Uncharted or Heavenly Sword?

Just got a call from my girlfriend asking whether to buy Uncharted or Heavenly Sword. I told her Uncharted, because I'd heard good things about it, and since we gave Heavenly Sword a rental and the two hours we spent trying it out didn't really wow me. So this might come a little late, but given the same choice, which game would you have picked?

I would've picked Uncharted. Heavenly sword was only ever really known because of the tech it used at the time. The gameplay was sort of weak. Uncharted is the way to go

Uncharted. All I remember from Heavenly Sword is hair and the half-nekkid lady.

Uncharted, buy Uncharted 2 as well.

Uncharted. Never played Heavenly Sword, but Uncharted is great.

@Yanngc33 said:

I would've picked Uncharted. Heavenly sword was only ever really known because of the tech it used at the time. The gameplay was sort of weak. Uncharted is the way to go

I haven't played Heavenly Sword, but I kind of feel this way about Uncharted.

I loved Uncharted.

Uncharted is a better game but I loved Heavenly Sword

Uncharted. It's actually still a fun and playable game.

Uncharted is the better choice for sure. Although the characters and their animation (especailly during the cutscenes) were pretty amazing in HS. HS also had Kai.... TWING TWANG~!

Heavenly Sword's gameplay wasn't that bad; I enjoyed my time with it. That said, I still prefer Uncharted.

Uncharted is way in the lead. I'm somewhat relieved. It seems by suggestion was not ill-advised.

Uncharted is too obvious an answer to even give it a second thought. Now if the choice was between Uncharted and Killzone 2 that could be trickier. Heavenly Sword didn't feel right to me, I guess my expectations for it back then were too high as I was hoping it would be the (back then) next generation God of War.

I kinda like both, but then again I know that launch titles aren't perfect.

Valkyria Chronicles

As much as I like Heavenly Sword, think it's worth a play, and wish for a sequel, I'd say Uncharted.

@shootermcclay said:

Valkyria Chronicles

This lol.

But yeah, both are fantastic games. Heavenly Sword should not be discounted, it was fun.

I liked Heavenly Sword but Uncharted was definitely better.

Uncharted is better but still has issues. Uncharted 2 is massively better and much of the foundation of it comes from the first game. Heavenly Sword has more issues but it's still worth playing.