I was just reading the AV Club Goty list and someone put the new Call of Juarez as one of their GOTYs. I had completely forgot about this game, yet I remember really enjoying it. I might even put it in my top 10 somewhere.
Can anyone think of games that may not get a second glance that deserve it?
Great DLC might also be worth bringing up, for example Mass Effect 3: Citadel.