#1 Posted by Emandudeguyperson (2750 posts) -
#2 Posted by Vinchenzo (6464 posts) -

They are simply amazing. If you say otherwise I expect a real response instead of "You don't get anything for them."

#3 Posted by Emandudeguyperson (2750 posts) -

Getting acheivements in games makes me feel like a peice of shit. Why would you put acheivements in a game like Eternal Sonata? Or Ghost Recon: Advanced Warfighter? Or Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion? It just doesn't make much sense to me. It makes me feel as if Microsoft is using it as a ploy to get people to buy their games.

#4 Posted by Teh_Eel (302 posts) -

I feel they ruin my experience with the game as I have to go out of my way and get them instead of enjoying the game.

#5 Posted by JazzyJeff (463 posts) -

They're not a huge part of gaming for me, but that's because I know I'll never be able to compete with people and their huge score. I think it's great for people who are into competition or get that rewarding feeling when they see the "Achievement Unlocked" graphic appear.

Don't have a problem with them, but could live without 'em.

#6 Posted by Azteck (7416 posts) -

I love them, or I love seeing "Achievement Unlocked" followed by that "Pu-lump-sound"

I don't go out of my way to get them on my first playthrough, I just like getting them as I go along. In fact, I don't even go back to get them that often, it's just recently since Giant Bomb started the achievement rating.

#7 Posted by ADDTasty (114 posts) -

I love 'em. As someone who normally never plays a game more than one time through, they add a lot of incentive for me to keep playing a game even after i might have finished it.

#8 Posted by Insectecutor (1220 posts) -
@Teh_Eel said:
" I feel they ruin my experience with the game as I have to go out of my way and get them instead of enjoying the game. "
You don't have to. If they ruin your experience why bother? I just ignore them and when I get one it's a nice surprise. I don't think the achievements/trophies you can get should be visible until you get them. The way they are now they're challenges, not achievements.
#9 Posted by VisariLoyalist (3092 posts) -

they're the most idiotic things ever invented

#10 Posted by cc23574 (665 posts) -

Depends on the achievement, I like the achievements were you really have to something for it, I hate those achievements you get for completing an level. Sure it helps my virtual penis......ehh I mean gamerscore to grow, but I want to get the feeling that I accomplished something. So from your poll, I'm okay with them.

#11 Posted by natetodamax (19421 posts) -

This is the second time I've suggested you use the search bar. I'm pretty sure there was a thread like this a few days ago.

#12 Posted by ImperiousRix (3095 posts) -

I like achievements.  On my first playthrough, I really don't look at them or attempt to do anything crazy to get them.  However, I feel they really aid replay value and provide some form of "checkpoint" system that was missing before.
Some games can be long and turn into a grind.  With achievements, you always feel like you're accomplishing something, and when you get those "accidental" ones, it feels like a testament of your skills.

#13 Posted by Weltal (2302 posts) -

They are enjoyable. As far as I can tell the only people that dislike them think they matter somehow.

#14 Posted by Bob_Toeback (323 posts) -

They are only there to say "Look, I am better than you... I have more achievments" and just to make games more replayable, and you should be able to do these things without achievments. I don't really see a point to them myself =/

#15 Posted by PeasForFees (2415 posts) -

They are okay but, they encourage games which are absolute garbage, out of all the games half or even more are most probably garbage and a waste of time.

#16 Posted by Pazy (2683 posts) -

They really annoy me, partially because of people e-penis issues about it but also because it takes me out of the experience. The amount of times ive been really enjoying a game then the "acheivment unlocked" graphic comes up with the sound as well, then I look around and go "oh ye, I was playing a game". I ended up telling it not to show them on my 360, on Steam games with acheivments like Team Fortress 2 Ive left them on because I feel they are better integrated in to the game and the style of game that im playing it dosent take me out of the game (or if it does it dosent matter).

I also hate the fact that they arent equal, like Avatar on 360 versus the points in the Orange Box (360 version). They end up barely feeling like achievments. 

The last complain really is that most achievments feel like they are patting me on the head and saying "Good Boy, heres a biscuit". I really dont need to be told that I done well by finishing a level, I already feel my own sense of achievment or perhaps lack of (because of a shoddy game).

#17 Posted by SmugDarkLoser (5041 posts) -

Depends on game.  I screw them off in rpgs but not the case in action games or shooters.

And Paxy, you realize it's the unlocking of an achievement that is the fun, not getting points for it?  And as far as totals, it's getting them all in a particular game, not just any game. 
It's like an unlock challenge system that's required in every game and is unified.  That's damn good and I think I speak for the majority when I say gamers like to unlock things and ber completiionists.

#18 Edited by Hitchenson (4708 posts) -

I love achievements. I feel that they add great replay value to a game, and get me to do things I necessarily wouldn't normally try to do otherwise.

#19 Posted by Pazy (2683 posts) -
@SmugDarkLoser said:
 And Paxy, you realize it's the unlocking of an achievement that is the fun, not getting points for it?  
I dont really like either, points feel patronising and the idea of following this seperate path in order to get an "acheivment" feels pointless to me since I complete all this and all I get is a pat on the back and a way to prove to people I got a pat on the pack. When I do something interesting in-game the only reward I value is my own sense of acomplishment, a new character or place worth interacting with or perhaps a new weapons. The achievments are too seperated from the game to be worthwhile to me in anyway.
#20 Posted by AgentJ (8994 posts) -

I think its kind of fun to see how much people have played with certain games, and have leaderboards for gamerpoints and stuff. So "love em".

#21 Edited by Jeust (11601 posts) -

i'm okay with them... I don't really care, and never go out of my way to get them, but sometimes looking at them gives me new ways of enjoying myself, and experiencing the game. 

For me it's a bit forced, that kind of trophees, since you don't really win anything but those 5 seconds when a popup shows. Generally it just brings an additional forced longevity to the game.

I just play for fun...