Who Wins Best Media Briefing for E32010

  • 0 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
#1 Posted by evildeadron (830 posts) -
#2 Posted by TurboMan (7393 posts) -

Easy choice. Ubisoft.

#3 Posted by StarFoxA (5138 posts) -

Ubisoft had the most unintentionally hilarious briefing, Nintendo showed the most games that I'm interested in (I have no PS3, and I could care less about Kinect).

#4 Posted by JJOR64 (18904 posts) -

Nintendo hands down.

#5 Posted by WilliamRLBaker (4777 posts) -

who cares? e3 is not a competition.

#6 Posted by evildeadron (830 posts) -

my order would be  
 
1) EA (ten games, no filler) 
2) Nintendo (3ds looks neat, and tons of games announced) 
3) Sony ( Portal 2 on PS3 is pretty big, but where was The Last Gaurdian?) 
4) Microsoft (Kinect? No Thanks) 
5) Ubisoft (wtf?)
#7 Posted by BlueStriped (99 posts) -

Have to give it to Nintendo for showing a lot more new games since that is what matters.

#8 Posted by Terry_Bogard (302 posts) -

Oh crap.. I voted for Microsoft by mistake. I guess it was Nintendo.

#9 Posted by ch13696 (4582 posts) -

I'm going to have to go with Nintendo. I was thinking about Sony at first. But that was because of Twisted Metal and Infamous 2. However, Nintendo brought out a whole new handheld. Proving that 3D can be done without glasses, pictures can be turned into 3D pictures, and you can adjust how you want your 3D. Not only that, Kid Icarus looks pretty bad ass.

#10 Posted by MostlyHeadless (116 posts) -
@WilliamRLBaker said:
" e3 is not a competition. "
You are joking, right?
#11 Posted by canucks23 (1087 posts) -

I can understand why Nintendo's was good, but their stuff just isn't for me. I voted for Sony because they were my personal fave even though the first half was pretty boring. The second half made up for it.

#12 Posted by CharlesAlanRatliff (5374 posts) -

Nintendo easily. Such good pacing with reveal after reveal!

#13 Posted by ricetopher (1046 posts) -

Ugh, more of this shit. If I had to choose, EA.

Hate these threads, can't we just realize we, as people who play games, are the real winners here?

Online
#14 Posted by wfolse1 (455 posts) -

Nintendo, quite obviously.  They brought tons of awesome looking games.

#15 Posted by TooWalrus (13135 posts) -

Nintendo, this year, thoroughly excited for a lot of the things they were showing.

#16 Posted by zyn (2591 posts) -

Nintendo!

#17 Posted by samcotts (2258 posts) -

Nintendo won by a country mile. 
 
Anyone who disagrees is wrong and can suck it.

#18 Posted by SJSchmidt93 (4884 posts) -

Have not watched Ubi's. But Sony. Konami is still to come.

#19 Posted by JJWeatherman (14557 posts) -

You guys are probably going to think I'm just a fanboy, but I was probably the most interested in the Xbox conference. I think the Nintendo one announced better games, but there was something I liked about the Xbox one. Maybe it's that Kinect is the most interesting motion controller of the bunch in my eyes. Plus, Harmonix dancing game! 
 
So yeah, I liked the Microsoft one, but Nintendo realistically was better.

#20 Posted by trophyhunter (5800 posts) -

 on a scale from one to ten I'd give Nintendo a 9 Sony a 8.5 and Microsoft a 5 

#21 Posted by zudthespud (3281 posts) -

I didn't see all of Sony's but what I did see was pretty cool. Microsoft was all about Kinect which is going to flop, and Nintendo was too Epic, if you know what I mean. EA Prolly comes second just for Bulletstorm, and Ubisoft... well meh.

#22 Posted by masterherocard (419 posts) -

I've only read the live blogs. So far, I'm saying nintendo, If only because it seems like everything nintendo ever made is coming to the 3ds.

#23 Posted by Bones8677 (3210 posts) -

Though I liked Nintendo's press event, it was only because the last few years were absolute garbage. So my expectations were rock bottom. I was hoping they'd burn up. But it was overall very well executed. 
 
But I'm gonna have to go with Sony, it had more WTF moments than any of the others. Gabe Newell coming onto stage admitting that he was wrong, has got to be one of the best E3 moments ever.

#24 Posted by Church069 (250 posts) -

Ubisoft wins because their briefing was just bat shit crazy. 
 
In all honesty though I would have to say nintendo won this time.  They had the best conference. Reggie messing up his lines.  Live demo folks situation.  Crazy trailer for the 3DS featuring Iwata, Miyamoto, and Reggie.  Most importantly new games revealed that I'm actually interested in.
#25 Posted by RiotBananas (3600 posts) -
@JJOR64 said:
" Nintendo hands down. "
Your picture is Mario. You're not even allowed to vote! 
 
I won't vote because there wasn't a "None of the above".
#26 Posted by KingBroly (1645 posts) -

Nintendo by a landslide.  Why?  Well, let's see... 
 
Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, Game, 3DS
 
Down the line, flowed really well, lots of enthusiasm, everything you could ask for almost.  Not to mention the plethora of 3DS titles that were shown afterwards.

#27 Posted by ZeForgotten (10397 posts) -

As said by Kevin Butler: Everyone wins  
But Sony just a little bit more because they made me jizz my pants because of Twisted Metal

#28 Posted by Allprox (534 posts) -

I seem to have voted without actually clicking on anything, odd?

#29 Posted by Scrumdidlyumptious (1639 posts) -

Nintendo definitely. If there was less talking and montages in Sony's one, it would be them.

#30 Posted by davidwitten22 (1708 posts) -
@RiotBananas said:
" @JJOR64 said:
" Nintendo hands down. "
Your picture is Mario. You're not even allowed to vote!   
Did you watch the Nintendo press conference? Because it was really well done, and I always blast the Wii and Nintendo. Nintendo hands down.
#31 Posted by RiotBananas (3600 posts) -
@KingBroly said:
"  Not to mention the plethora of 3DS titles that were shown afterwards. "
Oh you mean, Mario and Zelda? I'm not a Nintendo hater but damn do they recycle old shit.
#32 Posted by evildeadron (830 posts) -

di you also notice, no Cammie Dunaway or any Never / Maybe bullshit at Nintendo this year
#33 Posted by kalmis (1558 posts) -

Nintendo hands down

#34 Posted by Lashe (1244 posts) -

Microsoft. I'm growing tired of traditional, or 'hardcore', gaming. I'm hoping the Kinect will be a bit of a breath of fresh air in a sea of horribly derivative games I seem to find myself in. Having said that I doubt they'll push it far enough, but it still excites me the most. 

#35 Posted by Hef (1096 posts) -

Sony cause the new zelda looked like...well zelda.  Donkey Zong was probably the best thing there along with the 3ds.  But infamous 2, killzone 3 footage, sly collection(probably not many people care but i loved those games), Portal 2 on PS3, kevin butler, news on a cheap Move and a kick ass new twisted metal made me very happy indeed.  Maybe if other M and zelda looked good i'd go with nintendo, but golden sun, donkey kong and 3ds just don't hold up again the flood of awesome that was sony's press conference.

#36 Posted by JJOR64 (18904 posts) -
@RiotBananas:   Fun fact about me:  I play my 360 more then my Wii and PS3 combined.  My username is gray for a reason.
#37 Posted by Gruff182 (851 posts) -

Its close between Nintendo and Sony.
 
On the grounds of I have less than no interest in buying anything related to Nintendo, i'l pick Sony.
Nintendo did do well though, for a change.

#38 Posted by CharlesAlanRatliff (5374 posts) -
@JJOR64: Shut up you stupid Nintendo fanboooooy!!!!
#39 Posted by WinterSnowblind (7613 posts) -

As a gamer, I don't see why anyone would consider this a competiton, and reading through these threads it's really easy to spot the fanboys. 

But in terms of putting on a good show, Microsoft easily win.  They showed some great tech, and it was all very entertaining.
In terms of games, Nintendo triumphed, it was a huge turn around for them from the past few years.  The 3DS looks great and their Wii lineup isn't shabby.
And well, Sony had some cool promo videos.

#40 Posted by CaptainObvious (2992 posts) -

Ninty.

#41 Posted by Banjo_ace (118 posts) -

i don't own wii but nintendo did good for once

#42 Posted by WickedCobra03 (2102 posts) -

Easily Sony.  They didn't make total tards of themselves using their motion controls and am mildly interested.  Gabe Newell and Portal 2 on PS3.  Kevin Butler.  A release date for Gran Turismo 5.  Still supporting the good PSP (i.e. not the PSPGo) and awesome PSP commercial with Kevin Butler.  Oh yeah, and Twisted Metal!

#43 Edited by BigChief (503 posts) -

I say Sony. Kevin Butler, Portal 2, Infamous 2, and Dead Space 2? Good stuff. Although in fairness, I didn't catch the entire Nintendo press conference.
 
Edit: Oh! And LittleBigPlanet 2!

Online
#44 Posted by WickedCobra03 (2102 posts) -
@BigChief said:
" I say Sony. Kevin Butler, Portal 2, Infamous 2, and Dead Space 2? Good stuff. Although in fairness, I didn't catch the entire Nintendo press conference.  Edit: Oh! And LittleBigPlanet 2! "
Yeah, Dead Space Collectors edition is a great buy, especially with Dead Space: Extraction now for the Playstation 3.  It was a great game on the Wii that was totally overlooked.
#45 Edited by JauntyHat (323 posts) -

Nintendo, although the first 10-15 minutes were very awkward and unnerving with the clunky Zelda controls and your Wii party debuts, the rest of the show was phenomenal. The only major Nintendo franchise that got left out was Star Fox (and even that was shown on their website afterwards.) What I love about Nintendo games is they actually have a personality to them, and when they're revealed you can get behind them. The games that were shown were games that we as gamers wanted. It wasn't Modern Shooter number 3 or Action Adventure game 2 or some iteration on Tiger Woods' golf.

My issue with Sony's press conference is that it was full of third party video games we have already learned about (EA Day 2!), as well as SEVERAL boring video game montages. Those deserve to be shown over your booths down in the game floor, not taking up 5 minutes a piece of your conference. The best parts of this conference were Kevin Butler's speech, Portal 2 with Gabe, and Twisted Metal. Unfortunately only one of these three is actually (probably) a playstation exclusive.

Quick Edit: Also, if you can announce that games such as Assassin's Creed, Metal Gear Solid, Saints Row and Kingdom Hearts  are coming to a Nintendo console as a SIDE NOTE and still feel pretty confident with your lineup, that is why Nintendo was awesome. 

#46 Edited by MostlyHeadless (116 posts) -

I didn't watch Ubisoft's or EA's conferences so I'll just give my impressions of the Big 3.  
 
1. Nintendo - They seemed to know that a large part of the competition's conferences were going to be chock-full of motion control tech stuff, and they decided to go the other way with it. They just stuck to the games, and it worked. Almost every title gave me a sense of giddy joy that I haven't felt for a while. There was some talk about the 3DS at the end but even there they seemed to focus primarily on the games for the system and less on the system itself. This may be the year I buy a Wii.
 
2. Sony - I was pretty scared that we weren't going to get a lot of exciting game announcements once they started in on the Move segment, but they saved themselves in glorious fashion at the end with a ton of exciting reveals. Also, while I'm still on the fence about the whole motion control fliggin-flaggin, the things they were doing with Move sure gave me hope for some really neat things in the future. I'm not sure if Sorcery really excites me as much as a game as it does as a tech demo for things to come. But it's far more exciting than an on-rails star wars game.
 
3. Microsoft - I had a hard time mustering much enthusiasm for Natal/Kinect/Ultimate flailing challenge 2010. While the tech really is neat, it just doesn't seem that it's capable of anything more than mini-game collections, on-rails games and sports titles (though they can always prove me wrong). The lack of any type of stick or d-pad that can be used as a way to move about the game world seems to really hinder it's ability to do anything interesting. The titles they mentioned early looked great (Dead Space 2, Gears 3, COD, etc). But everyone knew they were happening already and that really deadened the impact they could have had had the developers/Microsoft not jumped the gun with their announcements.

#47 Posted by phrosnite (3518 posts) -

Nintendo of course!

#48 Edited by TheAdmin (711 posts) -

Microsoft Wins. Why? 
 
Kinect - it actually works and works well. I was thoroughly impressed with all the things it can do (voice, tracking, motion, etc)
ESPN on 360 - this is huge news in entertainment (cable companies will lose subscriptions) 
Games - Gears, MGS Rising, Halo, Black Ops. 
 
 
I thought Nintendo did excellent. why? 
No Cammie - Seriously leave your mom at home. 
3DS - looks cool and end of show, try it out thing was a great move  
 
Points off?   
Games - here's where they lose points.  Zelda controls looked janky.   Zelda, Goldeneye, Kirby, DK, Mario sports. New games, yes, but no new IP.  Kirby and DK look fun however. There was just too much "hey, remember X franchise? well here is an update!"
 
Sony did great also. Why? 
Games - Plenty of game trailers and real-time demos 
Kevin Butler - It's nice to see them embrace the marketing thats working and working well 
Move - again, looks great and more precise the wii motion plus. move games look fun  
Portal 2 - this was a hell of an announcement!
 
Points off?  
 PSP - a new marketing strategy is not the answer. They need to update the hardware, give another analog stick, and integrate the PS Network more.  
 
 
At the end of the day - we all win.

#49 Edited by Spoonman671 (4554 posts) -

How did Nintendo win?  Didn't you guys play enough side-scrolling platformers in the 90's?
 
And as for Sony, where the hell was Last Guardian?

#50 Posted by KyleWilms (39 posts) -

Sony all the way!

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.