jaycrockett's Fallout 3 (Xbox 360) review

Tops Oblivion in every way but one.

This game is a phenomenal achievement. Oblivion is my all time favorite RPG, and Fallout is as good or better in almost every way. The graphics are better. The sound is fantastic. I absolutely love the radio stations, both the songs and the DJ's. The voice acting is generally excellent. The VATS combat system is extremely entertaining. Probably a necessary addition to handle guns in Oblivion's engine. The main story is more compelling and personal than Oblivion's. And there are many meaningful moral choices to make.

The only thing that keeps Fallout 3 from surpassing Oblivion is the setting. Not that it doesn't execute on it's post-apocalyptic theme; to the contrary. But it's so well done it's, well depressing. I just don't want to live in this world. All the dark humor fell flat to me because I genuinely felt bad for these people. This doesn't prevent it from being a great game, it is. It's just the difference between a 50 hour game and a 300 hour one. (Yes, I played Oblivion 300 hours.)

The only other quibbles were the oft mentioned inability to play after the main quest, and the fact that my dog ran away right after I got him. (I just told him to get some food and he never came back.)

Edited by Crono

Wow, 300 hours in Oblivion?  What exactly did you do that kept you engaged for that long?  I really enjoyed Oblivion (and this game as well) a LOT but I don't think I could ever even approach that number.  I am surprised you don't have an Oblivion review with that much time invested.

Anyway solid review that is nice and concise.  Although I couldn't disagree more about the radio stations XD personal taste though :)

Edited by jaycrockett


In Oblivion I did the main quest, all four guild quest lines, and all the big DLC. I played two characters, and the second character was designed to never level, so I actually completed the fighters and thieves guild lines at 2nd and 3rd levels. It actually made things easier for the most part. Except that last thieves quest, it's not easy to break into the imperial tower at 2nd level.

Also I play games like this extremely slowly. I read every book, look at every object, try to arrange my loot neatly, etc.

In general I find I can add 25-50% to the time estimates given for game completion. Which is fine, more fun time for me! Unless it's a bad game...

As for an Oblivion review, I guess I could go give it a 5. I don't think I could sum up in words how much I like it. I bought my 360 because of it.

Other reviews for Fallout 3 (Xbox 360)

    My trek through the Capital Wasteland. 0

    After Oblivion, Bethesda’s 2006 hit, the expectations were extremely high for Fallout 3 and the game doesn’t disappoint. Although some fanatics of the original Fallouts may not fully appreciate the move from top-down fully turn-based to a hybrid of the latter and first person shooter , fans of previous Bethesda games will recognise the core movement, navigation and little secrets they have added. In fact there are a huge amount of similarities between this and Oblivion, although instead of wande...

    10 out of 10 found this review helpful.

This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:

Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.

Comment and Save

Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.