#1 Posted by Jedted (2672 posts) -

They haven't had too many british dudes on the bombcast, and the ones they have had are mostly developers. Anyone else like to hear him have a discussion with the GB crew?

#2 Posted by Animasta (14824 posts) -

god no

(also technically he is a developer)

#3 Posted by Phatmac (5921 posts) -

They haven't had any real interaction before so no.

#4 Posted by MariachiMacabre (7097 posts) -

No thanks. Vastly different type of reviewer. His reviews are as much entertainment as information.

#5 Posted by Tim_the_Corsair (3053 posts) -

He's also her in Australia last I heard, so that would probably add some difficulty.

Mayhaps he'll wind up on a podcast if they come out here for PAX?

#6 Posted by Nightriff (6476 posts) -

No....I like his videos but I wouldn't want to hear him talk with the GB crew for a whole Bombcast

#7 Posted by InfiniteGeass (2143 posts) -

Just put Gary Whitta on the podcast.

#8 Posted by Little_Socrates (5834 posts) -

I'd listen to it if Croshaw didn't show up "in character" and just had a regular Bombcast conversation. But I'm certainly not clamoring for it.

#9 Posted by Gamer_152 (14300 posts) -

I love Yahtzee and would really enjoy hearing him on the Bombcast, but I doubt that is gonna happen.

Moderator
#10 Posted by Indiana_Jenkins (410 posts) -

E3 2013.

After Alex Rigopulos, no one is off the table for an E3 podcast.

#11 Posted by two_socks (265 posts) -

Where's the Seanbaby collab?

#12 Posted by impartialgecko (1768 posts) -

I like Yahtzee, but he's at his best when he's behind the production of his videos. I doubt whether he'd be nearly as entertaining without his script. Anyway him and the GB crew are very different types of reviewers, he wouldn't get along with Patrick for one.

#13 Posted by CaLe (4319 posts) -

Let's have TotalBiscuit and the Yogscast on as well while we're at it.

Online
#14 Posted by MikeGosot (3235 posts) -
@adam1808 said:

I like Yahtzee, but he's at his best when he's behind the production of his videos. I doubt whether he'd be nearly as entertaining without his script. Anyway him and the GB crew are very different types of reviewers, he wouldn't get along with Patrick for one.

Now i want Yahtzee in it just to hear him and Patrick debating.
#15 Posted by ArbitraryWater (12904 posts) -

This is an idea that does not appeal to me in the slightest.

#16 Posted by pyromagnestir (4386 posts) -

I'd listen to it. But then I listen to every bombcast so that isn't saying much. But I'm sure he'd be fine. As an aside, anyone else think the quality of his video's dropped significantly when he stopped picking songs relevant to the game and instead got a proper theme song? The songs really added something extra, for me. Now I just mute the theme until the talking starts.

#17 Posted by Tim_the_Corsair (3053 posts) -
@MariachiMacabre
No thanks. Vastly different type of reviewer. His reviews are as much entertainment as information.
He actually has done a lot of "straight" writing before his Yahtzee thing took off.

He wrote (writes?) for Hyper and PC Powerplay in Australia (prominent magazines when magazines were actually prominent) for several years in a relatively straight role. He's also a pretty nice dude based upon my singular meeting with him many years ago.
#18 Posted by fuzzybunny566 (471 posts) -

@two_socks said:

Where's the Seanbaby collab?

sometime between Racketboy and HuguesJohnson

#19 Edited by LaszloKovacs (1272 posts) -

No thanks.

If he were to appear as himself instead of his "Yahtzee" persona, I might be interested, but I doubt that would happen. I doubt that's what Yahtzee fans want from him anyway.

#20 Posted by LTSmash (709 posts) -

No guests and add two hours.

#21 Posted by Shaka999 (541 posts) -

@two_socks: Oh my god yes.

#22 Posted by ajamafalous (12515 posts) -
@LTSmash said:

No guests and add two hours.

#23 Posted by Jrinswand (1745 posts) -

Absolutely not. I got enough of Mr. Yahtzee like 3 years ago, when his shit was still relevant.

#24 Posted by ToTheNines (1122 posts) -

The people that say no to this idea are laughable, the people that think this could happen are even more laughable.

If this does happen someday, I'll pour ketchup all over this post and eat it.

#25 Edited by believer258 (12977 posts) -

Nah, I don't think so. Besides, Ryan is enough of an asshole to go around.

...

...

...that didn't come out quite right.

(Sidenote: I should probably mention that I do not, in fact, dislike Ryan. He's awesome.)

EDIT: All right, I feel I should give a serious-faced answer. Look, I really like the Bombcast, and I really like Yatzhee, but they would go together about as well as gravy biscuits and bananas. Yatzhee has said before that, while his schtick is for entertainment, he also doesn't express opinions that he doesn't have. They may be exaggerated, but he doesn't seem to think along the same lines as the Bomb crew, not even close, and I think they'd walk away from that podcast slightly annoyed at each other. I just wouldn't bet on it being a good mix.

#26 Posted by bartok (2663 posts) -

That guy is still around bitching about how old obscure computer games are better then the games of today?

#27 Posted by MariachiMacabre (7097 posts) -
@Tim_the_Corsair
@MariachiMacabre
No thanks. Vastly different type of reviewer. His reviews are as much entertainment as information.
He actually has done a lot of "straight" writing before his Yahtzee thing took off.

He wrote (writes?) for Hyper and PC Powerplay in Australia (prominent magazines when magazines were actually prominent) for several years in a relatively straight role. He's also a pretty nice dude based upon my singular meeting with him many years ago.
If that's true then I would actually maybe enjoy hearing the discourse between him and the crew.
#28 Posted by ThePickle (4272 posts) -

They've never spoken about him ever. Also he sucks.

#29 Posted by Turambar (7262 posts) -
@MariachiMacabre said:
No thanks. Vastly different type of reviewer. His reviews are as much entertainment as information.
So very little of both?  I kid, I kid.
 
But seriously, I doubt someone is going to fly out from Australia just to appear on a podcast.
#30 Posted by DocPorpoise (143 posts) -

it has potential to be interesting. has there ever been any mention by a GB dude about him, veiled or otherwise?

#31 Posted by Rowr (5862 posts) -

im not sure how that would "gel"

Giantbomb crew are ridiculously American.

#32 Posted by D_W (1409 posts) -

Yahtzee is a bit strange, as he doesn't like to be referred to by his "real" name for whatever reason. Having him on one of the E3 podcast would be interesting as he's actually fairly laid back outside of Zero Punctuation and has a sense of humor not altogether dissimilar than the Bomb Squads (go check out his LPs on the youtube. They're pretty damn funny in an almost ER way. Though the commentary and game play are recorded separate.)
 
Personally I'd rather see him and the Game Station crew do something together.

#33 Posted by kerikxi (575 posts) -

@two_socks said:

Where's the Seanbaby collab?

Goddamnit, yes.

#34 Posted by Video_Game_King (36566 posts) -

@Animasta said:

god no

Something about this feels...not right.

@Animasta said:

GOD NO

That's better.

#35 Posted by Milkman (18021 posts) -

No. He's terrible.

#36 Posted by MEATBALL (4036 posts) -

Please god no.

#37 Posted by Dalai (7793 posts) -

He should be in every Bombcast, but I haven't listened to the Bombcast in a few years so I'm in favor of it clearly to piss off a lot of you.

#38 Posted by CornBREDX (6758 posts) -

This would be my shortest response if not for this starting sentence. 
No. Thank you for coming. 
 
@Dalai: This though I am ok with. =)

#39 Edited by SathingtonWaltz (2167 posts) -

Er.. no. Maybe I'm biased because I've met the guy in person but I really don't care for much of anything he ever has to say. I don't even know how he can say that gaming is his hobby when he doesn't even enjoy 90% of the games he actually plays.

#40 Posted by Jace (1136 posts) -

@Animasta said:

god no

(also technically he is a developer)

this forever.

#41 Posted by AndrewB (7782 posts) -

They have a Brittish dude on every week. His name is Brad.

Also, of the very few people I might like to see guesting on the Bombcast, sure, Ben Croshaw would be one.

#42 Posted by bchampnd (111 posts) -

I wouldn't mind if Yahtzee made a guest appearance on a Bombcast but I'm not sure how well it would go. Real time discussion and debate is a very different format from what he usually does. There are some strong personalities on the Bombcast so I could see certain crew members jumping all over something he says without giving him a chance to defend his point. I'm not saying they shouldn't call him out on things - because that's part of what makes the crew great is that they are quick to point out bullshit - but I'd just worry that the force and tone with which they do so might end any meaningful dialogue. If the crew is in a light-hearted, joking around mood it could be great. If they're feeling snippy, it could be a disaster.

#43 Posted by Fattony12000 (7969 posts) -
#44 Posted by Tylea002 (2382 posts) -

@Gamer_152 said:

I love Yahtzee and would really enjoy hearing him on the Bombcast, but I doubt that is gonna happen.

This.

#45 Posted by nintendoeats (6144 posts) -

Part of me says hell no, and part of me is dreadfully curious about what that would look like.

#46 Posted by RockyRaccoon37 (475 posts) -