Needing Advice on Getting A Game

For a while now I've been wanting to get a good long game that would take me a while to chew through.  I've looked at various games and can't quite pull the trigger.  I adore Fallout 3 but with the final DLC pack coming out soon, that game is close to going on the permanant shelf (I dont really feel like another play through).

I'm looking for a game with a good story.   A lot of sandbox games can take a while to beat but really contain more filler then actual story.  I know there are probably tons or JRPG's out there but thats not my thing.

I'll throw out some of my likes/dislikes - any advice would be apprecaiated.   I own each console so platform is not an issue.  I'd even be willing to go previous gen but would have to pick up a PS2 as my PS3 isnt backwards compat.

Dislikes:
Mass Effect
JRPG's
Science Fiction
KOTOR: II

Likes:
KOTOR I
Fallout 3
inFamous
GTA IV

I'm really considering Okami (Wii).  I've heard nothing but great things about it however as noted, I'm afraid it may be a little too japaneese for me.

Oblivion is a blast.

"Dislikes:

KOTOR: II

Likes:
KOTOR I"

Aren't KOTOR I & Fallout 3 technically science fiction? Anyways...

I will second Oblivion.

" Aren't KOTOR I & Fallout 3 technically science fiction? "

The worst part about Okami is the insane amount of dialogue.  It's good, but there's a ton of it.

I played Oblivion - not my thing. 

Like I said - strange taste in games.

"@Agnogenic said:

" Aren't KOTOR I & Fallout 3 technically science fiction? "

So is inFamous, go figure."

I would say Valkyria Chronicles, mainly because it is more of a tactical RPG than a JRPG/WRPG. Then again, you are a fan of inFAMOUS, have you thought about checking out Prototype?

" @Snail said:

"So is inFamous, go figure."

I wouldn't classify inFamous as sci fi. Mass Effect is sci fi. "

Try to figure out what gameplay you like - not which setting you prefer.

It's not out yet, but Borderlands is probably something you should be looking forward to.