If you have criticisms, let me know. 

@Ahmad_Metallic: I can't tell if your being facetious.

@CraigAA said:

   If you have criticisms, let me know. 

No that's ok, the last time (and first time) i criticized a video of yours, in a totally neutral and decent and non-confrontational way, you were a complete sarcastic dick about it, getting worked up like an idiot and talking about whether my argument is valid or not.  It was a sad sight, so just a heads up for people, if you criticize something in this guy's video expect a wall of text full of sarcasm and dickery.

I thought it was great, man! Well produced and offered up tons of info. One thing I'd suggest: Personally, I really liked it when you stopped talking for a bit and would play a bit of music or dialogue from the game. You did it a couple times in the Sound section of your review, but I think I'd be nice punctuation throughout the rest of the video as well. So long as it's not excessive, that is. 
 
I'll definitely be checking out some of your other reviews though! This was a first for me.

I'm repeating my Youtube comment again here, since i would like to know if this was okay with you, prior to me making my own video review -- "Nice review, Craig -- i just bought this game today (it was released in Europe today) and i'm putting together a video review myself. Do you think it's possible for me to upload it as a video response to your review, would that be okay with you? Please do let me know; cheers."
 
Sorry for being intrusive ^^

Great written and video review. Who the hell decided not to recommend it? BLASPHEMY!

As always, a well-made and informative video review :)

Good job!

I'm going to bump this thread for ya. Bump

And since theres a hurricane coming, I'll do my normal one bump now in case I lose power. 

Fantastic as always

Anyone willing to recommend the written version? Petty please with sugar on top?

Some comments:
A "merely memorable character" sounds like a contradiction, to say that a character is memorable is quite strong praise.
Cache is pronounced like "cash" but maybe your pronounciation is a regional thing.
You show a lot of moments from far into the game. I don't think it's a very spoilery review, but it's something to keep in mind.
 
Pretty well produced overall.

To me, there's a big difference between being memorable and being someone I actually care about. I remember who Sarif and Taggart are, but I didn't care about their fates. Malik, on the other hand, I grew to actually like and care about.  
 
I've heard both pronunciations of cache. To the best of my knowledge, both are accepted. 
 
I show moments from far in the game, but they mean nothing out of context. For example, when I'm discussing story and you see Jensen running from machine gun fire, that scene is taken from almost the end of the game. But without knowing the context, it's just an action beat. 
 
Not shitting on your points, just defending mine.

Never had an AI spot me when I was in cover but that may be down to you playing it on 360, I've heard the A.I can be finicky compared to PC, not that the PC versions A.I is great but you get the idea. I urge anyone who can run it to get it on PC over consoles, while I haven't played the console versions the aiming looks very clunky, on the PC firefights felt great (plus quick load times), id often be able to take out a couple of opponents quickly with a silenced pistol, reminicent of Splinter Cell's quick headshot thing (never played it). The graphics really are all over the place, the art direction is fantastic as are the enviroments, certain characters like Adam, Megan and Tong look great but most others don't, it reminded me of Mass Effect where Shepherd and the alien species looked great but the humans looked terrible. Graphically the game feels like an extreamly upgraded PS2 game. Great review btw.

Saw your review before I saw this post. Well written and the video was very professional. Me likey