I also want to play Rule of Rose because I remember there being some controversy. Also I wound up with the soundtrack at one point and it's really good. Would be nice to have the context to go with it some day.
Bloodrayne gets a bad rap but they did some pretty cool things for the time. I don't know how it holds up now but I always think about trying them again. Bloodrayne 2, at least, has lots of great slow-mo death scenes and -- oh man, I just remembered -- an insane ending scene.