This topic is locked from further discussion.

#1 Posted by Wilshere (310 posts) -
#2 Posted by TheHT (11385 posts) -

So she sets up the kickstarter to get financial support for a research project and now wants backers to actually do the research for her too?

le sigh

#3 Edited by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -

EDIT: Nah, I don't really hate to do it ;)

#4 Posted by Hailinel (24975 posts) -

Who seriously thought she'd follow through?

Online
#5 Posted by Bourbon_Warrior (4523 posts) -

I'm gonna make a kickstarter for Ghostbusters 3 get a few million and say well Bill Murray doesn't want to be in it sorry guys.

#6 Posted by TheHumanDove (2523 posts) -

GOTTA GET DEM TROPES

#7 Edited by Animasta (14698 posts) -

probably should've had something before hand, to be honest

(also I hope we can all be calm and completely civi- oh who am I kidding)

#8 Posted by Hitchenson (4682 posts) -

That's what the morons who donated get.

#9 Posted by Jams (2961 posts) -

So what exactly happened? I'm not getting much info from a thread that links to another thread.

#10 Posted by Twinsun (479 posts) -

She is still making the series afaik, so I don't see what the problem is.

#11 Posted by SuperWristBands (2266 posts) -

She'll get it done. I have no clue how long it'll take but I'd rather it be done well than rushed out. Bummer she underestimated the time it'd take. Kind of a big deal to the backers she promised but I'll wait. Though I'm more interested in the video where games do it right as opposed to where they go wrong. I see plenty of those already.

@Hailinel said:

Who seriously thought she'd follow through?

Follow through for the deadline or the video series?

#12 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@Jams said:

So what exactly happened? I'm not getting much info from a thread that links to another thread.

she missed her deadline and posted something about how she was looking for suggestions.

@TeflonBilly: also you said that they would be shit not that she wouldn't get to it in time, so in your face! lol

#13 Edited by huntad (1941 posts) -

You know what? I had something intelligent posted here, but fuck it. Nevermind.

#14 Posted by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -

@Animasta said:

probably should've had something before hand, to be honest

(also I hope we can all be calm and completely civi- oh who am I kidding)

Shoulda, coulda, woulda.

I've said it was a scam from the start and lo and behold!

#15 Posted by Gladiator_Games (444 posts) -

Hey guys! Remember the ouya?!

#16 Posted by Brandino (254 posts) -

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

#17 Edited by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@TeflonBilly: nah you just kept arguing that they would be shit, never mentioned anything about a scam, and let's be fair here, if it really WAS a scam I highly doubt she'd be asking for suggestions. (she was just unprepared as far as I can tell)

#18 Posted by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@Jams said:

So what exactly happened? I'm not getting much info from a thread that links to another thread.

she missed her deadline and posted something about how she was looking for suggestions.

@TeflonBilly: also you said that they would be shit not that she wouldn't get to it in time, so in your face! lol

Actually, my exact words was that I didn't believe she had the talent or abilities to come through with the project.

I even specifically said that I hoped she would be able to step up to the plate, prove me wrong and actually shed light on a subject I *DO* believe should eb shed a light on. I just wished it was by somebody with more of a deft hand, talent and not such a shitty attitude.

#19 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@TeflonBilly: I don't want to argue about her (but apparently I am forced to because I do not think the worst of her as many people seem to here), I'm just saying innocent until proven guilty. call her lazy all you want but wait until she actually stops responding before calling it a scam.

but apparently I'm a feminazi stereotype so who cares what I think

#20 Posted by Class_A_Ninja (55 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@TeflonBilly: nah you just kept arguing that they would be shit, never mentioned anything about a scam, and let's be fair here, if it really WAS a scam I highly doubt she'd be asking for suggestions.

Maybe Kickstarter's "legally binding" crap after that NPR bit scared her.

I don't doubt that she has the intention to follow through, I just am a little shocked to find out that she didn't have her examples identified and arguments sketched out on a napkin before looking for funding. So the funding was to buy games to research the topic that hopefully would line up with her thesis she already thought up? I don't think that is a good way to make a thesis.

#21 Posted by Commander_Crichton (156 posts) -

Damn! Guess I’ll never get to know just how misogynistic Ico truly is.

#22 Posted by FunExplosions (5407 posts) -

Most of the donated money came from people on Facebook just following the current zeitgeist. They could give a shit about the project's progress this far down the road (greater than 3 days). Lazy campaign for money a great success! I plan to do the same. I mean, if you're stupid enough to fund me, then that's your fault.

#23 Posted by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -

@Class_A_Ninja: Well, it's not like she has a stellar record in knowing what a good thesis is, so I can understand her confusion.

#24 Posted by Dagbiker (6977 posts) -

@Brandino said:

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

I don't want to get into an argument, and responding to sexism with sexism is not right. But her whole kick starter is about sexism. She is cherry picking games that support her view that men are sexist, men make games, and so games are sexist. So she kinda started it.

#25 Posted by FunExplosions (5407 posts) -

I'm going to start a kickstarter for a game based on Ron Paul. I have nothing to show for it (just edited some Megaman and Mario sprites lol). That'll get funded, right? Wait... it totally was.

#26 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@Dagbiker said:

@Brandino said:

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

I don't want to get into an argument, and responding to sexism with sexism is not right. But her whole kick starter is about sexism. She is cherry picking games that support her view that men are sexist, men make games, and so games are sexist. So she kinda started it.

victim blaming huh? call her a lazy asshole, call her a terrible feminist or fuckin whatever, but she did not deserve any of the super horrid responses she got. also that wasn't even close to her points but hey, who really cares? it's time to burn her at the stake for missing a deadlineeeeeeee

#27 Edited by familyphotoshoot (654 posts) -

@Dagbiker: Expect your typical HURR DURR BLAMING THE VICTIM HURR DURR SEXISM HURR DURR MISOGYNY responses.

Frankly, I'm not surprised she hasn't come through with anything. We're talking about a woman whose Master Thesis was about TV shows like Firefly.

#28 Posted by Dagbiker (6977 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@Dagbiker said:

@Brandino said:

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

I don't want to get into an argument, and responding to sexism with sexism is not right. But her whole kick starter is about sexism. She is cherry picking games that support her view that men are sexist, men make games, and so games are sexist. So she kinda started it.

victim blaming huh? call her a lazy asshole, call her a terrible feminist or fuckin whatever, but she did not deserve any of the super horrid responses she got. also that wasn't even close to her points but hey, who really cares? it's time to burn her at the stake for missing a deadlineeeeeeee

I did not say any of that. In fact I said the opposite. I said "responding to sexism with sexism is not right."

#29 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@Dagbiker said:

@Animasta said:

@Dagbiker said:

@Brandino said:

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

I don't want to get into an argument, and responding to sexism with sexism is not right. But her whole kick starter is about sexism. She is cherry picking games that support her view that men are sexist, men make games, and so games are sexist. So she kinda started it.

victim blaming huh? call her a lazy asshole, call her a terrible feminist or fuckin whatever, but she did not deserve any of the super horrid responses she got. also that wasn't even close to her points but hey, who really cares? it's time to burn her at the stake for missing a deadlineeeeeeee

I did not say any of that. In fact I said the opposite. I said "responding to sexism with sexism is not right."

then what does "so she kinda started it" mean, then? That sounds like victim blaming 101 to me, regardless of any other part of your post

#30 Posted by JoeyRavn (4977 posts) -

@TeflonBilly said:

@Class_A_Ninja: Well, it's not like she has a stellar record in knowing what a good thesis is, so I can understand her confusion.

As someone interested in Feminism and popular literature (comic books, mainly) and someone who is currently (technically, right now) working on a dissertation, this is extremely appealing to me. Thanks for posting it. I can't speak about the Kickstarter project itself, because I haven't been following it. What I gather is that she aimed to high, which is a shame. These topics are well worth exploring, but everything has to be done properly.

Also, come on. Justify your text. At least for your Master's Thesis, do the effort.

#31 Posted by DeadVillager (77 posts) -

I'm sure that she'll get around to the videos eventually, but I'm secretly hoping she never does. Not because I want to delight in knowing that I was right and that a lot of people and their money was wrong, but that I don't want to know that $150k is enough to give somebody the authority to publish in-depth analyses and interpretations on the messages behind a large number of current, classic, or otherwise cherished videogames in a manner that, going off of her current track record, will be grossly misinformed or otherwise insulting to the stories or messages that the designers and developers of these games were actually trying to tell, inspiring them to make these games in the first place.

#32 Posted by Deusx (1905 posts) -

@TheHT said:

So she sets up the kickstarter to get financial support for a research project and now wants backers to actually do the research for her too?

le sigh

Le... Don't. just don't.

Seriously now, this is hilarious. She received ALL THAT MONEY and ALL OF THOSE GAMES (300 games) and she couldn't even make one video? Oh wow, I hope that project fails. Look, I love women, you can say all you want "you're a misogynist hur dur" but fuck it, that kickstarter alone created some of the worst drama I've seen surrounding video games. Those videos are not going to help at all. Let that project die like the rest of the feminazis and women hating opinionated fuckers out there. These are video games people. Video games!

#33 Posted by familyphotoshoot (654 posts) -

@Animasta: Do you not understand the concept that sometimes people ARE to blame for what happens to them?

#34 Posted by falserelic (5445 posts) -

A bear can be sexist too.

#35 Posted by BraveToaster (12589 posts) -

Why am I not surprised that she had no back up plan in case the deadline was missed?

#36 Edited by Carousel (418 posts) -

It's funny.

People are still going to defend her.

#37 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta: Do you not understand the concept that sometimes people ARE to blame for what happens to them?

are you really going to argue that she deserved everything she got? that game that was about bruising her, huh? I'm not talking about blame but merely severity. She probably knew that she would get some amount of shit for what she was doing, but what she got was in no way close to what she brought to the table, if you get my meaning.

#38 Posted by Carousel (418 posts) -

@Animasta: "I'm just saying innocent until proven guilty."

You never seem to have this mentality when a man is under the gun.

#39 Edited by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@CaptStickybeard: wardell has proven he was a shithead long before that suit ever happened

#40 Edited by familyphotoshoot (654 posts) -

@Animasta: Are you really going to tell me that she actually suffered because someone made a silly flash game where you can virtually punch a picture of her? Really?

Are you also going to tell me she really needed over $150,000 to do the exact same kind of videos she's been doing for for several years without that kind of funding? It's the cash grab that people are responding negatively to, not the content of the videos. Oh wait, she hasn't even made the videos.

#41 Posted by Hailinel (24975 posts) -
@SuperWristBands Either or both.
Online
#42 Posted by GunslingerPanda (4798 posts) -

Can she go away now? Maybe get a real job instead of preying on idiots and white knights?

#43 Posted by Carousel (418 posts) -

@Animasta: As did Anita. But she confirms your beliefs so you don't think she can be wrong.

#44 Edited by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta: Are you really going to tell me that she actually suffered because someone made a silly flash game where you can virtually punch a picture of her? Really?

Are you also going to tell me she really needed over $150,000 to do the exact same kind of videos she's been doing for for several years without that kind of funding? It's the cash grab that people are responding negatively to, not the content of the videos (which by the way don't even exist yet).

her kickstarter thing was only at like 10k or something for the bare bones shit; reddit and 4chan were to blame for her getting way more money than she needed or even deserved

also if you really don't see how something like that would cause her pain, well, bully for you but that would sure as shit make me suffer.

@CaptStickybeard: read this thread and see if I defended her videos at all

#45 Posted by Mirado (993 posts) -

How she got $160,000 to rename few TV Tropes pages and do a less in depth (and, most likely, more inaccurate) analysis then a free website is beyond me.

That's over $30k per episode to just go and read TV Tropes.

#46 Posted by familyphotoshoot (654 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta: Are you really going to tell me that she actually suffered because someone made a silly flash game where you can virtually punch a picture of her? Really?

Are you also going to tell me she really needed over $150,000 to do the exact same kind of videos she's been doing for for several years without that kind of funding? It's the cash grab that people are responding negatively to, not the content of the videos (which by the way don't even exist yet).

reddit and 4chan were to blame for her getting way more money than she needed or even deserved

What in the actual fuck are you talking about? Do you honestly believe that 4chan gave her money? Are you insane?

#47 Posted by Dagbiker (6977 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@Dagbiker said:

@Animasta said:

@Dagbiker said:

@Brandino said:

Although i am disgusted at the way people acted towards this whole kickstarter project and her youtube (all the horribly sexist and ignorant comments) the whole thing sounded ridiculous and it doesn't surprise me one bit that she didn't go through with it. It's also the reason i don't back anything on kickstarter.

I don't want to get into an argument, and responding to sexism with sexism is not right. But her whole kick starter is about sexism. She is cherry picking games that support her view that men are sexist, men make games, and so games are sexist. So she kinda started it.

victim blaming huh? call her a lazy asshole, call her a terrible feminist or fuckin whatever, but she did not deserve any of the super horrid responses she got. also that wasn't even close to her points but hey, who really cares? it's time to burn her at the stake for missing a deadlineeeeeeee

I did not say any of that. In fact I said the opposite. I said "responding to sexism with sexism is not right."

then what does "so she kinda started it" mean, then? That sounds like victim blaming 101 to me, regardless of any other part of your post

What I'm saying, is that, regardless of how people should act. When people feel like they are being attacked they will retaliate.

#48 Posted by Animasta (14698 posts) -

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta said:

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta: Are you really going to tell me that she actually suffered because someone made a silly flash game where you can virtually punch a picture of her? Really?

Are you also going to tell me she really needed over $150,000 to do the exact same kind of videos she's been doing for for several years without that kind of funding? It's the cash grab that people are responding negatively to, not the content of the videos (which by the way don't even exist yet).

reddit and 4chan were to blame for her getting way more money than she needed or even deserved

What in the actual fuck are you talking about? Do you honestly believe that 4chan gave her money? Are you insane?

4chan and reddit's way too harsh trolling of her caused other people who wouldn't have donated to donate, whether due to increased exposure, guilt or what, I can't really say but it's quite easy to see if you look at the graph.

#49 Posted by TheHT (11385 posts) -

@Animasta said:

@familyphotoshoot said:

@Animasta: Do you not understand the concept that sometimes people ARE to blame for what happens to them?

are you really going to argue that she deserved everything she got? that game that was about bruising her, huh? I'm not talking about blame but merely severity. She probably knew that she would get some amount of shit for what she was doing, but what she got was in no way close to what she brought to the table, if you get my meaning.

so you agree that what she brought to the table was terrible?

#50 Edited by TeflonBilly (4713 posts) -

@JoeyRavn said:

As someone interested in Feminism and popular literature (comic books, mainly) and someone who is currently (technically, right now) working on a dissertation, this is extremely appealing to me. Thanks for posting it. I can't speak about the Kickstarter project itself, because I haven't been following it. What I gather is that she aimed to high, which is a shame. These topics are well worth exploring, but everything has to be done properly.

Also, come on. Justify your text. At least for your Master's Thesis, do the effort.

That's really cool. May I ask which comics you wanna focus on? Obviously you have to touch upon Gail Simone and her Women In the Refrigerator deal, that was seminal.

Also the Sue Dibny/Dr. Light rape and the utter gross fiasco that Identity Crisis was for teh entire DC Universe.

Cereberus is a great look at Dave Sim's genius devolving into mysoginistic insanity over the years.

Strangers In Paradise and The Maxx have great female characters who truly stand out as original three dimensional characters who don't fit in any tropes.

And you can take a look at how the whole Girl Power scene of comics has grown with Tank Girl and Grrl Scouts.