I finally decided to do a boss fight with some internet ppl on my guy as opposed to just helping others for humanity
On my playthrough I like to summon an NPC phantom ... just so I know I can do it without the help of RLY OP ppl on my first play through.
Anyway sure enough, they killed Orenstein first and I got Smough's soul and started freaking out, checked my bags and then it hit me... thats why u kill one first not the other, u only get the soul of the one u kill last, is this true? and is there no way to get the other soul at all until NG+? I was really looking forward to the spear... if the hammer is the only thing the other souls is good for I might aswell eat it now coz It is completely useless to me this is a Faith playthrough.
If someone can confirm these two things for sure, would be nice. Let the be an official warning to anyone else