#1 Posted by jclane (427 posts) -

I'm asking because I plan to buy a couple of GC controllers and a bunch of games, but I don't own a GameCube anymore. However, I've got a perfectly functioning Wii and I know that the system was backwards compatible with GC games and gear. The question is, what's the quality like (i.e. as good as it would look and sound on an original GameCube) and does it support the full library of GC games or is it like the PS3's limited BC where some games work better than others and some don't work at all?

#2 Edited by believer258 (12967 posts) -

From my understanding, it's nearly perfect. I certainly never had any problems playing Gamecube games on a Wii.

#3 Edited by Fattony12000 (7969 posts) -

@jclane: The emulation is as flawless as it's possible to be I reckon, at least in my experience. The audio glitches contained in the GC versions of OoT and MM are still there, for example. Flawless Victory.

"It succeeds the Nintendo GameCube, with early models being fully backward-compatible with all GameCube games and most accessories."

"In late 2011 Nintendo released a reconfigured model, the "Wii Family Edition", which removed Nintendo GameCube compatibility; this model was not released in Japan. The Wii Mini, Nintendo's first major console redesign since the compact SNES, succeeded the standard Wii model on December 7, 2012 in Canada. The Wii Mini can only play Wii optical discs, as it omits GameCube and online game capabilities."


#4 Posted by jclane (427 posts) -
#5 Posted by capaho (18 posts) -

I played a few GC games on my Wii before I mothballed it a couple of years ago and they played well, as well as a GC game plays, anyway. It isn't hi-tech but it works.

#6 Posted by BisonHero (8564 posts) -

I randomly played Super Monkey Ball 2 on my Wii a little while ago. The story mode has in-engine cutscenes, and for some reason the audio and video would get out of sync on those (this did not happen while I played it on the GameCube). I didn't test other Wiis, so maybe mine has an optical drive issue? It's never had problems with any other game, though, and even the rest of Super Monkey Ball 2 was completely fine.

Every other GameCube game I've tried was totally fine.

#7 Posted by JasonR86 (10029 posts) -

Very good, especially over component.

#8 Posted by HistoryInRust (6650 posts) -

Is it actually emulating anything? I was under the impression the original Wii models just had Gamecube hardware under the hood.

#9 Posted by ModernAlkemie (375 posts) -

Unfortunately the Wii doesn't emulate the GC's sturdy side handle, which allows you to game at the speed of life by taking your GC on the go!

#10 Edited by BisonHero (8564 posts) -

@historyinrust: Yes, I believe they just have a GameCube chipset in there somewhere. Which is why it's weird that Super Monkey Ball 2 had issues for me. I'm assuming the Wii and GameCube optical drives have their differences, and maybe the Wii one was loading things faster than the GameCube hardware expected?

#11 Posted by Ben_H (3647 posts) -

I played a fair number of GC games on my Wii and didn't have any issues. The version of Majora's Mask on that collector's edition Zelda disk was just as broken as it was on a GameCube (It locks up when you go to play this one song on a wall a good percentage of the time. I lost 2 hours of progress because of it). Pikmin 2 runs great.

Man, I should dig my Wii out. I still gotta finish a few games on it.

#12 Posted by dionysis (53 posts) -

I've never run into any problems with it. Pikmin 2 was the most played game on the Wii for a good long time several years ago when my sons were into it. We also played a fair amount of Double Dash, F-Zero, Paper Mario, and the GC Fire Emblem game.

#13 Posted by Gamer_152 (14299 posts) -

It's always been just about perfect for me. If I didn't know any better I would have said the games were running on the Gamecube.

#14 Posted by TheManWithNoPlan (6349 posts) -

I've had a Wii for about 5 years now and have never tried the Gamecube functionality, but as far as I understand it's pretty good.

#15 Edited by TechnoSyndrome (1107 posts) -
#16 Posted by xaLieNxGrEyx (2646 posts) -

Is it actually emulating anything? I was under the impression the original Wii models just had Gamecube hardware under the hood.

The Wii is a Gamecube with motion controllers