I asked for your opinions and you turned out in droves.
Here are the results (GameSpot and GiantBomb combined):
Beyond Good & Evil (PS2) - 7 Votes
Metal Gear Solid 2: Substance (PS2) - 6 VotesStretch Panic (PS2) - 3 Votes
Jak II (PS2) - 2 Votes
Sega Superstars Tennis (360) - 1 Vote
I'm so proud of you all. You picked one of the two games I most wanted to play from that list. I'll get started tonight and let you know what I think in the very near future.