Either most of you like motion controlled shovelware or your blinded by the fact double fine is making it. This is going to be crap. Kinect is awful. The only redeeming thing about it is dance central. And if you say other wise, try to convince me that going 9 feet back and waving like a crazy person is easier and more convenient than using a controller.
Nobody expects this to be awesome. Anyone expressing excitement over it probably listened to the discussion about it on the Bombcast -- it's just a stupid thing. It's a product that revels in the stupidity and ineptitude of the Kinect. Nobody expects it to be good, they expect it to be entertaining.