#1 Posted by BlueLantern1995 (142 posts) -

#2 Posted by crazyleaves (666 posts) -

Which do you like THE MOST?!

#3 Posted by Colourful_Hippie (4833 posts) -

First one. The second one plays a lot better but I preferred the Zelda-esque structure of the first game.

#4 Posted by laserbolts (5444 posts) -

First one I found the second to be a huge disappointment. Couldn't wait for it either. Fuck.

#5 Posted by Nottle (1931 posts) -

I've only played the first one so I didn't vote. But isn't the 2nd one better in every way? How is it less of a zelda game?

#6 Posted by GunstarRed (5796 posts) -

I really liked the first game and was left pretty underwhelmed by the second.

#7 Posted by poheroe (158 posts) -

first one for sure.

#8 Posted by MetalMoog (969 posts) -

I've only played the first one but voted for it anyway. :D

#9 Posted by WarlordPayne (709 posts) -

I loved the first one and was pretty disappointed with the second one. D2 improved a fair amount of the gameplay but there was no story to hold everything together, so the whole game felt like one tedious sidequest after another, even when you were playing the main story quests.

#10 Posted by Getz (3344 posts) -

Yeah, I was really impressed with the second game for the first few parts and my enthusiasm slowly waned as I played. By the end I was left with a mostly ambivalent thumbs-up. First game was more engaging.

#11 Posted by PillClinton (3352 posts) -

Darksiders the First.

#12 Posted by CJduke (845 posts) -

First one

#13 Posted by MooseyMcMan (11948 posts) -

The second one. But only just barely.

#14 Posted by sins_of_mosin (1713 posts) -

First one by a long long ways.

#15 Posted by habster3 (3618 posts) -

Second? Wow, I'm certainly in the minority here

#16 Posted by theuselessgod (339 posts) -

I feel the second one had too much stuff and spread itself too thin. The first was very tight and solid and thus felt like a complete experience. Darksiders 2 has everything and the kitchen sink and, while I'm impressed they actually made a game that worked, felt a bit loose because of it.

I do think the platforming/traversal in 2 is leagues above 1, though. But I still prefer 1.

#17 Posted by NoobSauceG7 (1327 posts) -

I really did not like one that much. I love 2 a lot. I like the loot and the combat much more and there are still great dungeons.