Every year a GOTY poll is held that various other gaming forum participate in, including penny-arcade and TIG. Here are the past results: http://vote.grumpybumpers.com/
You can vote for the 2012 poll here: http://vote.runhello.com/2012/
This one is great because it lets you vote for your top 20 games and therefore the results have a very long tail.
Log in to comment