#1 Posted by BeachThunder (12740 posts) -

Basically, I'm talking about the feeling of having played a game and thinking "yes, I just played a masterpiece!"; a game that when you finish it, you feel like you should give it a standing ovation.

Personally, the last game that I played that I would consider 'amazing' would be Planescape: Torment; gameplay: not so good, but that was balanced out by the outstanding narrative elements. I'd also say Walking Dead, but for obvious reasons, I haven't finished the game yet - so I'm going to abstain from calling it amazing just yet...

Anyway, what was the last game that you played that you personally would consider 'amazing'?

#2 Posted by allworkandlowpay (873 posts) -

Bioshock 1.

#3 Posted by DizzyMedal (401 posts) -

Saints Row 2.

#4 Edited by FluxWaveZ (19418 posts) -

Masterpiece isn't really a term that I think of, but the last game I played that left a significant impression on me is either Spec Ops: The Line (which I started and finished today) or Journey.

#5 Posted by ThePaleKing (613 posts) -

Some moments in Resonance.

#6 Posted by Dooley (214 posts) -
#7 Edited by Bane122 (834 posts) -

Enslaved. Liked parts of Heavenly Sword and enjoyed the demo so I expected to like it but for whatever reason just sat on the game for a year or so. Finally played it last month and was blown away. Good gameplay, great writing, top notch voice and mocap acting, and an absolutely gorgeous art design. Damn shame the sequel isn't happening.

#8 Edited by Asurastrike (2185 posts) -

Red Dead Redemption

#9 Posted by Icicle7x3 (1216 posts) -

Super Metroid

#10 Posted by RandomInternetUser (6789 posts) -

I can't ever give love to just one game so I'll just list the ones from the past couple years.

  • Demon's Souls when I played it in 2010 and Dark Souls (to a lesser extent since it wasn't quite as fresh of an experience after Demon's Souls, still absolutely loved it.)
  • Skyrim
  • Battlefield 3 for the multiplayer, not so much the campaign.
  • Darksiders
  • League of Legends
  • ...I replayed DMC3 like 4 times since last year. (Can't resist giving love to this game any time I have a chance to.)
  • Episode 2 of The Walking Dead
  • BF: Bad Company 2's multiplayer
  • Red Dead Redemption

I feel like I might be leaving some PS3 game out but I can't remember... Anyways, those are the games I've played since 2010 that I find to be "HOLY FUCK AMAZING."

#11 Posted by kindpixel (2868 posts) -

Hm, Amazing game. Planetside 2. That game's epic moments still amaze me.

#12 Posted by BisonHero (7692 posts) -

Half-Life 2. Portal. VVVVVV. Bastion.

Just to name a few games I played on PC in the last decade that fit the description.

#13 Edited by munnyman5 (186 posts) -

I just finished playing MGS4 for the first time like 2 days ago, and I knew that it was something crazy/special; even if a good deal of the references were lost on me (I haven't played any other Metal Gear game), I still laughed heartily and more often than I expected.

When I finished playing Journey, I found out that I had played with ONE other person the whole way through (though I didn't know it until the end), and it left such an impression on me that just I have remembered his/her PlayStation Network username off the top of my head ever since. I even sent a friend request immediately after with the attached message "That. Was. Amazing." which I also remember. Why? Because emotionally charged memories are more strongly stored in memory. Why? Because the amygdala is very close to the hippocampus. Look it up.

And dude, straight up, Saints Row: The Third blew my goddamn mind out the back of my fuckin' head. I mean I visit GiantBomb.com, so I am probably the kind of person who would obviously dig that game, but let me hit you with this: my friend is a brash young bon-vivant that drinks a lot, has a lot of sex, and barely plays video games. He also happens to be a supremely cool guy (no, not because of the drinking, sex, etc.) with a pretty keen sense of humor. He'd boot up GTA:SA every so often to put in a bunch of cheats and beat the Christ out of cops for a half hour to unwind, but that was about it. But one fine day, I lent him my 360 and Saints Row: The Third, and it was literally the first video game this marvelous motherfucker had ever played from start to finish. He did the missions and everything - a concept he had never even considered in other games - and we even talked about how crazy the TRON level etc. were. I think that if SR3 can draw in a dude who could scarcely give less of a fuck about games, it's something special, too.

So that was 3 answers. Sorry.

EDIT: Fuck, Red Dead Redemption was super great as well. I barely even have emotions; the kind of guy who is pretty much always kinda happy-go-lucky and not a whole lot else. But Red Dead made me shed 2 tears at the end. Yo, I NEVER cry, hear me? That's 4 answers. Once again, my apologies.

#14 Posted by crithon (3474 posts) -

depends for a lot of different games. Recently from the Steam Sale my low expectations to a lot of games, really surprised me to the charm of a lot of games I passed by.

But basically Rayman Origins really did make me re evaluate my standards for platformers now.

#15 Posted by me3639 (1881 posts) -

I can never pick one however, Bioshock, Red Dead Redemption, Dragon Age origins, Dark Souls, Fallout 3, Alan Wake, and Braid quickly come to mind.

#16 Posted by alexl86 (658 posts) -

I played Skyrim yesterday, which I think is amazing, however I've played that game on and off for almost a year now. I don't think any of the games I've played since Skyrim's release, which includes Saints Row the Third, Rayman: Origins (I haven't played enough of it though) and Final Fantasy XIII, are amazing games. Actually, maybe FIFA 12 would qualify...

Of games from this generation, I'd say GTAIV, Dragon Age: Origins, Bastion, Batman Arkham Asylum and Mass Effect. I have to say, since it's been mentioned so often here, that I didn't like BioShock.

#17 Posted by WarlordPayne (708 posts) -

The last one I played was Deus Ex: Human Revolution. I played it a month or two ago and, outside of a couple of boss fights, I was completely enthralled.

#18 Posted by EVO (3946 posts) -

Dear Esther, in particular the cave was fucking amazing.

#19 Posted by Animasta (14753 posts) -

hmm... Binary Domain maybe. if not that, than witcher 2, and if not that then Nier (which is a masterpiece, THE masterpiece really)

#20 Posted by huntad (1994 posts) -

Super Meat Boy. I was really late to the party.

#21 Posted by Sploder (917 posts) -

Persona 4. Before that Persona 3.

#22 Edited by MEATBALL (3722 posts) -

Journey. Mark of the Ninja was pretty close. The Walking Dead will likely be there when the final episode is finished. Episode 3 was pretty incredible.

#23 Posted by CookieMonster (2471 posts) -

Super Meat Boy.

#24 Posted by ToxicFruit (1731 posts) -

I think it is going to have to be Dragon age:origins for me. I became really invested in its story

#25 Edited by Willin (1289 posts) -

Journey. God dammit if that game isn't fucking amazing.

#26 Posted by geirr (2792 posts) -
#27 Edited by Captain_Felafel (1622 posts) -
#28 Posted by ervonymous (1297 posts) -

Grandia. It's part nostalgia, but replaying it on Vita reconfirmed my feelings. Sometimes you just want to go "Fuck it, I'm going on an adventure, keep your intricate plots to yourselves."

It's a bit on the easy side.. but at least you can try to beat all the enemies before they get a single action in for the alternate victory music? There's a fan patch to spice things up but I can't vouch for its quality.

#29 Posted by TobbRobb (4931 posts) -

Dark Souls and Bayonetta. I keep saying that every chance I get, but those might be the only games I've ever felt were truly amazing. I have a lot of respect and love for other games, but those two are at the top, looking down on the filthy peasants.

#30 Posted by TruthTellah (9553 posts) -


#31 Posted by isomeri (1549 posts) -

The Walking Dead continues to amaze me. Earlier in the year I was amazed by Journey. Before that I guess Bastion. What a fantastic time for gaming this is!

#32 Posted by pantzing_nome (591 posts) -

Rayman Origins

#33 Posted by BleedingStarX (283 posts) -

Binary Domain or Max Payne 3

#34 Posted by Twinsun (513 posts) -

Probably Gravity Rush, that game deserves way more attention than it's getting.

#36 Posted by Zaccheus (1813 posts) -

Journey. Definitely Journey.

#37 Posted by c0l0nelp0c0rn1 (1816 posts) -

@BeachThunder: Bastion

#38 Posted by MetalGearSunny (7003 posts) -
#39 Edited by PenguinDust (12706 posts) -

Skyrim. Yeah, it was that long ago. I've played many games since but nothing I'd describe as amazing. Good, yes; hellaciously fun, absolutely, but nothing as engrossing and exciting as Skyrim. Because of the mods, Skyrim doesn't end for me when it's over. The creative community extends the life and entertainment value of the game beyond the traditional life cycle. It continues to be one of the best experiences I've had with a video game.

#40 Edited by MordeaniisChaos (5730 posts) -

Alan Wake so far. Would have said LA Noire so far but the ending of the Golden Butterfly case is obnoxiously difficult even though the clear bad guy all but admits to it.

Actually lets just say Skyrim...

#41 Posted by Freelancer52 (77 posts) -

Assassin's Creed 2 or Red Dead Redemption...but there are others that I have played more recently than that but I am having a hard time thinking of them

#42 Posted by Poltergeist13 (70 posts) -

Max Payne 3, great story and characters...multiplayer is a blast also.

#43 Posted by TranceQuina (154 posts) -

I'm a harsh critic and I don't use the word "amazing" very often at all, but I do still say that about Dark Souls.  Or, as I've called it before, Sword Quest 2.  The near-complete lack of guidance created and fueled a community of players helping each other without anyone losing the sense that it was *their own* adventure.  The reward in playing it is made possible by the punishing structure of the game.  For once, the game is "fight for your life," not just "get to the end and see all the content we made."  It's probably the truest adventure game I've played, and the most morbidly satisfying dungeon crawl as well. 
I did love Demon's Souls as well, but the differences made to the formula in Dark Souls really counted for a lot in my book.

#44 Posted by Kidavenger (3682 posts) -

Portal 2, the campaign was amazing and the community has put out some great stuff since.

#45 Posted by Hunter5024 (6164 posts) -

Bastion. It's the game I played most recently on my all time favorites list. All of that game is totally beautiful to me, from the mechanics to the story.

#46 Posted by Video_Game_King (36272 posts) -

Gimme a minute....either Persona 2 or Eversion.

#47 Posted by Somnus (85 posts) -

Journey. That game is just... holy shit...

#48 Posted by A_Dog (739 posts) -


Great humour, story, and I really liked the level designs.

#49 Edited by YI_Orange (1178 posts) -

The most recent game for me, not counting The Walking Dead(though if you haven't played those just fucking do it. If the last 2 episodes are anywhere near as good as the first 3 then it's got a damn good shot at being GOTY for me) is Journey I believe.

It's sad to see so many people here listing old games and I hope they're just picking a game from any time instead of actually thinking about the LAST amazing game they played. There's a lot of awesome games out there and if you haven't been able to call one amazing for the better part of a decade, you might need to step away for a bit.

#50 Posted by Aska (431 posts) -

Last time I had that feeling was the beginning of this year when I played through Bastion. I really fell in love with what that game was doing.