#1 Posted by BeachThunder (13365 posts) -

It doesn't necessarily have to be a new release game, it just needs to be new to you (so you could play a game from a decade ago, which then becomes your new all time favourite).

Personally, the last time I got a new favourite game was when Braid (PC) was released; so, that would have been April 2009. Before that it would have been Bioshock.

So, when was the last time a game took over your previous #1 spot? What was it?

#2 Posted by DoctorDanger99 (745 posts) -

probly WWE '13. for me it was the first wrestling game i had really played in close to a decade and since release ive probly put a few dozen hours if not more into it.

#3 Posted by FancySoapsMan (5885 posts) -

3 years ago, when I first played Persona 3: FES

nothing else has come close since

#4 Posted by thisguyrich (98 posts) -

Similarly to FancySoapsMan Persona 3 became my favourite 4 or 5 years ago (whenever it came out). I put like 100 hours into that game and I never do that. Closest I've come since has got to be Burnout Paradise which coincidentally is my 2nd favourite game.

#5 Posted by MonsieurSpy (9 posts) -

12 Years ago,when I first encountered the beautiful beast called Deus Ex.

#6 Posted by PandaBear (1484 posts) -

Battlefield 3 ... started playing in December 2011. Sue me.

#7 Posted by ervonymous (1299 posts) -

Others can't touch it so it's not fair, but Tales of Vesperia is my favorite of this generation.

#8 Posted by spexeh (19 posts) -

I'm still chasing my original Counter-Strike high. I am a console gamer these days, but I really think that the lack of dedicated servers typical of matchmaking-oriented games leaves players without a "home" and discourages online community building. Yeah, yeah, I know you can play with your friends at any time, but there's definitely a benefit to joining the same server every day and playing with a "local" crowd.

#9 Posted by Zekhariah (700 posts) -

Mass Effect 2 probably (played in 2011). It was the first time I had played a well done cinematic game, so there was some extent of impact like the games I had played a few decade ago.

#10 Posted by DoctorDanger99 (745 posts) -

@PandaBear: ive tried so fucking hard to give that game a shot. but aafter the mess that was the launch and other issues ive had, i just cant like it. id really like to. i think the idead of battlefield is amazing. i just wish sombody else besides DICE would make the game. they are like Obsidian. they come up with really good ideas, but are piss poor developers who make buggy and unfinished games.

#11 Posted by Little_Socrates (5834 posts) -

This year, actually. Just not sure if it was the new release or the older one yet, and if either really tops Super Meat Boy.

#12 Posted by TheFreeMan (2712 posts) -

Uncharted 2, which I played in 2010. It's still got what I consider to be the most satisfying shooting out of any TPS I've ever played, and the story and characters and more adventure-y aspects hit all the right buttons.

#13 Edited by GetEveryone (4532 posts) -

About the time I realised I'd been playing SF every day for a month.

Before that, it was speed-running through Metroid Fusion repeatedly.

Earliest was probably reading absolutely every snippet I could about Shadowman pre-release, totally devouring the lore, then playing the fucking shit out of it as a 10 year-old. That game was the tits.

#14 Posted by K9 (642 posts) -

The Assassins Creed franchise as whole for me. Although the story has been dragging on for a bit too long for my taste I really enjoyed playing through the whole Assassins Creed 2 Ezio trilogy. Plus, this is the only open world game where I find the combat to be fun and enjoy just goofing around randomly stabbing people.

#15 Posted by Marcsman (3381 posts) -

This generation. Motorstorm

#16 Posted by Jack268 (3368 posts) -

I played MGS2 10 years ago and couldn't deal with the wonky controls but playing it in the HD collection back in February definitely made it one of my favorite games.

#17 Posted by CookieMonster (2502 posts) -

Probably Paper mario 64 whatever year it was released

#18 Edited by phrosnite (3511 posts) -

Mine were:

  • Dungeon Siege 2 - 2006 until december 2009
  • Dragon Age: Origins - december 2009 until april 2012
  • Mass Effect 1,2 & 3 - april 2012 until ???

Yeah, before 2006 I never thought about a game being my all-time favourite.

#19 Posted by ZeForgotten (10368 posts) -

This generation it's probably the Assassin's Creed games. 
Before that though, probably Final Fantasy 8 when that came out. 

#20 Edited by RedCream (779 posts) -
#21 Posted by Catarrhal (869 posts) -

It was back in the year 2000, when Shenmue was released. Yes, I'm one of those people…

#22 Posted by BBAlpert (1886 posts) -

I don't know if I'd quite call either of them my All-Time Favorites, but I really, really liked Orcs Must Die 1 and Hotline Miami.

#23 Posted by SirOptimusPrime (2038 posts) -

The closest I've come lately has been Dark Souls, but I haven't had a game dethrone Baldur's Gate II since 2003. I was a little young to 'get' the D&D games when they first came out but when I snapped up my dad's collection back then BGII stuck.

I'm willing for something to beat it, because I don't want to be the nostalgia-tripper, it's just that I really haven't come across a game better than it.

#24 Posted by TeflonBilly (4742 posts) -

The perfect storm that was Persona 4. I started watching the ER when it began and after 10 episodes or so I got it myself, dusted off the PS2 and went to town and got past where the guys got. I finished it way before the ER ended, but the combination of experiencing how fantastic that game was, watching Jeff and Vinny play it their way and the way the community turned it into a very zeitgeisty thing made it an extra special experience.

The exact same thing happened with Deadly Premonition.

#25 Posted by mikey87144 (2011 posts) -

Skyrim, Oblivion, and GTA Vice City all occupy that space but I can't rank them.

#26 Edited by Jeust (11601 posts) -

Bulletstorm last month. It was the best experience I had in singleplayer with a first person shooter. A captivating and funny ride, with interesting and mysterious locales, great gameplay and humour. Nothing topples it for me.

#27 Posted by AltonBrown (967 posts) -

Persona 4. Loved P3, but 4 just grabbed me more, I guess.

#28 Edited by Canteu (2920 posts) -

9 Years ago when Dark Chronicle came out.

and for serious, this gen probably dark souls.

#29 Posted by crusader8463 (14756 posts) -

I added XCom the most recently, but before that it was Dragon Age: Origins, L4D 1/2, KOTOR and Evil Genius.

#30 Posted by jewunit (1091 posts) -

Super Street Fighter IV definitely hooked me hard and would chart on my all-time list. I think Ghost Trick and the second Phoenix Wright game would as well. I really do love Capcom and the games they make.

#31 Edited by Bobby_The_Great (1089 posts) -

All-time favorite recently would have to be Demons/Dark Souls. That'll be a classic I can always come back to many years from now.

Dragon Age: Origins, all 3 Uncharted games, Super Street Fighter IV, Mortal Kombat (2011), and a few other fighting games I'll add as well.

#32 Posted by Azteck (7416 posts) -

Mass Effect 1

#33 Posted by Freqtal (107 posts) -

I think it will have to be Read Dead Redemption.

#34 Posted by Scarlet_Rogue (534 posts) -

When Mega Man 2 came out.

#35 Posted by TheWyotee93 (202 posts) -

Dark Souls actually. I dont know what it is about that game that gets me but it does

#36 Posted by Stonyman65 (3097 posts) -

Fallout 2

Metal Gear Solid

Deus Ex

Resident Evil 4

Saint's Row The Third

#37 Posted by AlexW00d (6829 posts) -

MGS, 14 years ago.

#38 Posted by pyromagnestir (4391 posts) -

Portal/Portal 2. Those games are pretty much my ideal video games.

#39 Posted by believer258 (13046 posts) -

Chrono Trigger, this past summer.

#40 Posted by Animasta (14827 posts) -

Nier probably; Hotline Miami came close, as did Binary Domain, but...

#41 Posted by BaneFireLord (3105 posts) -

When I played Oblivion for the first time back in '08.

#42 Posted by EquitasInvictus (2072 posts) -

The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

I bought it twice, for the pc the second time around, and with all the variations of playthroughs I enjoyed over hundreds of hours including DLC, the Shivering Isles expansion, and mods, it probably holds the record for the most time I've spent on a game.

#43 Posted by MordeaniisChaos (5904 posts) -

Mass Effect, only the original. After that, it was Dragon Age, Origins only. Now, it's probably Skyrim. But really all three are essentially tied as they are all pretty different.

#44 Posted by fuzzypumpkin (418 posts) -

MGS3 when it came out and then Bioshock on X360 when it came out. I dunno though, Final Fantasy VIII holds a very special place in my heart still.

#45 Posted by Palmlykta (236 posts) -

In about 2005 when I played Metal Gear 2 for MSX. Very anachronistic of me. Then again me and the modern games industry is kinda going our separate ways so yeah... I'm one of those persons.

#46 Posted by Bell_End (1234 posts) -

judging by that GTV trailer.... soon

#47 Posted by Fredchuckdave (7736 posts) -

12+ years ago, Vagrant Story

#48 Posted by Kerned (1183 posts) -

It's hard for me to ever nail down an "all-time favorite," but I think Dark Souls is the most recent game to come close. Prior to playing that I would have said the original Deus Ex without any hesitation.

#49 Posted by BjornTheUnicorn (375 posts) -

2010 brought Rock Band 3, Mass Effect 2, Mario Galaxy 2, and Kirby's Epic Yarn, which all rank very highly among my favorites.

#50 Edited by probablytuna (4272 posts) -

Mass Effect 2 probably, so 2010.