#1 Posted by ChillyUK7 (305 posts) -

Ive started this topic because after playing Mafia 2 which is a great game but has limited replay value, so collecting the playboy mags, wanted posters and getting achievments is what's keeping me playing it for now, that and the epic shootouts in missions like The Buzzsaw and Room Service.
 
I was wondering what extras do you like to see in games, specifically single player, is it concept art, different costumes, challenge levels etc? and which game/s do you think have done it right?

#2 Posted by WoodenPlatypus (1389 posts) -

How abouuut. Crazy ass wannabe pornographic dance video at the end of Bayonetta? 
That is one of the best from a 360 game. 
#3 Posted by MysteriousBob (6262 posts) -

The only time I'll replay a game is if it'll be significantly different like playing Fallout 3 with different decisions.

#4 Posted by PenguinDust (12773 posts) -

I like alternate costumes, but on the same token I hate unlocking crap so I am kind of at a crossroad as far as that's concerned.  The most appealing thing to me, at least for single-player is being able to play the main campaign again with a different character.  I think Ninja Gaiden did that in one of its numerous variations.  Maybe it wouldn't make sense storywise, but since it's your second (or later) play-through that shouldn't be a huge consideration.  It'd probably take a lot of work though in some situation for the game developer, so it's not feasible for every type of game. 

#5 Posted by carlthenimrod (1604 posts) -

New Game Plus.
 
Let me play the game again over again super-powered, I don't care if it makes the game broken. I love games like Shadow Complex or RE 5 that let you play again with things carried over. It also encourages playing again on higher difficulty levels.

#6 Posted by MattBosten (511 posts) -

New Game +
Also things like Bioshocks audio diaries!

#7 Posted by ChillyUK7 (305 posts) -
@carlthenimrod:  Yeah I loved Ratchet and Clank for that, technically the difficulty level goes up after your first playthrough but it didn't feel like it due to the upgraded weapons and armour.
#8 Posted by Wes (270 posts) -

Bonus levels are the best incentive to keep playing, but they take a long time to make in comparison to concept art and collectibles. Costumes are also good, especially if they're ridiculous like Uncharted and Uncharted 2's "Doughnut Drake."

#9 Posted by Brodehouse (10487 posts) -

Resident Evil 5 is the clear example that everyone should follow.

#10 Posted by Coombs (3507 posts) -

Depends on the game, 
RPGs give me a New Game+  (Tales of Vesperia)
Fighters give me TONS of unlockable costume stuff (Tekken 6) 
Racing Games give me TONS of cars to buy and upgrade (Forza) 
Sandbox Games give me TONS of collectibles ( Just Cause 2) 
FPS give me an online leveling System that actually determines the caliber of player I face (Battlefield MC: 2) 
Platformers give me...... I don't know, Do platformers have replay value? 

#11 Posted by Jasta (2232 posts) -
@WoodenPlatypus said:
" How abouuut. Crazy ass wannabe pornographic dance video at the end of Bayonetta? That is one of the best from a 360 game.  "

I completed it last night and that video blew my mind.
#12 Posted by ZanzibarBreeze (3205 posts) -

Here it is:
 

Commentary.

#13 Posted by Redbullet685 (6186 posts) -

Commentary. Like Valve games and Super Monkey Island 2 SE did.
Costumes
New Game +
Bonus Game modes that are unlocked after beating the game or entering a code.

#14 Edited by zero2000 (73 posts) -

My favorite collectibles in a game is definitely the dog tags in MGS2. Dog tags for nearly every enemy on every difficulty level. You had to change up your strategy multiple times, and approach enemies in often unique ways to obtain the dog tags. Especially on the harder difficulties.
 
So in general, I like any collectible that are actually interesting to get, seeing as I am a completionist. Rather than just the usual "boringly look at every nook and cranny for collectibles". If these collectibles unlock anything, that is an extra bonus, but I like to get them just to....get them all.
 
Besides that, I like stuff such as new weapons, costumes, skins, New Game +. Anything that might make the 2nd or 3rd playthrough more enjoyable.

#15 Posted by Yummylee (23197 posts) -

Collectibles, though not hidden like a needles in haystacks like those bleedin' pigeons in GTAIV -_-. Unlockable costumes I always love to have rooting for. Weapons, and if the games a little on the arcade side, some extra characters too. Or at least character skins to add some improvised comedy like in the Uncharted series. Basically Saints Row 2 is the definition of what I want in the way of unlockables <3

#16 Posted by bartok (2640 posts) -

Toss up between the episode with Patrick Stewart or Daniel Radcliffe. I love Extras and love how Ricky Gervais doesn't run his shows into the ground just 2 seasons and an hour long special to wrap them up.

#17 Posted by TheGreatGuero (8882 posts) -
@ChillyUK7 said:
" @carlthenimrod:  Yeah I loved Ratchet and Clank for that, technically the difficulty level goes up after your first playthrough but it didn't feel like it due to the upgraded weapons and armour. "
I just wish that the difficulty would have kept increasing each and every time you complete it. Like if the 3rd, 4th, 5th, and so on playthroughs would keep getting harder and harder, I probably would have kept playing the game as long as I could.
#18 Posted by tourgen (4568 posts) -
i liked the audio logs in Batman.  The challenge rooms in Portal were very good.  The commentary for Portal was good too except for the voice actress bits.
 
My favorite extras are things that add to the story of the game or fill in some sub-plots.  The Codex in Mass Effect was fantastic and probably the best example I can think of.  A close second is challenge rooms or challenge modes.  Take the original encounter and ramp it up to extra hard, crank AI reaction times if it's a shooter, make the floor lava if it's a 3D platformer, etc.  Award something for completion.
#19 Posted by ChillyUK7 (305 posts) -
@Coombs said:
" Platformers give me...... I don't know, Do platformers have replay value?  "
Not sure about most platformers but Ratchet and Clank allows you to play through the game again on a higher difficulty but u keep all ur weapons/armour etc to upgrade, one of the few games I would replay over and over.
#20 Posted by sodiumCyclops (2778 posts) -

For some reason, this thread makes me wanna play more of Ratchet And Clank: A Crack in Time

#21 Posted by ChillyUK7 (305 posts) -
@sodiumCyclops:  Me too i've not finished it yet but can remeber there's a big challenge room thing, it's white and contains unlockables like artwork n stuff.
#22 Posted by Coombs (3507 posts) -
@ChillyUK7:  
Sure, I guess Newgame+ would work for platformers
#23 Posted by FirePrince (1772 posts) -
@WoodenPlatypus said:
"How abouuut. Crazy ass wannabe pornographic dance video at the end of Bayonetta? That is one of the best from a 360 game.  "

4 friends were at my house when we witnessed that.
#24 Posted by JJOR64 (19541 posts) -

I love games that let my bring my goods/gained abilities to the next difficulty level like Devil May Cry.

#25 Posted by iam3green (14368 posts) -

unlock ables to make the game replayable. resident evil 4 and 5 are great examples of it. it was pretty short game but make them a little bit longer. i enjoyed playing that game over and over. i think i beat it like 4 times. 
 
i also enjoy different endings and clips of developers making the game or talking about the game.

#26 Posted by killersneakers (19 posts) -

i will never replay a game, i am some kind of adventure-seeker

#27 Edited by ChillyUK7 (305 posts) -
@iam3green:  Yeah Making Of vids are usually quite rare for games but you get them for movies all the time, Uncharted 1/2 had good Making Of  vids.
#28 Posted by Mrnitropb (2131 posts) -
@ZanzibarBreeze said:
" Here it is:
 

Commentary.

"
Dude, yes! commentary nodes or tracks should be in a lot more games. If for no other reason than to hear some designer go, "yeah sorry about this part, not sure why it sucks so hard."