Sure why not but there are more important things that should be on the front page in my opinion.
Perhaps get rid of that "question of the day" on the top of the forums that changes every month and you are forced to make a blog post and make that into a poll.
Should GiantBomb.com add a Poll of The Day?
" I don't see anything wrong with this. They could even discuss the results on the Bombcast. "In that case, perhaps a weekly poll would be more fitting.
Jeff talked about something similar with lists, that they might consider implementing them more seriously - there will probably be something through that avenue instead.
I'm not a fan of daily polls. After you've been doing them for about a week you run out of things to ask about. And I definitely wouldn't want to see it promoted on the front page, there are far more important things to be promoted on the front page than a silly poll.
While a weekly poll would be cool, I can think of a few better things to put on the front page than that.
" @CitizenKane said:yeah" While a weekly poll would be cool, I can think of a few better things to put on the front page than that. "Any particular ideas you wanted to share with the rest of us? "
You did not ask me in particular about this but i think that my sentiment about this is somewhat identical to his. The site has underwent quite some redesigns and with every redesign something important would go away. From the top of my head there is the "popular wikis that need work" tab, "most active wiki editors" and "upcoming releases" that were removed during redesigns that really should get back on there first." @CitizenKane said:
Any particular ideas you wanted to share with the rest of us? "" While a weekly poll would be cool, I can think of a few better things to put on the front page than that. "
" @Kyreo said:I was actually aiming my question at CitizenKane the moderator... but thanks for the input. It's changed my perspective on things a bit.You did not ask me in particular about this but i think that my sentiment about this is somewhat identical to his. The site has underwent quite some redesigns and with every redesign something important would go away. From the top of my head there is the "popular wikis that need work" tab, "most active wiki editors" and "upcoming releases" that were removed during redesigns that really should get back on there first. "" @CitizenKane said:
Any particular ideas you wanted to share with the rest of us? "" While a weekly poll would be cool, I can think of a few better things to put on the front page than that. "
You pretty much nailed why Giantbomb shouldn't have it. Gamefaqs does it. Giantbomb and Gamefaqs are two separate site and doesn't need to emulate other websites. Beyond that as you said, they fill it with throw away questions. Lastly Giant Bomb does its own thing, it's called question of the week.
Please Log In to post.
Log in to comment