I like Toby the most.

@mutha3 said:

Orlando for sure. Hell, he wins simply by having that douchey-ass hat.

Oh come on, that hat is for winners. I wanna get me one of those.

Orlando is my favorite. Johnny was cool too. Toby was stupid.

Johny was too quiet and Tobias was too much of a little kid. Orlando is just about right.

Loved the character, but am also a huge sucker for Liam O'Brian so Orlando was totally my favourite. Loved Johnny as well, and thought Toby was okay-ish. I preferred the drinking buddies and bar patrons to Catherine and Katherine.

Orlando is cool, im pretty sure the voice actor is the same guy who did Akihiko in P3? im not sure.

I must say the OP's avatar is very appropriate for this subject matter. Orlando or Johnny. 

@Sayishere: Yep, he's Akihiko.

I'm gonna jump on the Orlando bandwagon, though Johnny was pretty cool and Toby was the much needed light-heartedness.

@Sayishere@YI_Orange Wow, I didn't even notice that he's Akihiko. The amount of Persona voice actors in this game is insane.

Out of these three, Orlando.  He's your bathroom bro, after all.  But, frankly, my favorite of all of them may very well have been Erica.

@natetodamax said:

@Sayishere@YI_Orange Wow, I didn't even notice that he's Akihiko. The amount of Persona voice actors in this game is insane.

you should go play Fallout: New Vegas; he's literally like 25 named characters there

Liam O'Brien is an American voice actor and voice director who voices Pacer, Cachino, Jessup, Sergeant McGee, Sergeant Lee, Sergeant Cooper, Major Dhatri, Major Knight, Private Crenshaw, Lieutenant Gorobets, Captain Parker, Poindexter, Comm. Officer Castillo, Comm. Officer Tilden, Comm. Officer Stepinac, Private Kowalski, Private Sexton, Ranger Pason, Private Stone, Lieutenant Markland, Ranger Grant, Alexander, Isaac, Tomas, James Garrett, Ralph, Santiago, Orris, Jacob Hoff, Carlitos, Jerry the Punk, Anders, as well as some minor characters in Fallout: New Vegas.

@Laketown: Aw man, I knew virtually the entire male population of the NCR sounded like him! Thanks for that.

Jonny was cool and someone I would've personally liked to hang around, though, so I'll vote for him!

Orlando of course! he's my bathroom buddy!