Kif, we have a conundrum

 Alright, so on tuesday my wallet gets considerabely lighter.  I've narrowed it down to either Alan Wake or Red Dead on the PS3.  I've been anticipating both games for awhile (especially considering they were announced pretty much at the same time 4 or 5 years ago), and still don't know which one i should get first.  Now I can only get one, and i won't be buying the other for for about a month.  Now the whole point of this thread is to convince me which one I, or anyone else coming to this page, should buy.
 
Go!

more bang for buck = RDR

Wait for the RDR reviews.

both have been reviewed and RDR has got a 10 and a 9.75 so far, it looks to be the best bet

The valore fog

" Wait for the RDR reviews. "

get RDR then rent or buy alan wake when its cheap