Favorite Act?

#1 Posted by Seppli (9736 posts) -


#2 Edited by Seppli (9736 posts) -

Love Act III to bits. Has a great driven gameplay narrative. Breathtaking setpieces. Nonstop action. Hordes of Enemies. Mass Slaughter. And the most creepy rendition of hell in a long time. Feelin' the pain of them tortured gimpsuit giants. Dang that's nasty!

#3 Posted by Jackel2072 (2226 posts) -

Hmm i dont know which one was my favorite. But i really liked the level where you had to click on stuff to kill things. im going to vote for that one. 

#4 Posted by StarvingGamer (7558 posts) -

Act II. The bigger emphasis on larger areas is perfect for kiting as my DH. Fucking hate those jumping monkeys though.

#5 Posted by Mr_Skeleton (5117 posts) -

Act II is great (aside from the terrible last quest).

#6 Posted by Irvandus (2643 posts) -

I love Act 2, the setting, the vastness of it, the changing environments, the story. Act 3 comes in close but felt really small compared to Act 2, like watching a season of a tv show after they've had major budget cuts.

#7 Posted by laserbolts (5309 posts) -

Probably the first one. It's the one I liked the look of the most out of them.

#8 Posted by project343 (2807 posts) -

Act II. Most interesting environments with a nice consistent variety. Plus, that was the narrative highlight of the game... a low highlight for sure, but a highlight nonetheless.

Without going into spoilers: the closer I got to red in Act III, the more annoyed and tired of playing I got. I was glad to see that Act IV wasn't just Hell. Otherwise, I'd probably kill someone for the repetitive environments. Figure I should qualify myself as a Hell-hater in nearly every game ever--Dante's Inferno was a slog, to say the least.

#9 Posted by MentalDisruption (1618 posts) -

Act III. I had a lot of fun with it. I like the environments in Act II a little better, but the masses of enemies in Act III wins me over. Act IV would be more of a contender if it didn't feel short and rushed. The idea behind Act IV is cool, but they failed at executing it to its full potential imo. Act I is too much of a tutorial, but that's what its there for I suppose.

#10 Posted by freakin9 (839 posts) -

When I saw the Act II boss I had high hopes for the eventual fight with Diablo... yeah not so much. It was the coolest boss fight, though the start of Act III was pretty neat, though it was the final full fledged act. Honestly I was a little let down overall that they didn't have 2 more acts where they had a similar interesting way to go through the missions like in Act 3.

#11 Posted by Tennmuerti (7720 posts) -

Act 3, because that's where you get hordes of enemies filling your entire screen.

#12 Edited by buft (3298 posts) -

@Seppli said:

Love Act III to bits. Has a great driven gameplay narrative. Breathtaking setpieces. Nonstop action. Hordes of Enemies. Mass Slaughter. And the most creepy rendition of hell in a long time. Feelin' the pain of them tortured gimpsuit giants. Dang that's nasty!

you know i couldnt decide so i read some comments and yours brought back some great memories of that act, another reason its my favorite is the diversity in the environments.

I think the weakest Act comparatively is Act 2, while it has some of the best character moments in the game it feels too collect quest heavy.

Edit: Act 2 does have the best boss fight though.

#13 Posted by happypup70 (167 posts) -

@buft: Yeah Act II boss is the best in the game, He is also my least favorite. Right now he can one shot me with all of his attacks and when I die which I have several times in the past two days I have to fight through his first two stages only to be killed by him when I am clearly not in the green ring of death.

#14 Posted by ShiftyMagician (2128 posts) -

Nothing tops the boss in Act II, so that Act is easily the best one for me. Everything else was visually boring in comparison, including the final boss that was tame in comparison to the Act II boss fight.

#15 Posted by Turambar (6484 posts) -

Act 3 had heart of pestilences, so Act 2.

#16 Posted by PhantomGardener (446 posts) -

Act I.

#17 Posted by Death_Burnout (3767 posts) -

Act III? man I really don't like Act III, it's the antithesis of what I like about dungeon crawlers, It's always on. I can appreciate it was all out war and complete chaos, but that's not my thing.

It's a toss up between Act I and II. Even though Act II has more events and side dungeons Act I takes it over nostalgia. I also like Act 1's quest elements. Perhaps if Act II had something that resembled Lut Gholein music even if it's nowhere Lut Gholein then Act II would take it. I love Lut Gholein.

#18 Posted by buft (3298 posts) -

@happypup70 said:

@buft: Yeah Act II boss is the best in the game, He is also my least favorite. Right now he can one shot me with all of his attacks and when I die which I have several times in the past two days I have to fight through his first two stages only to be killed by him when I am clearly not in the green ring of death.

yeh there is definitely an extra yard or more on those than the animation suggests

#19 Posted by Canteu (2814 posts) -

Probably Act III, mostly due to it being Act IV and Act V of Diablo 2 combined.

#20 Posted by Encephalon (1174 posts) -

Act III. So many dudes.

#21 Edited by TentPole (1858 posts) -

@project343 said:

Act II. Most interesting environments with a nice consistent variety. Plus, that was the narrative highlight of the game... a low highlight for sure, but a highlight nonetheless.

Without going into spoilers: the closer I got to red in Act III, the more annoyed and tired of playing I got. I was glad to see that Act IV wasn't just Hell. Otherwise, I'd probably kill someone for the repetitive environments. Figure I should qualify myself as a Hell-hater in nearly every game ever--Dante's Inferno was a slog, to say the least.

I agree and that is why I think Devil May Cry 3 has the best hell in all of gaming.

Edit: Forgot the 3. Which is kinda important as the hell in 1 sucks.

#22 Posted by HarlechQuinn (438 posts) -

Act I for me, as it resembles the atmosphere of Diablo I & II the most... for me at least... And I just like woods, graveyards and crypts...

#23 Posted by phampire (263 posts) -

act IV for me, fighting demons in heaven was pretty fun.

#24 Posted by kindgineer (2484 posts) -

@Seppli: Act III, only because you literally were fighting an army constantly. It just felt badass taking down gigantic tunnel worms, legions of demons, and the pacing just picked up enough to make it chaotically fun.

Also, does anyone wish that D3 had a swamp Act like in D2?

#25 Posted by Irvandus (2643 posts) -

Wow this poll has had a major shift in leaders over time.

#26 Posted by Panpipe (471 posts) -

Prefer the first 2 acts to the latter 2. For some reason I like hanging out in the desert. Even though those desert wasps are bastards.

#27 Posted by Lazyaza (2136 posts) -

Hard choice to make. I think I had the most fun in Act 4 due to how crazy the games enemy numbers get but story wise I'd have to go with Act 2 and specifically in regards to Kulle. I mean they had to dismember the dood cause he went crazy after figuring out how to store powerful demons in a crystal and he's voiced by good old Steve Blum doing his Starcream voice. So great. You also meet the jeweler there and he's hilarious and the enchantress who makes me feel funny in the pants.

#28 Posted by TaliciaDragonsong (8698 posts) -

Act 2, loved the desert setting.

#29 Posted by Prismatic (56 posts) -

Act 3. The second half isn't too hot but the first is so much fun and actually feels like you're in a war. Act 1 is a real close second as it is consistently fun but no real stand out moments.

#30 Posted by happypup70 (167 posts) -

@buft: Honestly I think some of it has to do with the lag. Often I see my hit points pop out of my head before the animation for the hit happens while fighting Belial.

#31 Posted by pornstorestiffi (4905 posts) -

Tought choice between ACT I and II, but gave the vote to II

#32 Posted by csl316 (7345 posts) -
@Encephalon

Act III. So many dudes.

Yep.

But I kind of liked four, too, just based on the setting (although it gave me a huge Darksiders vibe for some reason).
#33 Posted by SJSchmidt93 (4874 posts) -

The first half of Act III is definitely the high point for me.

#34 Posted by Grimluck343 (1132 posts) -
#35 Posted by MikkaQ (10224 posts) -

Act Ii. The setting was pretty interesting and man... that boss was awesome. The last two bosses felt underwhelming by comparison. Probably the only encounter in normal I had to actually tweak my build to suit the fight.

#36 Posted by Burger_Time (9 posts) -

Act 3 for me. Defending the world against a never-ending demon army? Sign me up.

#37 Posted by JadeGL (609 posts) -

Act IV. I just wish there was more of it.

#38 Posted by Xeirus (1279 posts) -

@freakin9 said:

When I saw the Act II boss I had high hopes for the eventual fight with Diablo... yeah not so much. It was the coolest boss fight, though the start of Act III was pretty neat, though it was the final full fledged act. Honestly I was a little let down overall that they didn't have 2 more acts where they had a similar interesting way to go through the missions like in Act 3.

I see where you're coming from, but keep in mind D2 only had more because of an expansion, so never fear more is on the way!

#39 Posted by Addfwyn (1914 posts) -

A4 is the easiest, and you can plow through it in like 30 minute without even trying, so that's nice. A3 is a lot of fun with a ton of really dense combat situations, but Heralds of Pestilence are dangerous. Lost my first character to a combination of lag and NM champion Heralds of Pestilence.

A2 has wasps, so is instantly the worst act by far. It also seems to consistently take the longest.

#40 Posted by Deathpooky (1340 posts) -

Act 4 had the coolest setting and visuals, but it's incredibly short and even with the shortness still feels padded and pointless at times. Lot of throwing random characters and minibosses at you.

Act 2 has wasps and multiple boring desert and sewer crawls. The bosses were the best. But the wasps. Fuck the wasps.

Act 1 was basically a classic Diablo homage. Got me back into the game, but nothing special.

Act 3 is the winner. Giant sweeping battle against overwhelming armies of hell, taking the fight to them, with you feeling like the badass savior of the whole bunch. The second half was less fun, but that first part was perfect. Wish the game had tried more events that seemed bigger in scope instead of largely being fetch quests.

#41 Posted by mazik765 (2315 posts) -

IV

#42 Posted by valrog (3671 posts) -

Act I. I just love the rendition of Leoric's Manor and the Tristram Cathedral.

#43 Posted by Pinworm45 (4088 posts) -

Act 3. Looks the coolest, and I thought azmodan was the best villain.. at least until I actually fought him. Lamest fight ever, which was disappointing considering how awesome I thought Belial was, and how much of a badass he was in the vivdeo. Also, the end of it gets repetitive. Still think it's the best though.

Then Act 1. Had the best atmosphere and as lazy as it kind of was, it was fun reliving Diablo 1, which I thought was far superior to Diablo 2. Which brings us to..

Act 2. It's kind of dumb that I can forgive act 1 for being a copy of Diablo 1, when I can not forgive Act 2 for being a copy of Diablo 2, but it is what it is. Hated act 2 in diablo, hated the desert setting, and rolled my eyes when I saw Act 2 in this game was a desert setting as well. I hate the enemies, it feels way too long, it feels like lots of busy work (so much go to this level, okay, now go to that level again which is exactly the same, okay NOW you can progress - the aquaducts and the two times that necromancer dude sends you into his library thing for example). Hate this act to the point that when I get to it, that's when I take a week long break from Diablo.

I don't even count act 4. It's too short for me to care one way or another about it.

#44 Posted by benspyda (1893 posts) -

After leveling 3 characters to 60, thus playing through each act over 9 times, I have to go with act I. I always enjoy playing it and I love the look of the areas. Act III is neat but trekking through those dungeons in the castle are so dull and tedious. Same with those heart towers, just go on too long will little change in environment.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.