#1 Edited by shmoodow (39 posts) -

After someone asked in the other "by the numbers" GotY thread about how the list would look if guests were included, so here it is:

  1. The Last of Us (154)
  2. The Legend of Zelda: A Link Between Worlds (76)
  3. Assassins Creed IV: Black Flag (68)
  4. Papers Please (66)
  5. Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons (65)
  6. Bioshock Infinite (62)
  7. Gone Home (59)
  8. Saints Row IV (50)
  9. Stanley Parable (45)
  10. Grand Theft Auto V (44)
  11. TIE: Lara Croft: Tomb Raider/Super Mario 3D World (40)
  12. Dota 2 (30)
  13. Rogue Legacy (29)
  14. Divekick (20)
  15. Animal Crossing: New Leaf (19)
  16. Guacamelee (15)
  17. TIE: The Swapper/DmC (14)
  18. TIE: Peggle 2/Gunpoint/Pokemon XY/Fire Emblem: Awakening (13)
  19. TIE: Tearaway/XCOM: Enemy Within (12)
  20. Beyond: Two Souls (11)
  21. TIE: Civilisation 5: Brave New World/Kerbal Space Program/Unity of Command/Device 6/Metro: Last Light (10)
  22. TIE: Antichamber/LEGO Marvel Super Heroes/Candy Box/Far Cry 3 (9)
  23. TIE: ALL I WANT IS FOR ALL MY FRIENDS TO BECOME INSANELY POWERFUL/Diablo III/Rayman Legends/Zelda: WInd Waker HD /Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Blacklist/Spelunky/Shadowrun Returns (8)
  24. TIE: Injustice: Gods Among Us/Shelter/Rocksmith 2014/Dishonored/Dead Space 3 (7)
  25. TIE: Battlefield 4/The Walking Dead/Fallen Enchantress/Call of Duty: Ghosts/WWE 2K14/Remember Me/Star Wars Pinball/Phoenix Wright: Dual Destinies/Year Walk/Far Cry 3: Blood Dragon (6)
  26. TIE: Batman: Arkham Origins/Icarus Proudbottom Teaches Typing/Dynasty Warriors 8/Borderlands 2 (5)
  27. TIE: Disney Infinity/DC Universe Online/Proteus/Lords of Waterdeep/Mark of the Ninja (4)
  28. TIE: State of Decay/Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance/Kentucky Route Zero/FIFA 14/Dead Rising 3/Just Cause 2 Multiplayer/Nuclear Throne (3)
  29. TIE: Plants v Zombies 2/Killer Instinct/Castles In The Sky/Knightmare Tower/Battleblock Theater/WoW Timeless Isle/Hitman: Absolution (2)
  30. TIE: Payday 2/Teleglitch/Paint it Back/Ryse/Hundreds/Dragons Crown/Luigis Mansion/F1 2013 (1)

Note: I didn't Include unordered top 10s (Will Smith, Zoe Quinn) and when a game was on a list multiple times I only counted it once at its highest position (Brad Muir, Dean Evans). Shorter lists (John Carpenter, Casey Malone) were ranked with their No. 1 game being worth 10 and the rest going down from there, with the last however many numbers missed off.

Link to download spreadsheet.

#2 Posted by DaveLang (5282 posts) -

The Realest List

#3 Posted by DystopiaX (5495 posts) -

Nice job. Interesting that the top is at least similar to the site's GOTY list.

#4 Posted by Superfriend (1682 posts) -

Yes! The number crunchers in the Giantbomb community never cease to amaze.

On a related note: There were a lot of really awesome games this year! If these lists are good for anything, then it´s realizing that 2013 sucked a whole lot less than everybody wants to think.

#5 Posted by KentonClay (363 posts) -

That list seems downright sensible!

#6 Posted by csl316 (12273 posts) -

Proteus makes a list after all, what a twist!!

#7 Posted by Fredchuckdave (8877 posts) -

Pretty solid list, Tomb Raider gets a little more respect but still kind of a small amount. Apart from Rogue Legacy not being on the top 10 this list is better methinks.

#8 Posted by Dalai (7834 posts) -

Now it's getting ridiculous.

#9 Posted by thatdutchguy (1301 posts) -

That's a pretty good list.

#10 Posted by HerbieBug (4228 posts) -

Bah! List by committee! D:

#11 Edited by Mike (16261 posts) -

This is getting recockulous. Although I bet this list is pretty close to what will end up coming out of the user-submitted lists aggregate, though.