• 136 results
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

This topic is locked from further discussion.

Posted by mracoon (4972 posts) 11 months, 2 days ago
#1 Posted by Master_Funk (737 posts) -

Last of Us, for me. Both great games.

#2 Posted by Milkman (17001 posts) -

Tough and probably a little unfair considering how recently I played it but my heart says Last of Us.

#3 Posted by TowerSixteen (544 posts) -

Oh god i'm not looking forward to the rhetoric in this thread, no matter which way it goes.

#4 Edited by selfconfessedcynic (2564 posts) -

I love both games, but TLOU is my pick - things like Winter and how it begins and ends make it untouchable in my eyes.

Won't be mad if it loses though, Skyrim is a worthy competitor.

#5 Posted by Pr1mus (3950 posts) -

I'm happy The Last of Us pulled through against The Walking Dead. As much as i'd like it to win this too i'm not holding my breath.

#6 Posted by MooseyMcMan (11276 posts) -

The Last of Us is great, but my vote's with Skyrim.

Moderator Online
#7 Posted by ImmortalSaiyan (4690 posts) -

I should really play The Last of Us, eh? I can't possibly vote without playing it. I wish I could see the results regardless.

#8 Edited by AMyggen (3314 posts) -

Have to go with Skyrim here.

#9 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

Skyrim to spite The Last of Us.

Fucking bring it.

#10 Posted by BeachThunder (12087 posts) -

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

#11 Edited by Master_Funk (737 posts) -

@beachthunder: The game is definitely a slow burn at the beginning, which was where the QL segment took place. But it ramps up big time, from the end of summer onwards, and never really stops.

#12 Edited by selfconfessedcynic (2564 posts) -

@beachthunder said:

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

By nature of the quicklook, Patrick etc couldnt spoil any of the story. It was also early in the game, so gameplay elements like the upgrade system and weapon variety at the end of the game couldn't be shown.

Essentially that quicklook showed little to none of the elements of what TLOU great outside of the great visuals and basic gameplay loop.

For me, though, it was the journey Joel and Ellie go through - from start to finish, it's just an excellently put together narrative whilst also being a finely crafted game.

#13 Posted by mracoon (4972 posts) -

@beachthunder: The narrative and the world mainly. I found the relationship between Joel and Ellie to be genuinely touching. I also enjoyed the combat but I know some people weren't fans of it.

#14 Posted by Milkman (17001 posts) -

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

Winter.

#15 Posted by Master_Funk (737 posts) -
@milkman said:

@beachthunder said:

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

Winter.


Winter is one of the greatest segments of a video game this generation.

#16 Posted by ViciousBearMauling (1169 posts) -

Skyrim is an ocean with the depth of a puddle. Never liked it.

#17 Posted by AMyggen (3314 posts) -

I enjoyed the world, the characters and the story of TLoU. The combat never clicked with me though, almost to the point where I think I'd enjoyed it more as a passive than an active experience. Still, one of my favourite story in a game this gen.

#18 Edited by RonGalaxy (3219 posts) -

@beachthunder said:

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

Its heart wrenching from start to finish. It doesnt give you a chance to breath. That section of the game is definitely not indicative of the overall experience.

#19 Edited by TheHT (11507 posts) -
#20 Posted by Captain_Insano (1547 posts) -

Oddly I didn't finish Skyrim (as with all Elder Scrolls Games) but I have to vote for it. The Last Of Us was great, but I didn't find it as great as the internets has made it. Skyrim was what I want games to be. Not without its issues but it's on the right track.

#21 Posted by Box3ru13 (704 posts) -

TLOU for a myraid of reasons that I will come back and edit this post to say why.

#22 Posted by Karkarov (3173 posts) -

I am glad last of us got rid of that other game, but it's time has come. Votin Skyrim.

#23 Posted by CaLe (4018 posts) -

I enjoyed my time with Skyrim, almost all of it. People say it had bad combat, but I say nay, it was fine. People say it had boring dungeons, but I say nay, they were good. People say it had tedious missions, and I say nay, they were grand.

The Last of Us is the best game ever made. Sorry Skyrim.

#24 Edited by Fredchuckdave (5706 posts) -

Last of Us loses because cross console, but at least it didn't lose to a non-game. Unless the Skyrim hate is too strong perhaps!? I kind of wanted a Dark Souls vs Skyrim match-up, figured the Last of Us would lose to either even though its much better than one and slightly better than the other.

#25 Posted by Pr1mus (3950 posts) -

@video_game_king: You should find a way to play The Last of Us one day. It's a good game.

#26 Posted by mercutio123 (471 posts) -

Again, TLOU is up against a game where the actual gameplay is terrible.

#27 Posted by Hunter5024 (5805 posts) -

Consider this before you vote: Skyrim sucks.

#28 Edited by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

@theht:

Poll results are leaning in my favor.

#29 Edited by Fredchuckdave (5706 posts) -
#30 Edited by Atlas (2454 posts) -

I really like TLoU, but c'mon, Skyrim is Skyrim.

When I was a child, playing Sega Mega Drive and then Nintendo 64 games, I dreamed about what games might someday be like. Skyrim comes as close to recreating my childhood ideal vision of the gaming future as possible.

#31 Posted by OppressedOstrich (3 posts) -

The Last of Us. With MGS4 out, The Last of Us should win it all.

#32 Edited by Fredchuckdave (5706 posts) -

@atlas: Everyone's childhood dream future should either be Ellen Page murdering fools or dying over and over, the two true games of the generation (well, okay Witcher 2 is number 2 but that lost like a year ago). Daniel Defoe on the side is just a plus.

#33 Posted by Pr1mus (3950 posts) -

I know it's only about 10% of the vote in but i am pleasantly surprised by how close this is. Never really believed until about an hour ago that TLoU or TWD would ever have a shot against Skyrim.

#34 Edited by altairre (1214 posts) -

@master_funk said:
@milkman said:

@beachthunder said:

Okay, so just out of interest, what part of Last of Us makes people consider it to be so amazing? I'm genuinely asking, because I've only seen the QL, which didn't exactly make the game seem exceptional...

Winter.

Winter is one of the greatest segments of a video game this generation.

It's the progression really. That game doesn't work well if you just look at a chunk of it. It's about how the characters develop, how they adapt to the situation and I found that to be reflected in the gameplay as well. I wasn't a huge fan of it at first but once you get better gear and an understanding of how to approach the situations the game lays out that part became terrific too. You actually have quite a lot of freedom to plan your attacks but also the ability to react if things go wrong which led to a few badass situations involving bricks, pipes and a few gun rounds.

It's the first Naughty Dog game of this generation where every part works and is interesting as opposed to Uncharted where the shooting is tedious for the most part. It should win this fight.

#35 Posted by selfconfessedcynic (2564 posts) -

@pr1mus said:

I know it's only about 10% of the vote in but i am pleasantly surprised by how close this is. Never really believed until about an hour ago that TLoU or TWD would ever have a shot against Skyrim.

I'm 100% with you on that one. This will be exciting to watch unless there's a massive Giant Bomb-EU shift to one or the other.

I'm pleasantly surprised how well TLOU is doing against these excellent multi-platform titles.

#36 Posted by RonGalaxy (3219 posts) -

Even if the last of us wins, it will go up against mass effect 2, which has been destroying everything it's put up against. I'm fine with this

#37 Posted by Hayt (298 posts) -

http://imgur.com/4yXGuwA

Last of Us has a bigger 50%

Collusion

#38 Posted by TheHT (11507 posts) -
#39 Posted by Deranged (1837 posts) -

Skyrim is a good game but where it truly draws in gamers is its sheer depth with the universe, characters and freedom. Sadly, that really wore off for me quickly and despite how hilariously short Last of Us is in comparison and with both games having barely average combat, the narrative in the latter was just too impactful to ignore.

Last of Us by a hair.

#40 Edited by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

@theht:

We all know the real Game of the Generation:

Pandora's Tower

#41 Posted by RecSpec (3849 posts) -

If this was Oblivion, I would've had a harder time picking. The Last of Us gets my vote.

#42 Posted by awesomeusername (4207 posts) -

I SWEAR TO GOD GIANTBOMB I FUCKING SWEAR

#43 Posted by Mento (2676 posts) -

I knew TLOU's console exclusivity would catch up with it and rip its throat out eventually. Maybe it can still win this though, since it's an awfully close race.

Moderator
#44 Posted by HH (611 posts) -

I love The Last of Us, I think it deserves every bit of recognition it gets, but Skyrim is my home, and I cannot vote against my home.

#45 Posted by mlarrabee (2990 posts) -

I should prob'ly play TLOU soon.

#46 Posted by altairre (1214 posts) -

@mento said:

I knew TLOU's console exclusivity would catch up with it and rip its throat out eventually. Maybe it can still win this though, since it's an awfully close race.

It won't. I think you're right in saying that this wouldn't go in favor of Skyrim if Last of Us wasn't PS3 exclusive though.

#47 Edited by bmehlers (130 posts) -

Haven't played The Last of Us, that's why I feel these polls are premature, but I love Skyrim so it has to win as of now.

#48 Posted by shinboy630 (1162 posts) -

I went with Skyrim because I enjoyed all of the time I spent with it, and because while the back half of TLoU (starting with Autumn) is stellar, I think a lot of the parts before it, like Pittsburgh, are pretty tedious.

#49 Posted by chilibean_3 (1655 posts) -

@mercutio123: This is a crazy thing to say when the game you are favoring is Last of Us! You crazy!

#50 Posted by Broomhitches (173 posts) -

This is sooo close.