Man, I did not see that coming. I figured that with Ryan having played (and loved the shit out of) Saints Row: The Third he would've been gung-ho about it from the opening bell. His late-game heel turn was more shocking than Skyrim not having a single quest line as good as Dark Brotherhood.
So now that the Deliberations are over, and we have a clear winner in Skyrim, what did you guys think of the Day Five bombcast? I'm still taking it all in, personally. From Vinny eventually throwing his hands up and walking away to Ryan's turn, to Jeff fighting tooth and nail to the bitter end. Great debate this year, I think.