Log in or sign up to comment
11 Comments
Posted by emergency

@Catolf said:

@emergency said:

Johnny talks about being in love with friends girlfriend in the nightmares. In one of the endings its revealed that it was Katherine.

i was planning to play the end to learn that on my own, i only wanting to talk about the two endings shown here... -_-

@the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG: I just figure things were coming to a head and being together five years she'd want something more, so I could see where she was coming from.

Sorry, you did pose it as a question in your text. I presumed you were looking for someone to answer it.

Edited by Catolf
@emergency said:

Johnny talks about being in love with friends girlfriend in the nightmares. In one of the endings its revealed that it was Katherine.

i was planning to play the end to learn that on my own, i only wanting to talk about the two endings shown here... -_-
 
@the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG: I just figure things were coming to a head and being together five years she'd want something more, so I could see where she was coming from.
Posted by emergency

Johnny talks about being in love with friends girlfriend in the nightmares. In one of the endings its revealed that it was Katherine.

Posted by the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG
@Catolf: yeah that makes sense because i imagine that there would be a reason why Vincent was attracted to her
 
@mutha3: i guess i thought she was bitchy because she never said "i love you" even though she kept implying she wanted to marry him. 
Edited by mutha3
@the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG said:

i never got why Vincent wanted to be with Katherine.  she just seemed like a bitch throughout the whole game.  maybe she was a good girlfriend before the game began but i will never know...  i

I don't think Katherine is as much a bitch as Vincent is a loser. She's pushy and bossy, but she also genuinely cares for him and looks after his sorry ass. Besides, its implied multiple time that part of the reason both are attracted to each other is because of that aspect of their relationship. 
 
Part of Vincent enjoys being bossed around, and part of Katherine enjoys controlling the guy.

@Lucifer

said:

I have only gotten true cheaters ending and i loved it aswell. But I honestly felt that it made no sense in context to the story and Vincent character development, especially after the whole escort mission and the scene after that .

Same here.
 
The game honestly plays them as joke endings anyways. But really, it makes the whole "dating sim" expectation people had from the game even more funny-- the game doesn't even have a serious ending for Catherine with a C.
 
.....But it does highlight how pointless the choice system in Catherine is. I like the concept behind it, and I like how it isn't a dumb bioware good/evil split, but the story really has been written in a specific direction and the input from the player just works against it at every possible turn.
 
Its not that big of a deal since the same can be said of any game with "moral choices", but I think it worked against Catherine in this case.
Posted by Catolf
@RaikohBlade said:
I agree, the lovers ending was pretty cliche. I found it to be kinda boring, except for the part with Erica. The cheaters ending was more exciting, not to mention funnier.
yeah that was about how I felt. It was okay and yay wedding but.. unno i never thought Vincent's ideal was to be married, he just got pushed towards it with her when he didn't want too.
 
@the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG said:
i never got why Vincent wanted to be with Katherine.  she just seemed like a bitch throughout the whole game.  maybe she was a good girlfriend before the game began but i will never know...  i like how they didnt kill off the Boss and he had bandages on his face.  i think i liked the true lovers ending because it showed Katherine's unbitchy side?  and it was just a nice ending where everyone was happy so i think i liked it better

yeah she was hella bitchy, but it seemed before that, they got along pretty well, especially with the pictures you get on the 8th day from the back log. But her clock was ticking and didn't want to goof around with Vincent anymore i suppose.
 
@valrog said:
I really wish this would come out on PC. But I suppose it will never happen...

I think someone found out that Catherine might have once been looked at as a PC game but they changed their minds, but who know's if the popularity is enough they might port it?
 
@Lucifer said:
I have only gotten true cheaters ending and i loved it aswell. But I honestly felt that it made no sense in context to the story and Vincent character development, especially after the whole escort mission and the scene after that . I also played the whole game answering completely honestly to what i felt and got a total maxed out chaos bar pretty quick. Does that make me a bad person? Though i guess it makes sense hehe.

Yeah, it seemed out of place, but he did love her and then she broke it off all suddenly due tot he cheating thing, he could have even said it just to get her back, we all know we say whatever someone wants to hear so they won't take off on you in a sense.
 
XD I tried to answer honestly and went into chaos as well when i was going for K's true ending, so I had to say what the game wanted to hear out of me lol. It dosen't make you a bad person, as they said there is no right answer, it's just how you feel. Going along with Vincent's speech that people arn't so simple, you can't just define them.
Posted by Lucifer

I have only gotten true cheaters ending and i loved it aswell. But I honestly felt that it made no sense in context to the story and Vincent character development, especially after the whole escort mission and the scene after that .
 
I also played the whole game answering completely honestly to what i felt and got a total maxed out chaos bar pretty quick. Does that make me a bad person? Though i guess it makes sense hehe.

Posted by valrog

I really wish this would come out on PC. But I suppose it will never happen...

Posted by the_OFFICIAL_jAPanese_teaBAG

i never got why Vincent wanted to be with Katherine.  she just seemed like a bitch throughout the whole game.  maybe she was a good girlfriend before the game began but i will never know...  i like how they didnt kill off the Boss and he had bandages on his face.  i think i liked the true lovers ending because it showed Katherine's unbitchy side?  and it was just a nice ending where everyone was happy so i think i liked it better

Posted by RaikohBlade

I agree, the lovers ending was pretty cliche. I found it to be kinda boring, except for the part with Erica. The cheaters ending was more exciting, not to mention funnier.

Posted by Catolf

 
Thats what it is. I figure I can do a blog to express what I thought of the game as a whole as I go through the various endings on the long road to maybe one year.. or ten down the road of getting this platinum. Considering my Hype for this game so far, I figure it was obvious I would try (most likely fail) but i will try.
 
As I step back and look on this game as a whole I would sit and agree I thought the best part about the game was the story as a whole. The worst is the block climbing, but, I say worst in the fact that I'm not very good at it, and I don't have the patience of a saint. I get frustrated easy and I tend to rage quit at times only to come back five minutes later. XD But no, the block puzzeling was not the highlight of this game, but in the end i felt really damn smart when i finally figured it out. Then again I had to redo them to get golds and the cycle starts over my my rage quitting and so forth, I endured, I have all Normal golds grabbed..
 
I should have been done with this game at least five days ago, I guess i'm a glutton for punishment. SPANK ME CATHERINE IMMA BAD GURL~
 
I'll be talking about game endings but I WILL be covering them with spoiler boxes so people can just open the one that got and read my thoughts on that and I avoid spoiling others. I wish this was the way the spoilers were done in the Catherine threads but they weren't.. Ah well right?
 

Katherine: True lovers End.

 
 All the while an Okay ending. But.. a little Cliche..
 

Catherine: True Cheaters End

 

 
Needless to say so far this is my favorite ending. Hands down. I guess I need to get two more endings to talk about.. I'll get to work ont hat!