@Animasta said:
@Sargus said:
@Animasta said:
@Sargus: they're "demands" mean nothing though. Sure, using demand instead of request certainly gives them an air of entitlement, but they're "demands" are nothing more than requests, because that's all they can realistically do.
would using request instead of demand suddenly make it ok?
No, it would just be a slightly more polite way of making a completely ridiculous wish. I'm not going to "request" the ending of To Kill a Mockingbird be changed. It's an idiotic notion. I completely understand the disappointment in the ending and the speaking out against it... But there are no do-overs.
It's funny... I wonder how many people who "request" a different ending to Mass Effect are the same people who throw huge fits every time Lucas changes something in Star Wars. He gets tons and tons of crap for even the smallest changes because it's well-known that you're not supposed to go back and tinker with an existing story. It's bad form and never works out well. Yet people want Bioware to rewrite the ending to the trilogy they've been building for years. It just makes no sense.
fallout 3's ending was a "do-over" actually! You know, the OTHER big western RPG developer?
and they want to rewrite it because they think it's garbage and it can be easily put back in, where a movie cannot.
Fallout 3's change was nowhere near as dramatic as what would have to be changed for ME3, though. Moreover, that change was driven much more for the desire to make the game have NO ending - I.E., make it open-ended to allow for more DLC. And if you ask me, they shouldn't have even done that.
And endings in movies can be changed, you just don't see it because it's a horrible idea. Again, look at Star Wars. The changed ending isn't as drastic as making characters who died live or anything, but Lucas changed the music for the end of RotJ, then put young Anakin as a ghost (which, narratively speaking, actually makes NO sense. If someone watches the original trilogy before the prequels, now, they're going to be confused because they have no idea who Hayden Christensen is. They've never seen him before). Those changes could be seen as "minor," yet nobody in their right mind thinks making those changes was a good idea. Lucas could have gone further and tacked on some new footage that hints at the Emperor having clones or something, thus giving a "new" ending, but that would be even worse.
But even with Star Wars, that's the creator of the story making changes to HIS story. That's a stupid idea, totally, but it would be even worse for fans to dictate what changes are made. It's not their story, it's his. It doesn't matter how much fans think the prequels are garbage - they don't have a right to either request or demand the prequels be changed. They can ignore them, sure. Whatever. But they will always exist.
Log in to comment