Please play Chrono Trigger. It is the best video game ever made. And to anyone who disagrees with that statement: do not let me find out where you live, because I will take a shit on your front porch in the middle of the night.
EDIT: I'm kidding of course, but seriously, I see from your list that you don't really prefer the "Japanese" style role-playing game, or RPGs in general for that matter, which is perfectly fine. To each their own. But IMO Chrono Trigger is a story told in game format that should not be missed. There are no random encounters, if those are a turn-off for you. The amount of content they were able to put on a SNES cart is baffling. The music is almost universally heralded as some of the best ever, and the characters you meet within the story you actually care about. This is a rare gem from back when video games were video games. If it ever comes to Steam and you promise to give a whole-hearted effort to play through it, I will buy it and gift it to you.