zombiepie's Dreamfall: The Longest Journey (PC) review

  • Score:
  • zombiepie wrote this review on .
  • 22 out of 23 Giant Bomb users found it helpful.
  • zombiepie has written a total of 3 reviews. The last one was for Osmos

Fall Into A World of Madness


Three is Company

Many games claim to be cinematic or claim to have a movie like quality to them. However very few games come as close to being a movie as Dreamfall: The Longest Journey. While it does not resemble a movie completely, it certainly feels like watching a movie while being in control of the play button. Odd, I know; it certainly is a unique experience. One could compare it to Indigo Prophecy, but experiencing Dreamfall is more like being the viewer, while Indigo Prophecy hands more control to the player, making them feel like the director. It all works in the grand scheme of things in Dreamfall’s favor; in fact the cinematic quality of this video game is what really sets it apart from anything else someone can experience.
 
Right away, Dreamfall mystifies players with a short gameplay session, starring a supporting character as he journeys into an unknown new world. Later it cuts to a bedridden Zoe Castillo, the main protagonist, as she starts to narrate an explanation in the beginning of the game. She explains that she’s a college dropout, and as she describes her life many young adults will begin to relate with her themselves, regardless of gender or race. She is a typical girl that defies all the stereotypes female video game characters have accrued by now, she’s neither a damsel in distress nor a femme fatale; she has merely lost her ambition and direction in life. However, this soon changes after a series of events have her turn into a Nancy Drew of sorts. Zoe finds herself experiencing visions that tell her to “Find April Ryan, save her.” As a result of this Zoe finds herself in a fanciful adventure which for the first time in a long time gives her some direction in her life. Over the course of this journey one will experience multiple perspectives in the form of two other playable characters that further immerses the player in the game world.
 
You Are so Much Cooler Than I Can Ever Explain

To those unaware Dreamfall: The Longest Journey is the sequel to the traditional adventure game The Longest Journey, released in 1999. While Dreamfall isn’t a traditional adventure game in the same vein as The Longest Journey, it still holds up when compared to the latter. However to those select few gamers that are interested in playing Dreamfall but have yet to play The Longest Journey don’t worry, this game is more than accommodating for you. While I do question you prerogative in refusing to play The Longest Journey, not doing so might actually make you relate better to Zoe’s confusion when dealing with what is happening around her.
 
The story is about...well many things, but there is a heavy focus on dualism. In the game there are two worlds: One that represents science and logic, Stark (essentially our world), and the other represents magic, Arcadia. There is a disturbance between/in them; it all somehow relates to Zoe's investigation. There are many characters, and all have secrets and purposes that draw you in, like peeling a deliciously juicy tangerine. Characters can be really pleasant and endearing like Zoe's toy-bot, gorilla thing or they can be as hostile or grotesque like some of the foes you will face during the course of your journey. It is also a nice touch to have Zoe receive candid text messages from friends which range from genuine concern about Zoe’s condition and location to bawdy drunk text messages asking if her breasts are real. It all helps in convincing the player that these are real people caught in an unusual circumstance.
 
The central story is highly metaphorical. It's a complex affair that poses profound questions about the misuses of corporate, governmental, and religious power, and the significant difference between belief and fanaticism and wisdom and intelligence. The story covers many ideals, some with less intrigue and ambiguity than others.  However the story never stops short of being completely engrossing. All of the characters feel and behave realistically (even your bird sidekick Crow). Also the story successfully builds up this feeling of peril and urgency, which utterly convinces the player to act in post haste. Overall the story is the crown accomplishment in this game as it is both metaphorical without being tedious, as well as funny and enjoyable without being annoying or senseless.

The Worlds in Dreamfall are Completely Whimsical
However the textures for this game are a bit washed and blocky to today’s standard but the distinct design saves the look of the game. The game looks good in general mostly because of the aesthetics; environments feel fanciful and support the magical feel and setting of the game. While the characters may animate stiffly, this barely detracts from what they are saying. Which might I add the voice acting is fantastic and well done. Sure the graphics aren’t going to rock your socks off but the environments have a wonderful depth to them that makes them wonderfully immersive and enchanting. When the player goes from one world to the next the look and design is vastly different further creating the sense that one is really exploring an “alien” or “parallel” world.
 
It is good that this game looks nice and has a compelling story since there is not much in the form of interacting with what will surround the player. The game mainly consists of moving a character from one point to another to advance the story; most of the time, you will be doing nothing more than pointing the joystick forward. There is the occasional puzzle or two during backtracks; most of which are a joy to figure out. The better puzzles are the ones that involve sound. Yes, you need to listen! These puzzles are more than unique. There is spoken dialogue and interactive conversations a la Mass Effect, minus the morality consequences. Most decisions do not reflect on other characters, but you do have the choice to be an ass if you so choose. While gallivanting around, you will be treated to a soothing soundtrack reminiscent of Oblivion's, and just like Oblivion the light orchestral score really melds well with the fantasy setting.
 
However the developers also have made an attempt to “modernize” Dreamfall by inserting various action elements in the game. Firstly the player will have to fight numerous enemies that stand in their way, but to put it bluntly these fighting sequences are the worst part of the game.  The player has the option of using heavy or light attacks, but seeing how light attacks can be blocked and completely nullified and heavy attacks cannot one can essentially get through these sequences with merely locking onto foes and rapidly clicking the heavy attack button. Secondly there are multiple stealth sequences, and in a post Assassins Creed and Metal Gear Solid 4 world these sequences feel completely archaic and a throwback to the very first Splinter Cell game.
 
Some of The Places You Will Go to Are Hellish

Yet even with these action sequences and in game puzzles the player interaction in Dreamfall is extremely minimal. And it is the fact that there is very little player interaction in Dreamfall that will dissuade many players from playing it. However for the attentive and patient gamer you’ll almost certainly find yourself compelled by the overall experience.
 
Dreamfall is a pure, relaxing joy to play; one of the few games you can play comfortably laying back. Some may be distraught by the lack of action; others may have a lack the patience to listen to all of the dialogue. However, if you do play it, you will be rewarded by a rich experience that you will not soon forget, because Dreamfall is like a movie worth watching twice to look for those details you missed the first time.
13 Comments
Posted by RHCPfan24

Wasn't that fun?

Posted by floodiastus

I got stuck in the caves with those big guys when you have to search for runes and stuff :( 
 
Awesome game though. Looking forward to their next one

Posted by Tiwi

So is it better than the longest journey?
I've played them both and i want to know what you think.
 
ps. I loved the drunk text also. i laughed for like 5 mins after reading it.

Posted by babblinmule

I never really liked the longest journey because of what they made april into. She was such a nice, pleasant girl in the first game, nothing like the battle hardened depressive she becomes.

Edited by Insectecutor
@tiwi said:

" So is it better than the longest journey? I've played them both and i want to know what you think.  ps. I loved the drunk text also. i laughed for like 5 mins after reading it. "

I think TLG had a better atmosphere and story, but I went back to it recently and got really impatient with the dialog. There seemed to be an awful lot more of it than I remembered, and the pace of the game was really slow. Dreamfall is great the way it descends into darkness as the story progresses. It went from being what I thought was a rather nasty twee sequel into something much deeper and more engaging than I'd ever hoped. I would still say TLG is the better game, but it hasn't aged very well.
 
@babblinmule said:

" I never really liked the longest journey because of what they made april into. She was such a nice, pleasant girl in the first game, nothing like the battle hardened depressive she becomes. "

You mean Dreamfall. The Longest Journey was the first game, Dreamfall was the sequel in which April had become a jaded miserable old bitch.
Posted by ZombiePie
@tiwi: I like both games but for different reasons, but in the end I'll go with The Longest Journey because it felt like a complete experience in the end. 

@babblinmule: The developers made her a failable individual who was never able to quite recover from having a false "destiny" from the last game. She may not have been likeable but she was relateble, I mean if I had gone on a taxing adventure only to find out it was a farce I think I would be at least a little bitter.
Moderator
Posted by Kill

The Longest Journey is one of my favourite games. Dreamfall doesn't even list. I barely remember it.
 
While the Longest Journey is a satisfying, long adventure that ends brilliantly. Dreamfall ends with more questions than it answered. Frankly, it rides off the legacy of the first game. it has no new ideas, the characters are butchered and not the ones I love (April especially) and the gameplay mechanics are boring.

Posted by teh_destroyer

The Dream Fall games were fantastic, I remember playing them on my dads computer several years ago. Its sad to think that the adventure genre is almost dead.

Posted by zyn

The keyboard + mouse controls are crappy.  Better to play this using a controller.

Posted by Ragdrazi
@Kill said:
" The Longest Journey is one of my favourite games. Dreamfall doesn't even list. I barely remember it.  While the Longest Journey is a satisfying, long adventure that ends brilliantly. Dreamfall ends with more questions than it answered. Frankly, it rides off the legacy of the first game. it has no new ideas, the characters are butchered and not the ones I love (April especially) and the gameplay mechanics are boring. "
 
The first game wasn't a game at all. The first game was an interactive storybook that tried occasionally to be a game and failed miserably at each attempt. This time they got  a chance to actually present interactivity on several levels, and while you may have found them boring, I think they were better than them not being there at all. I love the first game as a storybook. I love the second game as a game.
Posted by HAMMERCLAW

Run-and-gunners will avoid this game, the way a lobster avoids boiling water, but if you like playing Myst, and Syberia is your kind of game, you're going to love Dreamfall TLJ.
Posted by ZombiePie
@zyn: And I disagree, not once did the controls seem to get in the way of the game experience.
Moderator
Posted by MajesticOverlord

Talk about being great with words. I'm gonna get myself a copy of the game asap.

Other reviews for Dreamfall: The Longest Journey (PC)

    Presents a new argument of how far story can go in games. 0

    Usually when you pop into some gaming message board, you eventually hit the same “graphics vs. gameplay” argument. Story, for the most part gets left out of the picture. Dreamfall: The Longest Journey makes an outstanding case to present how far story can go in games, going beyond gameplay and graphics to give you an experience that can surpass satisfying the other two sides.  The Longest Journey is back to tell you it's next chapter. Dreamfall for those who don’t know is a sequel to an adventu...

    1 out of 1 found this review helpful.

    An emotional roller coaster ride 0

    Dreamfall: The Longest Journey is set in Arcadia and Stark, two parallel worlds where magic and technology hold the grasp of one world respectively. You begin your journey in Stark - which is sort of like a futuristic version of our world - as Zoë, an unemployed and unmotivated young woman who is stuck at the real-life puzzle most of us get stuck at – and it’s really easy to relate – the one where you’re trying to figure out what to do in your life. So one day, as a favour to her old boyfriend, ...

    0 out of 0 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.