I wonder if this is going to stop anyone from playing. While I personally abhor this idea, I can see many people jumping through the necessary hoops.
Want To Play Final Fantasy XIV? Convert Your Dough Into Crysta
Paying per character is a dumb enough move. I don't care if my one character can be any class, because as long as there are multiple races, there are reasons to have multiple characters. Add this payment system to it, and the BS meter is hitting the top of the charts. That and you make a PC MMO that plays better with a freaking controller, and I'm just done. I wasn't planning on buying this before, was taking a cautious wait and see stance, but I'll stick with WoW then.
And of course, the correct answer to the problem is to save the $2 leftover, and 2 out of every 5 months you'd only have to pay $10, but it's still total crap. And you have pennies left over. Fuuuuun.
You also don't have to constantly make a new character to experience something different. I never played WoW for long because (among several other reasons) whenever I got bored of what I was doing, I'd have to start from absolute scratch, and I pretty much said screw that mess.
Complain all you want, but in FFXIV you never actually need another character to do something new, so paying $3 is a luxury in the purest sense. People didn't "let" them do it, they just designed a game where you didn't necessarily have to (though for FFXI it was $1, so the extra storage space was worth it)..
FFXIV is great, and this pricing structure hardly seems any different than stuff like Microsoft points. Yes, it's kinda dumb, but it's something a lot of other businesses do for whatever reason.
I just used a credit card to bypass this system anyway, I don't see what all the hooplah is, except another reason for people who hate everything Japanese to try to hate on this again.
Man, why the hell are MMOs so messed up compared to other games. I know server costs can be kinda crazy, but some games seem to be doing fine online without having to screw you on every possible corner.
My only conclusion is that these games are designed for the insane asian markets that devote their lives and abandon their babies to play the games. Only someone that stupid would be able to get into them anyway.
Wait. So, instead of just letting you pay a flat monthly fee via credit card like everyone else, either just the fee or the fee+ micro-transactions for nonessential but cool extras, or going free-to-play + micro-transactions for nonessential but cool extras, they are instead choosing option C, which is a flat rate, plus an additional monthly fee for essentials in the game, but done through a bizarre moon-money currency system ala Xbox Live Marketplace?
What do you think, Jean-Luc?
At first I thought you ran out of room in the title. Crysta? Dumb.
So, was setting up that playonline account to set up an FFXI account just practice for paying for currency that will pay for our gaming? Psssssh. Listen to me. I almost sound as if I intend to partake in this madness. I'm not even going to try this game.
"One dollar equals 100 Crysta points, the publisher says, but bundles of Crysta have to be purchased in $5, $10, $20, $30, $50, or $100 increments."
That sounds exactly like the Microsoft points system, what with the purchase amounts being purposely not equal to how much you actually need to buy something. At least they're not messing with the ten base system like M$ Banana Dollars does. Still bullshit though.
" this news was out of date before it was posted, I signed up and added a char without even knowing about these points. good job fear mongering "Yeah or how about the misreported wild fire that was the fatigue system. After the director explained how it works, very few sites did a follow up. Now you get the baw of sheep who would never buy this game anyways, complain about it on comments for any FFXIV related "article".
I have to say that I like having left over Crysta as much as I like having leftover Microsoft Points... which is to say, I don't. But that being said, I always end up using all my Microsoft Points and I'll most likely use up all my Crysta as well. Not to mention I can just buy Crysta with PayPal, a company I trust fairly well.
This is the kind of stuff that is going to get them sued. Their goofy account system for FFXI brought them a lawsuit and I can almost guaranty this whole hot dog/hot dog buns way of paying the monthly fee is going to get them in trouble yet again.
I really wonder why they keep doing stuff like this.
I’ve always enjoyed creating loads of alts on MMO’s (hell I even have a bank alt on borderlands) I can’t see that I’m going to stay with one character in FFXIV no matter how much they can do, so I’m not going to fork out extra money just for what I would call standard on almost every other MMO.
Even having a crafting alt would be silly, because it'd just be faster to level that on your main and let your fatigue deplete from your combat classes.
I fully agree that having to go through hoops just to pay for all the fees, etc. is not good, but really, how bad is it that you have to pay $15 a month for a one-character subscription? I mean, take WoW for example. You have to pay $15 there, right? I know that with WoW, you can make a million alts if you want to, but in FFXIV, you shouldn't have to. They way they've been setting this up looks to me as though you really only need one character. As long as you spend time on each of the classes and crafting, you will be able to consistently level up your character, etc. That being said, it'd be kind of a waste to have one character for fighting and one for crafting, because you just wouldn't get the right kind of experience from it - literally and figuratively. So yeah, it's dumb that you have to buy $15 worth of 'Crysta' just to pay for $13 of membership, but if it gets left over and you keep buying a monthly subscription, I don't really see the problem. Personally, I'd be happy to pay it if I were to play this.
Maybe that's just me. :/
I must confess that I know very little about the class and race mechanics for FFXIV, but I thought it was pretty sensible to assume it had different classes, and different races. When I make alts it's so that I can see all there is to see from the game, and get a decent view of all the different ways there are to play the game. If one character in FFXIV can do everything.... then why are there different classes at all?
Besides, I play MMOs with several different people, and I don't like to go running off ahead of everyone else when they aren't around. That takes up 3 of my slots minimum, one to play by myself, one to play with one group of friends, and one to play with another.
It's pretty similar to FFXI if you are familiar with that at all. There are a pretty wide variety of classes (Though a lot of them are crafting/gathering classes right now) that you change by changing your weapon. For example, if you equip a big axe you'll be a marauder. As you play that class, you'll build up your skill with the axe (and thus the marauder class) and unlock new abilities and weapon skills.
If you want to change classes or want to play with a lower level friend, you just switch your weapon. Switch to a staff and you'll be a conjurer, and your skill development is separate from that of your marauder, so you can go back with your friends who just started the game and play with them that way, while developing that class. Unlike FFXI, there's some more multi-classing options, so you can actually take [some] abilities you learned in one class and use it in some others, but you don't have access to every ability of every class at once. Changing weapons changes your class.
The biggest problem I could see for you is if you want to play with your newer friends as the same class that you were already levelling, that may create a problem. But for the most part, you can level every class with one character. There are different classes because there are still different roles, you can just freely change between them. That's why alts are generally unnecessary, unless you really really want to try a different race. Overall, splitting up your time between alts is less ideal than dividing your time on your main between different classes.
Sorry, it may be slightly complicated to somebody not familiar with XI or XIV already, did that explanation help at all?
Yeah that makes sense, interesting way of doing things. I don't go for subscription based MMOs anyway, but if I did I can see how their current pricing model makes sense. However, like you said doing payments per character can easily turn into a PR disaster and turn people off the game before they know anything about it.
w/regard to the points system: its the same damned thing EXACTLY as XBL. Its not sorta like it, it is a copy of the model. How many of you have 20 or 18 or 12 points in your MS points wallet? How many users do you think that is? Whats th install base of Xbox 360?
So lets say each of us on average have a stagnant 18 ms points. Lets say that is about 5 cents. Lets just say the sample group is 1 million users.
1 million users at 5 cents a piece is $500,000 for fucking free.That's what MS is making off of there stupid ass points system. It's cheating and stealing. Its clever manipulation of the market in order to get FREE money from us on a service
we ALREADY FUCKING PAY FOR.
I normally don't swear in posts, but this stuff gets me riled up. And now w/Sony and this game, It really sucks because what is going to happen is people are going to have leftover Shrutebucks and they'll be all "hm, what to do with these duckets?" and sony will come along and be like, "DUDE, we've got this SIIIIIICK red pair of wingtip shoes for your avatar. They are only 20 spacebucks! And they'll somehow spin it as if they are providing an extra service to users because they recognize the "problem" of leftover mangabucks and so they try to play the big corporation who is catering to the needs of users when
THEY MADE TH FUCKING PROBLEM IN THE FIRST PLACE. Knowing full well what they were doing. All I can say is (other than all this other nonsense I just spouted) the game had better be damned amazing.
p.s. What they could do is donate the leftover spacely sprocketdollars to charity. Then I could totally get behind the model.
I remember when my local arcade switched to this system. You bought cards with points on it. Every 1 dollar was like 100 points. But games were like 110 points. I don't even think you could combine cards! This is one of the slimiest business practice since Zanga's reward points.
" People in a FFXIV forum, getting mad about FFXIV.It's also a news story on the site, making it far more visible than any other thread in the FFXIV forum. If the responses really bother you that much, well, you know where the door is.
If you don't like it, the door is thaddaway... "
"...now w/Sony and this game, It really sucks because what is going to happen is people are going to have leftover Shrutebucks and they'll be all "hm, what to do with these duckets?" and sony will come along and be like, "DUDE, we've got this SIIIIIICK red pair of wingtip shoes for your avatar...."What exactly does Sony have to do with this?
There are, at the moment, no in-game microtransactions you could use these on.
Also, you CAN pay for the game with just a credit card, I have. The hooplah over this story is misleading, this [admittedly weird] system is more just replacing gamecard type payments for people who don't want to use a CC.
Again, YOU CAN JUST USE CREDIT CARD. I hate typing in all caps like an idiot, but it can't be stated enough that this story is just misleading.
" @Babylonian: thats why he wrote "convert". "Which do you think is more likely: that I straight up cannot read, or that I was poking a little gentle fun at Brad "Shoemarker" Nicholson for a pretty egregious headline typo that was fixed by the time you saw it?
Despite the crysta thing (which isnt news worthy imo becasue you can just use a CC anyways) the game is pretty good so far, its a VERY nice change of pace from WoW which i always go back but in 2 months am sick of it again. I can see myself playing FF14 for awhile and im glad its not just a reskined clone of other MMOs.
This edit will also create new pages on Giant Bomb for:Beware, you are proposing to add brand new pages to the wiki along with your edits. Make sure this is what you intended. This will likely increase the time it takes for your changes to go live.
Comment and Save
Until you earn 1000 points all your submissions need to be vetted by other Giant Bomb users. This process takes no more than a few hours and we'll send you an email once approved.