Can you decide what your favorite game of all time is?

Resident Evil 4.

15 years, give or take.

No, but I've always found the "What's the best/worse X" discussions pretty useless.

It's easier to name top 5 or something, but I don't think anything will top Final Fantasy VII. Halo 2 is closely on second spot.

Favourite game of all time, and favourite game right now tend to be different.

My game of all time is Diablo II - but as it was just after the expansion, with a big online community that for the most part, was fun to play with.

Yes, Skies of Arcadia Legends. (SotC, Metroid Prime and Persona 3: FES are not that far behind though.)

I started playing games before I entered school, so ~ 21-22 years.

Yeah, it's The Secret of Monkey Island. I've been gaming on and off (mostly on) for 25 years now.

Yeah, it's The Secret of Monkey Island. I've been gaming on and off (mostly on) for 25 years now.

Been gaming 24-25 years, and goodness... I'd honestly say Chrono Trigger or Castlevania: Symphony of the Night. Seriously, I could toss a coin on those two.

Super Mario Bros 3, easy. And I've been gaming for over 20 years.

Final Fantasy VI. Which is weird because it used to be a Link to the Past in the SNES days up until Ocarina of time took over it. Zelda is still my fav series. But FFVI's story and adventure holds the greatest memories to me.

P3 FES, hands-down.

• Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater
• 21 - 22 Years

Metroid Prime, but it's closely contested by several other titles. Whenever I really get down to brass tacks and think about it, though, it's the OG Metroid Prime.

Also, ~15 years.

Earthbound.

Been gaming for 23-25 years, I guess.

I've been gaming for 25ish years and I have no hesitation at all in saying Deus Ex

Ask me for 2 - 10 and I'll struggle

Gamer for 15 years.

My fave forever will be Mass Effect.

Same. P3 FES, nearly 17 years.

Super Mario World, because it's the best vidya gaem.

Persona 4 because its just perfect!

about 16 years

I have been playing games for about 18 years and it's pretty hard to pick my favorite game of all time. If I'm looking at the time spent in a single game, then CS:S should be my favorite game with maybe ~5000 hours under my belt. But I think open world games are my favorite genre of games so I have to pick between Morrowind and Oblivion. Skyrim is pretty good too, but I think I loved Oblivion more when it came out that I can say it's my favorite game.

Yes Lufia II: Rise of the Sinistrals, gaming for around 22 years also yes that pick is full of childhood memories.

No.

It would be a list that includes the likes of: Super Mario World, Starcraft, Street Fighter 2, Dragon Quest 8 and God of War 1.

Over 20 years of gaming...

No, but it only flits between a handful of games. Currently I would put forward Super Mario World but that's mainly due to recently replaying it with my partner. And I am about 34 years deep into this habit - dang.

Yes, XCOM 2. I have been playing games for 25 years.

I have a lot of favorites, but they can suffer from 'I'm not in the mood for that right now', whereas I can practically always boot up XCOM 2 and love it. It's not just certain periods like I have with Mass Effect. In fact, pretty much every game I play nowadays, once I am done with it, I go back to XCOM 2 for a playthrough before I play something else.

@demoskinos

Yes, 25 years and Ninja Gaiden Black.

This is an outstanding answer. It used to be my answer.

The Legend of Zelda: Link to the Past

Resident evil 4, or psychonauts

25ish years.

Okami.

Super Mario Galaxy. That game had a pure joy that has yet to be topped.

Around 16 years.

The Witcher 3 for me. Still amazed at how deep the story and characters were and how much there is to do and both DLC packs were fantastic in their own right.

Around 30ish years.

Been playing video games since i was 5 or 6 and will be 34 in December, and favorite game of all time is Dark Souls. Before Dark Souls came out it was Castlevania: Symphony of the Night

Psychonauts.

20 years.

I probably posted elsewhere in this topic years ago, but it's still Super Mario World. Symphony of the Night comes close but Mario World is something I can always play and have a great time. And 27 years.

Kind of? I can say with confidence it's Persona 4, RE4, or Super Mario World. It's definitely one of those three. Depending on what day you ask me though my answer of which one will change.

My faborite game of all time came out in 1999 and has been my favorote game ever since. Nothing will ever topple it from number 1. EverQuest.

Between Crysis, Max Payne 1, Witcher 1, and ST.A.L.K.E.R SoC, I can easily choose Max Payne, because unlike the other games, I can play it every year (while the others are 2-3 playthrough kinda games and that's it for me, they become memories).

So, Max Payne.

Nope, can't decide which game is my favorite. But I also can't decide which movie is my favorite. I can tell a couple of them I enjoy but that's mostly it, I don't really have a ranking. However, I can decide which music or music album is my favorite.

I've been playing games for maybe 18 years.

Yes. Final Fantasy 7.

~ 25 years

Nah. Some games, and the experiences I had with them, are simply incomparable, so my games rankings fall into tiers, moreso than individual ranks.

Half Life 2

~ 22 years

I'm 25 and it is still Okami.

Looks like I voted "No" in this thread 4 years ago.

Today I would vote "Yes" because it is The Witcher 3, and is likely to remain so until it is potentially usurped.

This got bumped by spam.