Giant Bomb Community GOTY - Best Download Only Game (Voting)

Winner: The Binding of Isaac

Runner-up: Cthulhu Saves The World (PC)

Winner: Bastion

Runner Up: Terraria

Need to play more download games...

Winner : ilomilo

Runner Up : Stacking

Honorable Mentions : Bastion , Outland

Winner: Bastion

Runner up: From Dust

Winner: Frozen Synapse

Runner-Up: Orcs Must Die

Winner Bastion. Runner Up Outland

Winner: Bastion

Runner Up: Frozen Synapse

Winner: Bastion

Runner Up: Outland

Winner: Bastion Runner up: Orcs must die

Winner: Outland
 
Runner-up: Bangai-o Missile Fury HD

Winner: Bastion

Runner up: The Binding of Issac

I wish I could also give Rock of Ages some GOTY potential but Issac just beats it.