I know Vinny was a huge fan of the first game and is on a (temporary?) hiatus from Dark Souls, but I think he should really get back into it. Not only is it a great game, but I'd really like to see it get some real Game of the Year consideration from the Bomb Squad. That means he and all the others need to give it a fair shake. Brad and Patrick have been pretty good about giving it a chance, but Jeff, and especially Ryan, need to drop the attitude and play the game before dismissing it outright. I personally never thought I'd be a fan of the series (and I really probably shouldn't be, considering the gross number of souls I just lost), but I think this game can be enjoyed by anybody if they approach it with the right mindset.
What do you guys think?