I like the top one the best and the bottom one looks like a soulcaliber game's box art.

I'm pretty sure that the second one is the US art. The third one's the best. 
 
E:Oh wait, the US one might actually be the first one since it has the ESRB rating on it.

3 
2 
1 
4

I'm pretty sure that the second one is the US art. The third one's the best.  E:Oh wait, the US one might actually be the first one since it has the ESRB rating on it.

@BulletproofMonk said:

I'm pretty sure that the second one is the US art. The third one's the best.  E:Oh wait, the US one might actually be the first one since it has the ESRB rating on it.

The ESRB is on the bottom on also

@kingzetta said:

@BulletproofMonk said:

I'm pretty sure that the second one is the US art. The third one's the best.  E:Oh wait, the US one might actually be the first one since it has the ESRB rating on it.

The ESRB is on the bottom one also

You're totally right. Didn't even notice that.

I personally like the first two.

The third one is the best one.

The last one seems to be the version we're getting for both systems in the UK.  No idea why it would have NTSC and the US rating on it though. 
 
My favourite one is the first one, followed closely by the Japanese PS3 cover and then the UK one.

I like the first one the best. Oh wait. That's the US cover? Oh god it's awful! When will publishers learn to stop ruining the amazing Japanese covers with these terrible MS paint imitations?

I'm writing my Senator. I mean, someone is getting a letter over this. I know! I'll start a facebook petition!

I really like the first one and third one.

Second one is my favorite- ugliest one is the US cover.

They all look pretty good, I think I like the top one the best.

The second one is a little plain but is still cool, with a nice colour scheme.

Third one might be a bit too hardcore for me. It seems like it's trying to convey the mood of the game, and does so well, I just like my covers to "pop" a bit more.

The bright blue light in the fourth one kinda goes the other way of being to gaudy, but at least there's no orange in there.

First one is the best, you guys are blind.

I don't think any of them are anything to write home about.

I definitely like the first one. Free of floating heads (depends on your view of what a floating head is, though), explosions and cast get-togethers, but it has a subtle sense of 'danger' to it. And it's also just really pretty. 

last one

First Cover: Yes
Second cover: Well...
Third cover: No. Looks like he's taking a shit
Fourth cover: Yes 

3 is where it's at. 2 and 4 look very dumb.

Unfortunately the ratings sort of give away what comes from where, but I probably would have guessed those anyway. Maybe not the UK one (2).

@FritzDude said:

Third cover: No. Looks like he's taking a shit

Can not UNSEE

See what's stupid (among other things) about the last one is he's walking away from the viewer and into the demons, right? Then why the hell would he have his shield in his right hand and his sword in his left? Anyone who's played Demon's Souls would know that doesn't make sense.

As for the first one, it's better, but that's not how reflections work. They just slapped the image from the second box art onto the helmet and called it a day, while an actual reflection on an uneven reflective surface like that one would not stay intact and perfectly vertical like that.

Second one I find a little generic and not very indicative (presumably) of the game. The Black Knight's just handing you the sword? I don't think he will.

Third one's best for me. As has been said, it illustrates the (again, presumed) feel of the game without intrusion of unnecessary elements. Though, it kind of looks like the dude's shoulder is on fire.

/over-thought opinion

I like the first and third one the best.  Four totally looks like a generic video game cover though, so that's probably what we'll get in the US.

2 
3 
1 
4

3rd

I like the 2nd one and the 4th one.

Third cover: No. Looks like he's taking a shit

I like the top one.

I like the first one the most.

@Rolyatkcinmai said:

I really like the first one and third one.

First one is NA CE, last one is NA regular. The other two are for other regions.

The JP one looks soothing to me, I like it. None of them are terrible as far as box art goes.

None of them are great and none of them are bad, but I prefer the first and last ones.

1
4
3
2

@pornstorestiffi: Cool, looks like I'll be getting the limited edition then.

I know, I know, it's silly.

Still, does anyone know what the Limited Edition gets you?

Edit: Nevermind, I googled it. Seems like you get the game, an artbook, soundtrack, guidebook and a Behind-the-scenes DVD. Neato!

3rd

in north america you are not allowed to have boxart that does not feature a dude with sword or a gun

@pornstorestiffi: Cool, looks like I'll be getting the limited edition then.

I know, I know, it's silly.

Still, does anyone know what the Limited Edition gets you?

First one. Third one is okay. Not a fan of the second or fourth.

@RockmanBionics said:

@pornstorestiffi: Cool, looks like I'll be getting the limited edition then.

I know, I know, it's silly.

Still, does anyone know what the Limited Edition gets you?

@pornstorestiffi: Looked it up myself, but thanks!

I like the 4th box- though I've always liked that kind of electric blue.

Limited looks sweet, although in the UK it's cited as a 'Day 1 Edition' - meaning if you don't buy it the day it's released, you won't get your pre-order AT ALL.  
 
I like the 3rd Cover most, explains the Demon/Dark Souls franchise wonderfully.

I like the third one, it's certainly different than many box arts, and it portrays the isolation theme that is prevalent throughout the game. 
 
EDIT: Why do the japanese get all the good box arts. I hate who designs the box art for North American releases. 

The first looks the best.

Both 360 covers are superior.