the Amy "controversy" as it were has brought up a lot of fervor so far on the interwebs, with IGN and other critics receiving it rather poorly. I know a lot of people are playing Amy saying "it's not that bad," some people ( a few) even going so far as saying they love it.
Looking back, I can think of a few games that were received rather poorly, which I actually absolutely adore. Shenmue, Omikron: The Nomad Soul, even Advent Rising.
What games do you secretly love that were critically blasted (and I mean ripped to friggen shreds) and why?