I'd be interested in seeing what people think were the most controversial, official Giant Bomb reviews. Reading through review comments full of debate, anger and frustration is really fun and I'd be interested in seeing anything I missed.
Inspiration for this thread came from Brad's recent Resident Evil 6 review and the comment section underneath. Then I thought back to Jeff's Catherine review, which has more than double that of RE6's current amount of comments and which I'd say was probably the most controversial review on GB. The comment section linked to Jeff's BlazBlue: Calamity Trigger review is also a fun read.