Torchlight 2 definitely, Diablo 3 didn't really satiate my loot cravings. Honestly I found Borderlands kind of boring. The world, the characters, the story, none of it was enough to keep me engaged. On top of that the shooting always felt static and awkward.
I'll wait for reviews on Borderlands 2 and see how much they changed.
Borderlands 2 first, because I've just been looking forward to it more than Torchlight 2. But I will play torchlight 2 eventually. It's pretty cheap, so the money's not an issue and I moderately enjoyed the first Torchlight (even if it was so easy I could almost play it with my eyes closed).
Borderlands 2 then Torchlight when/if it's discounted around the Christmas sales. I got lucky and got the Borderlands 2 DLC pack for cheap yesterday due to a pricing error, so feeling pretty good about that. Too bad I'm a lonely no-friender who will play it alone in my loneliness filled existence, alone.
I do not care for Borderlands 2, i do not care for D3 anymore and Torchlight was alright i guess.
I may give a shot to Torchlight 2 eventually.
I still don't get these people who are excited for Torchlight II. Torchlight was pretty mediocre, and while the sequel finally added multiplayer, Borderlands 2 or Diablo III seem like the obviously better lootfest game, if that's what you're into.
D3 is a terrible lootfest game because of the absence of loot. Itemization and drop rate are so terrible that you can play dozens of hours at a time without getting anything worthwhile for you or even good enough to try and sell at the AH.
When I saw Torchlight was being released the same day as Borderlands 2, I laughed. Feels like an awfully poor decision, but I guess they need to get it out stat before Summer ends.
I'll be playing Borderlands 2, and... if it's anything near as good as I'm hoping, I'll be playing that for quite some time to come :)
Maybe Torchlight 2 later.