If you get an Xbox One, spring for the Kinect. I don't see any real point to get the cheaper PS4-like X1 without the Kinect functionality. That is, unless you absolutely will not use any Kinect features, really can't afford to spend more than $400, and really like the Xbox exclusives. Personally, I really enjoy the Kinect. It works pretty damn well now, and having auto-sign in, using voice commands to record gameplay, control my home theater volume, to turn the console on and off, to snap tv/apps while playing a game, etc., etc. is awesome and highly useful.
It's worth noting that the 900p vs. 1080p graphics nonsense is highly overblown. I'm playing on a high-end 55" 1080p Samsung and the games look great. Forza 5 especially looks terrific, and ACIV, Watch_Dogs, etc. really have their moments. Basically, unless you're a complete graphics junkie and spend your time obsessing about if this blade of grass looks better on PS4 or X1, you won't notice any difference at all. I've looked at a ton of the comparison videos in full HD on my home PC, and the differences are marginal at best when they're even noticeable at all. That said, if it's extremely important to you to have the "best" console version of a game, know that the PS4 editions may be marginally better in some case because the PS4 is able to dedicate more system resources specifically to gaming.
UI-wise, I'm not crazy about the X1's Windows 8-like tile-heavy interface. They finally got the motion controls to be somewhat functional, but it's not a particularly useful or time-saving addition as much as it is a "neato" thing. I find myself using little more than the recent apps tiles, my apps & games section, and then just telling it to "go to ____" for everything else. Having the "go to___" option via the kinect offsets some of the interface shortcomings, so that's nice. Still, having to hunt for stuff in the UI is more difficult and clunky than it should be. It hasn't much affected my X1 experience, but it's a weakness.
You'll find some varied opinions on the X1 controller. I personally think it's great, with the exception of the oversized bumpers. Basically, if you liked the 360 controller, you'll probably like the X1 controller. It's among the best controllers I've used, and it hasn't been particularly tough to adjust to. I think the triggers and the sticks are as good as it gets. I don't find myself slipping off the sticks, which is a problem I've had with both Sony and Xbox controllers in the past. And those triggers have terrific feedback, both in terms of haptic/resistance. Great stuff there.
Game-wise, the X1 took a big step with the E3 announcements of a few exclusives and a bigger library for indie games. I'm personally thrilled about the Master Chief Collection, and Forza Horizon 2 has some real potential to be fantastic. And then you've got cross-platform games like GTA V making their way to next gen and some big ones like AC: Unity to release this fall to make this year-end even more promising for the new consoles. Games with Gold, HBO GO, and other developments on the X1 are really exciting as well.
Overall, I'd highly recommend the Xbox One. When it was first released, the kinect wasn't completed ironed out, and they obviously overestimated the public's willingness to spring $100 for it. However, they've continued developing it to where it's well worth it (IMO). MS has made missteps, but they're being very responsive to the customer, and that's a good thing. What we have now is a quality console, and I don't regret buying it day one, either. If you'll use the Kinect at all and have any interest in making it a home entertainment hub, get a full-featured X1. If you just want a gaming machine, get a PS4. And unless you're really, really into Mario stuff, pass on the Wii U.
JMOs.
Log in to comment