The darkness was pretty good. Haven't read the comics though, but most people that I've seen talk about the game think it's better than the source-material.
But from the games on that list, I'll probably take the batman games. Arkham asylum, since I haven't played arkham city.
I would vote for Batman: Arkham Asylum but I will just do the sequel instead. Also you are missing X-Men Legends 1 & 2 and the more recent Deadpool and Marvel Heroes. Has there been any new comic book video games announced? The only one I can think of is the MOBA Infinite Crisis.
Gotta go with Batman Arkham City, seems like popular opinion is that Asylum was better (seems weird that it's not on this list but Origins is), but I loved what City did to build on its predecessor. Damn, damn fine game. And hey, at least it was a relatively ambitious sequel as far as sequels go these days.
Shout out to The Darkness II, it's more straightforward than its predecessor, but I really enjoyed its gameplay, story and snazzy visuals.
Yeah I was looking for Freedom Force and City of Heroes (RIP) and sad to see neither on the list. Man, I dumped so much time into CoH. Long live Miss Blizzard!
Anyway, if I were just going by the list, probably Batman Arkham City? Although I would put the first Arkham game above it, just for how groundbreaking it was.
XIII and yeah, there's a bunch of comic book/graphic novel games missing from that list. Arkham Asylum, City of Heroes, Deadpool, Freedom Force, The Darkness, Marvel Heroes, The Walking Dead, Wolf Among Us & that doesn't even touch any of the manga-based stuff...
I was quite partial to XIII when it first came out, still waiting on the sequel to that cliff hanger ending...
Putting Arkham games in here is kind've unfair, they're the gold standard for comic book adaptations to games. Not including the Arkham games I voted for Spiderman 2 as swinging around the city in that game was the tops.
I voted for Arkham Asylum purely because it was so mechanically perfect and robust that when I first played it, it blew me away. Arkham City definitely refined that formula, but my memory of Arkham Asylum is going about searching for all of the audio logs because the voice acting and the writing for every single character was phenomenal. Both are great though.
You were missing Spider-Man: Web of Shadows, the best Spider-Man game. Super Hero Squad on DS was a solid Smash Bros. clone and Super Hero Squad: The Infinity Gauntlet on consoles was a really fun and charming coop game. X-Men on Gameboy Advance was a fun throwback to NES and SNES side scrollers. I have also heard good things Thor on DS and Batman: The Brave and the Bold. And no mention of the Marvel vs Capcom franchise? Or Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe? What the hell with these options? I voted for Iron Man 2.
Spider-Man for the original PlayStation.