Nintendo DS Lite vs. Playstation 2

I've been thinking of getting a Nintendo DS Lite again (I sold the one I had months ago) but now I'm wondering if I should get a PS2 instead.  I'm interested in getting the DS Lite for games like Rythm Heaven and to play The World Ends With You once more plus it being portable so I could play in the bus.  But the PS2 seems to have an impressive library (I wasn't much of a gamer in that generation and I've never owned a Sony console) and I'd enjoy playing RPGs like Kingdom Hearts, Persona 3 and 4, and other exclusives that I never got to play (had a GameCube).  Which one would you get in this situation?

You should definitely get the PS2.

Both.  But I've definitely spent more time on PS2 so I vote that.  Definitely play P3 and P4 (in that order, since it's probably hard to go back after improvements) is you get PS2 and are interested in them.

PS2 First. You'll get more out of it.

Go for the PS2. Anyone even remotely into games should have a PS2. It's a fantastic console. So many fantastic games. Most of which you can get very cheaply now.

Heh, the choice seems so clear to me! Get a PS2! The PS2 is my favourite console out there at the moment in terms of games, and if you want to play any good JRPGs, the PS2 is definitely the place to find them. Owning a PS2 is essential for anyone that likes video games. PERIOD.

Well, I'm convinced.  Thanks!

Unless you need a portable, get a PS2. They both have great libraries, but the PS2's is exceptionally good.

Sounds like you already have a few tv consoles, so maybe a handheld would be a good change of pace. Besides, the RPG lineup on the DS may be just as good, if not better than the PS2

if you haven't played chrono cross, get a ds.

A handheld versus a console?  That's not fair.  If it was DS vs PSP then I would got with DS.

EDIT:  I didn't even notice the first post.  lol   Go with the PS2, you will have more fun with it.

"Sounds like you already have a few tv consoles, so maybe a handheld would be a good change of pace. Besides, the RPG lineup on the DS may be just as good, if not better than the PS2"

What do you want to play ?

"AgentJ said:

"Sounds like you already have a few tv consoles, so maybe a handheld would be a good change of pace. Besides, the RPG lineup on the DS may be just as good, if not better than the PS2"

I actually only have an Xbox 360.  I had a PSP, Nintendo DS and DS Lite as handhelds for this gen (ended up selling all of them) so I know how it is.  I guess I was only playing on the consoles (had a Wii + Xbox) instead of my DS...  I put this poll up because seeing the new games on the DS kinda makes me wonder.And Goly, don't you mean Chrono Trigger?  I thought Chrono Cross was the PS1 spiritual sequel."

"What do you want to play ?

Would you play a handheld often ?

It's not a fair comparison, but I'd have to say PS2 has a better selection of games.

"

"addictedtopinescent said:

"What do you want to play ?

Would you play a handheld often ?

It's not a fair comparison, but I'd have to say PS2 has a better selection of games.

"

Why is it not fair?  If there's something on the DS that I'd like I'd play it like any other game, I guess I'm just searching for which console you guys think has the better library.Oh, and I forgot to tell you I played Chrono Trigger a while ago, Goly.  Never finished it though... :P"

For that I would either have to get a SNES or get a DS.  If only I had the cash... T_T  But I stopped playing it because of Golden Sun: The Lost Age, and I think I'll play that one again.

Two totally different choices. If you want more of a portable experience, you obviously want the DS. Vice-versa if you would rather have more of a at-home experience.

PS2 for sure, plus games are dirt cheap.

"For that I would either have to get a SNES or get a DS :P.  If only I had the cash... T_T"

I guess that's what it comes down to for me: "Which one has the better/most JRPGs" (not that I would dismiss any other genre).  For the moment though, it seems to be the PS2 and I checked some stuff on the new Devil Summoner game that's gonna be released soon at it looks pretty good...  Also got the 360 which has some that I should get around to buying.

And Karmum, what would you choose?

I would get a DS because it is still a current system. The PS2 will continue to drop, so there is really no hurry.

"FluxWaveZ said:

"I guess that's what it comes down to for me: "Which one has the better/most JRPGs" (not that I would dismiss any other genre).  For the moment though, it seems to be the PS2 and I checked some stuff on the new Devil Summoner game that's gonna be released soon at it looks pretty good...  Also got the 360 which has some that I should get around to buying.And Karmum, what would you choose?"

You are talking about Devil Survivor for the DS right?"

Playstation 2 hands down.  Especially if you want to boost the amount of games you can start your collection with.  Average PS2 game price is about under $30 now (with a few exceptions) and there's a lot of good games in the $15 and under bins.  I walked out of gamestop the other day with Way of The Samurai 2, Mark of Kri, Crimson Sea 2, and Freedom Fighters for $28!

That same $28 would have gotten me one DS game.  So if you don't have too much money, your gaming dollar can be stretched considerably with a PS2.

The PS2 has more SMT games, though...  Even if I did prefer Devil Survivor to Devil Summoner (I prefer Devil Summoner).

"mordecaix7 said:

"Playstation 2 hands down.  Especially if you want to boost the amount of games you can start your collection with.  Average PS2 game price is about under $30 now (with a few exceptions) and there's a lot of good games in the $15 and under bins.  I walked out of gamestop the other day with Way of The Samurai 2, Mark of Kri, Crimson Sea 2, and Freedom Fighters for $28!That same $28 would have gotten me one DS game.  So if you don't have too much money, your gaming dollar can be stretched considerably with a PS2."

I think just about everything in this post could be said with the PS2 replaced with DS. Lets try it.

AgentJ said:

"DS hands down.  Especially if you want to boost the amount of games you can start your collection with.  Average DS game price is about under $30 now (with a few exceptions) and there's a lot of good games in the $15 and under bins.  I walked out of gamestop the other day with Super Mario 64 DS, Ninja Gaiden Dragon Sword, Exit, and Dementium for $28!That same $28 would have gotten me one PS2 game.  So if you don't have too much money, your gaming dollar can be stretched considerably with a DS."

Yep, that sounds about right.

I put this poll up because seeing the new games on the DS kinda makes me wonder

The ps2 has SO MANY more and better games than the ds's puzzle and kids games.

"The ps2 has SO MANY more and better games than the ds's puzzle and kids games."

"BigBoss1911 said:

"The ps2 has SO MANY more and better games than the ds's puzzle and kids games."

I beg to differ the DS has a great library for all ages. Anyway if you have never played any games on the PS2 it might be better to start with those, there is enough quality content to last you at least a year or two. "

If you want a list of good PS2 games, i made a topic about this not that long ago

"If you want a list of good PS2 games, i made a topic about this not that long ago

http://www.giantbomb.com/playstation-2/93-1917/ps2-must-own-games/35-239565/#72

"

Yeah, thanks for providing that!

Whilst I love the RPG games on the PS2 (I was a late owner and have built a substantial collection), I still would choose a DS.  Thing is, it is a bit like choosing a Ferrari or a Lambourghini - either way, you will be happy.