This topic is locked from further discussion.
I think this is the only poll in this bracket where I haven't played one of the games; and I haven't played either of them.
That said, I've seen a little of both, and from that and hearing plenty of chatter on both titles I feel comfortable picking TWD.
In fact, y'know what sways me to it? Those articles Scoops did on the player decisions. I didn't even play the game but I found those discussions fucking fascinating.
Alan Wake was my GOTY of 2010. While I loved The Walking Dead's story and even though Alan Wake's gameplay was repetitive it at least had the gameplay there. I really hope S2 of TWD has more actual gameplay and not just QTE's and some of the easiest puzzles I've seen in a video game.