This fucking game, man.
I was super excited by everything I saw and read about this game prior to actually playing it. I like adventure games and puzzle games. I loved the old Sierra and Lucas Arts adventure games, played all of the Myst games, etc... But when I brought L.A. Noire home and put it in my Xbox something just failed to click. The story was interesting, everything about the gameplay was technically solid, but I just found it... boring.
What about you? What are some games you were looking forward to that you ended up not liking at all?